Evans, Arthur J.
Scripta minoa: the written documents of minoan Crete with special reference to the archives of Knossos (Band 1): The hieroglyphic and primitive linear classes
— Oxford, 1909
Zitieren dieser Seite
Bitte zitieren Sie diese Seite, indem Sie folgende Adresse (URL)/folgende DOI benutzen:
https://doi.org/10.11588/diglit.806#0032
DOI Seite / Zitierlink:
https://doi.org/10.11588/diglit.806#0032
Titelblatt
Preface
V
The aim of the present publication is to give in the first place a Corpus
…
many German scholars. In extending to the word of Minos (iv. c. 60, § 25). As I have pointed out
VI
For these reasons the First Part of the present volume has been devoted
…
la Civilisation minoemte), the term ' Minoan' has at
…
going to oppose the view that Minos I or II had any
VII
had puzzled the antiquaries of those days.
…
The Second Part of the present volume concerns the hieroglyphic script
VIII
In Section 8 is given a complete list of the Cretan hieroglyphs as at
…
be taken to represent official titles, and are principally found on the signets.
IX
the Philistines are grouped, and within whose orbit, later on, the Achaeans
…
My most cordial thanks are also due to Prof. Federico Halbherr, the
…
venture to take full advantage of the permission so liberally accorded.
…
who, by subscribing to the Cretan Exploration Fund, initiated in 1899, have
Contents
XI
THE PRE-PHOENICIAN SCRIPTS OF CRETE. THEIR MEDITERRANEAN RELA-
…
THE HIEROGLYPHIC OR CONVENTIONALIZED PICTOGRAPHIC SCRIPT OF
…
5 2. Protodynastic Egyptian and Egypto-Libyan Influences on Cretan Seal-stones . . . 118
…
§ 8. Catalogue of Conventionalized Pictographic (or Hieroglyphic) Inscriptions on Clay Sealings,
…
§ 10. Analysis of the Hieroglyphic or Conventionalized Pictographic Signary .... 234
…
THE PHAESTOS DISK .............273-293
List of tables / List of plates
XII
I. Signs on Vase from Orchomenos compared with Cretan........ 57
…
IV. Comparisons between Lycian and Carian Signs and those of the Cypriote Syllabary . . 76
…
VII. Comparison of the Greek Complementary Letters with South Semitic and Minoan Forms . 92
…
XXIV. Signs on Phaestos Disk.............. 276
…
Pictographic (or Hieroglyphic) Script, Class A.
I. The pre-phoenician scripts of Crete. Their mediterranean relations and place in Minoan story
1
THE PRE-PHOENICIAN SCRIPTS OF CRETE. THEIR
…
the fact that the classical civilization of Greece had been centuries before preceded absent"2
…
and Aegean Script (London, Quaritch, 1898, and /. H. S., in a tomb at Pronoia, near Nauplia. The vase has three
…
xvii). handles, on each of which is incised the sign H, but with
…
3 Tsuntas, MumjiMi, p. 113; Tsuntas and Manatt, op. cit., observes (p. 215) that the amphora was of Egyptian form,
2
the ruins of a house on the Acropolis at Mycenae, showed four or five characters
…
Fig. 1. Wall-painting in the Grotte de Marsoulas,
…
p. 985. In describing the marks on the Knossian blocks,
…
Waffen, p. 14a) that certain curvilinear designs below the
3
not seem to form words' and that they are perhaps nothing more than the
…
Was this great early civilization, then, altogether dumb ? Were the builders of Contrary
…
clear. The germs of written communication must have long pre-existed a^esm it,yt°f earIy
…
moreover at times appear with signs {Fig. i) or marks of ownership, and the law of
4
such signs appearing on a horse's flank.1 Similar characters occur in connexion
…
to pictorial prototypes. Thus a Table recently published by the Abb6 Breuil,5 here
5
geographical configuration of our quarter of the globe alike have changed since
…
stones, either carved or painted in the same manner
…
records—painted on rocks ' with a red, indelible colour',
…
a curious resemblance to some of the rock-carvings of
…
uncertainty (to say the least) attaches to some of the
6
which extend into the Sahara region and find their analogies in the rock-carvings
…
due to the decay of decorative elements, themselves of skeuomorphic origin. Others,
…
their bearing on the evolution of later syllabaries and alphabets. But the attempt
…
5 For a review of the literature regarding the Mera-
…
actions of the International Congress of Prehist. Arch., 1868,
…
Explorations in the Regions of the Prehistoric Rock Engrav-
…
made by him, on the spot, with the kind permission of
…
together with detailed comparisons between the pottery-
7
language did not sufficiently take into account the very early stage in this
…
rude linear figures on the Neolithic and Early Metal Age pottery of Hissarlik and Jraphs^not
…
already been attained. .Such graffiti must be taken in connexion with the general
…
it has taken place, whether in Chaldaea, Egypt, or China, or among the Aztecs and
…
within it {cf. Alias trojcmischer Alterth&mer, Nos. 2504, reduces the original elements of the 400 cuneiform signs
8
Mayas of ancient Mexico and Yucatan, we are able to trace the handiwork of
…
acquired in a practical form in 1889. In that year a four-sided bead-seal of cornelian, bearing on
…
to the Ashmolean Museum by that well-known antiquarian traveller the late Mr. Greville
9
Hittite characters, and in particular the identity of the wolfs (or dog's) head showing
…
An objection, however, to the first alternative was to be found in the fact that no Reasons
…
It was not long before decisive evidence came under my observation. In the Further
…
a Cretan source.1 Knowing of the considerable collection of 'island' and other early
…
evidence. At a meeting of the Hellenic Society, on November 27, 1893/ I was thus Existence
10
The evidence conclusively pointed to Crete as the principal source of these
…
making a house-to-house visitation in the villages, to obtain a knowledge of a large
11
A summary account of the results of this first campaign in Crete was published
…
to the Hellenic Society in November of the latter year a considerable mass of
…
the Athenaum (June 23) and the Times (Aug. 29), 1894.
12
graffiti on
…
in the same Cretan region. Here it may be
…
graphic kind (see Fig. 5, a, b, c3}, which supply the
13
together with clay human figures of a type that characterizes the votive deposits, like
…
preserved for us in the subjects of the signets and wall-paintings both of Minoan Crete
…
upon the top of a sacred cone or pillar in the manner shown in Fig. 7.* Its great baityao2.
…
1 Preliminary investigations of this cave, resulting in the Mr. D. G. Hogarth (B. S. A., vi. pp. 94 seqq.).
…
researches there from 1895 onwards, resulting in the dis- * Further Discoveries, &c, pp. 350 seqq., and Figs. S5 a,
16
The ex-
…
The hill of
…
on stone, and probably of a dedicatory nature, which in the strictest sense of the word
…
was with difficulty rescued. The inevitable massacre followed, directed, with every
…
Mr. Minos Kalochaerinos. Certain signs already noticed by Mr. W. J. Stillman3 on
…
the possession of his brother, Mr. Lysimachos Kalo- in Perrot et Chipiez, Greet Primitive, pp. 460,462.
17
there came subsequently to my notice a fragmentary indication the precise significance Enigmatic
…
nothing by which to determine its age. The clay slip itself perished at the time of
…
1 Cretan Picts., Fig. 30, p. 24 [293] and Fig. 40, p. 30 * Preliminary Reports have appeared in the Annual
18
script in
…
it, which I at once recognized as presenting the same form oflinear script as that of
19
I. § 3. THE HIEROGLYPHIC ARCHIVES OF KNOSSOS
…
found on the floor of a basement chamber, the
…
1 For the South-East Pillar Room see' Knossos,' Report,
20
Hierogly- Immediately behind the landing of the stone steps at the north end of the Long
…
c- ' filling has preserved a series of clay documents belonging to the first period of this
…
found. axis for the string by which chests containing the clay archives themselves or other
…
countof the discovery 1 failed to place these' hieroglyphic'
…
confined to the easternmost district of Crete than was
21
The inscriptions on these documents conclusively disproved a suggestion made Business
…
den Siege!steinen haben einen religiiisen symbolischen been engraved on these as on modern Oriental seals.
…
derschrift in dem Sinne zu thun haben wie Evans will, form of script.
…
schen Goldringe im Bilde zeigen.' That religious signs the tablet had at first escaped detection, and its exact
…
Many of these are, doubtless, the equivaient of Egyptian * See my letter to the Times (' Further Discoveries in
22
exceed the exquisite naturalism of this design.
…
I. $4. THE HIEROGLYPHIC DISK FROM PHAESTOS
…
A detailed account of this must be reserved for the concluding part of the present
23
disposal excellent photographs of both sides of the Disk, I am able to give in this place'
…
Fig. 11a. The Phaestos Disk. Face A.
24
stamped on
…
from the centre outwards. It is by far the largest hieroglyphic inscription yet dis-
25
The human figures in their outline and costume are non-Minoan. We miss the
…
under Merenptah. this same group of seafaring peoples, and the belt
…
Still more divergent from all known examples of Minoan dress is that of the Woman's
26
Ship on
…
On some of the linear tablets of Class B this is abbreviated into a half ship, but
…
for us from that side. But it may be reasonably asked, Was there room within the
…
as a curious correspondence in detail that the upturned
28
Approxi- At the same time we are warranted in believing that the Phaestos Disk belongs
…
chronological evidence goes, it would not be safe to place the latest elements in the
…
among the group of seafaring peoples with which so many characteristic features of
…
This new naval Confederacy was destined to outstrip the Minoan sea power, and it
…
of clay 0£ tne building at Knossos was to supply the earliest landmark of a new and more
…
script the most advanced phase of the Third Middle Minoan style, tablets and other
29
LINEAR SCRIPT OF CLASS A 29
…
vases, reliefs, and figures in native faience, among which were the Goddess with the tories.
…
magazine to the South-West, which lay beneath another later floor,3 produced a char-
…
took place in the South-East part of the site. Here, immediately above the Pillar Cups with
…
s 'Knossos,' Report, 1901, pp. 9-12. But the strati-
30
connect them with the latest phase of the Third Middle Minoan style, and with the
…
* The stone Hon weight inscribed with Khyan's name
…
and C'I'AAN do not appear in the same lists, and it is a
…
the names of Hyksos kings seem to be known.
31
LINEAR SCRIPT OF CLASS A 31
…
however, seem to point to a longer local survival of this type of script. The small
…
3 E. Meyer, NacktrQge eur Aegyptischtn Chrouologie, Ab- applied to the Thirteen Ih Dynasty kings, this would show
…
PP- 34* 35! ef. Aeg. Chronologic, pp. 65 seqq.). Dr. Meyer is interesting to note that the'Era of Tanis' wasaiso used
32
Palace or Royal Villa excavated by the Italian Mission at Hagia Triada near Phaestos,
…
What traces, moreover, may have there existed of the First Late Minoan Age
…
i9o6,pp.38o,seqq.)- The tablets of Fig. 73 are from' Lavori
33
LINEAR SCRIPT OF CLASS A
…
Thanks to the kindness of other ex- Deposit of
…
In the settlement at Zakro Mr. Hogarth
…
beautiful painted vases exhibiting lilies and anemones, and other relics illustrative of the
34
magazine in a layer immediately below one containing vases of the Zakro types, and
…
an isolated inscribed tablet of rectangular form found on a votive site called Papoura
…
of script.
…
The above finds show that Type A of the linear script was once prevalent through-
…
able to include a copy of this tablet in vol. ii of the
…
' By the courtesy of Dr. Hazzidakis, Ephor-General of
…
fragment of the rim of a ' matt' painted vase from hiscx-
35
LINEAR SCRIPT OF CLASS A 35
…
wine. It was, therefore, particularly interesting to find on the handles of several of ^P-L
…
Inscription on
…
the Cretan linear characters. This fact alone distinguishes the signs from mere aame ian.
…
may, however, represent some local fabric of a somewhat 3 See my observations on the 'Significance of the
36
of the in-
…
having after them the determinative signs of 'man* or 'woman'. In these groups
…
It is worth noting, as an archaic characteristic of this type of script in
…
- The graffiti are themselves as yet unpublished, served for the part of this work devoted to the illustration
…
1 See pp. I3seqq. of the documents belonging to Class A of the linear script.
37
LINEAR SCRIPT OF CLASS A 37
…
vol. ii of the present work. The associated ' larnax' 2 A single example of a bead-seal entirely devoted to
…
I observed a similar rock shelter, composed of a project- belonging to Classes A or B engraved in the field of
38
THE LINEAR SCRIPT OF CLASS B
…
At Knossos we see the inscriptions of the Linear Class A entirely superseded
39
LINEAR SCRIPT OF CLASS B 39
…
its most characteristic shape in the Second Late Minoan Period, best illustrated by ^second
…
Period, that is, to the concluding age of the Remodelled Palace at Knossos, ^chives
…
the different types of character of which this ' signary' is composed, must be reserved f„^"of
40
The Gram-
…
which betrays the hand of an official grammarian. The sinuous and boustrophedon
…
and they owe their subsequent induration to the burning of the Palace itself. Fire
42
of the
…
rest of the chamber by a stone bench, which may have stood before a wooden counter
…
work as well as in the ceramic and painted plaster decoration. Seven small bronze
…
Fig. 19. Typical example from ' Deposit of the Chariot Tablets'.
…
An interesting phenomenon, afterwards continually repeated in the case of similar
…
a Minoan Prince in his chariot, this latter, however, almost entirely destroyed by the
…
given in Fig. 20: a, from the neighbouring ' Room of the Niche', shows a figure of
43
LINEAR SCRIPT OF CLASS B
…
experience of how easily moisture could affect the tablets when in this unbaked state.
…
piece with their earthy matrix, and transferred on a wooden tray to the old Turkish
44
of the
…
a clay mass which no doubt owed its formation to the dissolvent effects of moisture
…
the tablets themselves was in a very bad state, but with the aid of a plaster backing
46
Titles on
…
them were arranged like books on a modern shelf so as to show their edges, the
…
to the individual deposit from which
…
The circumstances were these.
…
had left the excavation about the same
47
LINEAR SCRIPT OF CLASS B
…
We see here implements and weapons, chariots and their parts, and the Different
…
The example given in Fig. 24 shows a tablet relating to chariot wheels, which, con-
48
listsofmen. to be personal names, followed in each case by the ideograph of ' man' or ' woman'.
…
though what their quality may have been it is at present impossible to say. The
…
shows eight lines of inscription in characters of good style. The sign-groups,
49
LINEAR SCRIPT OF CLASS
…
1 The first group of the last line shows three signs and have been room for the first word ot line 3, consisting of
50
That, in addition to the tablets, ink-written documents must also have' been
…
and sacred writings; liturgies, and books of magic, or hymns, possibly, like that to the
…
None of these possibilities can any longer be excluded, but the perishable nature
…
7 ' Knossos,' Report, 1901, p. 27. The graffiti are not
51
LINEAR SCRIPT OF CLASS B
…
Fig. 27. Graffiti on stucco facing of wall, Room of t!ie Cists, Knossos.
…
from the wall-paintings of Theban tombs, first published
53
LINEAR SCRIPT OF CLASS B 53
…
by about 25 centimetres of deposit, a large part of the building was reoccupied, and [io^araT
54
of immobility in art is succeeded by one of gradual decadence, but the course of
…
I.§ 7. SURVIVALS OF THE ART OF WRITING DURING THE
…
from oversea, the form of culture which
…
" The rectangular building above the earlier
55
SURVIVALS OF THE ART OF WRITING
…
seignorial halls were parcelled out among humbler denizens. But on the later
…
It will be shown below that there are distinct evidences of the existence of
…
suggested in the Report.
56
The 'Kad-
…
of the
…
brilliant wall-paintings, have quite lately been struck on the Kadmeia of Thebes.5
…
It has been already noted above that during the Third Late Minoan Age, which
…
regards the building as the 'House of Kadmos'. See
…
Dr. Bulle, who rightly regards the resemblance with the
57
SURVIVALS OF THE ART OF WRITING
…
This consideration has an important bearing on the very interesting discovery inscribed
…
signs' (Fig. 31). The signs are painted in red on the body of the vase, and they itsindi-
…
it will be seen, goes a little beyond the mark in saying
58
fit on to
…
of script.
…
bility. Rather we may see in it a remarkable indication that the tradition of the
…
The remarkable inscription cut on the handle of a stone vessel found by Tsuntas
…
Pkls., tec., p. 4 [273], Fig. 2 (reproduced in Fig. 33). which Fig. 34 is taken. The stone vessel itself resembles
59
SURVIVALS OF THE ART OF WRITING
…
probable, to both causes combined, the centralized Minoan power, of which the great
…
Fie. 34. Part of stone vessel from Mycenae with inscription on handle.
60
prising spirits in the different districts would be impelled by their growing needs to
…
It is probably not unconnected with the new racial torrent from the North
61
SURVIVALS OF THE ART OF WRITING 61
…
Iliad may be taken to reflect Achaean domination at Knossos itself. At the same time
…
can be no question that the colonizing movement irom the Aegean shores, one of Mediter-
…
Spain, there are indications of intimate contact with the Minoan world, suggesting at
…
I. §8. MINOAN INFLUENCES ON THE ANATOLIAN SIDE
…
seqq.,and cf. 'Homer and his Critics',Edinb.Rev., Jan. 1908, to the extent of recalling a particular transitional phase of
…
Poems belong to a stage of culture in which bronze in words or colours, reproduces the society in which
…
distinct phase of which we have archaeological evidence, as weapons. He could not have had the archaeological
…
were of bronze, but small iron knives also occurred as is done in Homer. The method in the Homeric usage
…
L. M. Ill vases, bronze axes, and spear-heads, but an iron Mr. Lang has the credit of pointing out the distinct
62
as examples, presenting various indigenous characters, the origin of which has not
…
Hittite in- We must, of course, never lose sight of the fact that large sections of the
…
Yuzgat,7 and in the abundant documents of the same kind at present being brought
…
Bibl. Arch., ix. pp. 112-54), a"<l cf. Kretschmer (Eiitl. in d. Arch., 1888, p. 432). The first element in the word is also
…
attempt seriously to grapple with the non-Greek forms. 6 J. A. Knudtzon, Die zivei Arzawa-Briefs, &c., mil
…
Bibl. Arch., vii. (1881), p. 297; Wright, Empire of the Mil- * H. Winckler,' Vorlaulige Nachrichten ober die Ausgra-
63
MINOAN INFLUENCES ON THE ANATOLIAN SIDE 63
…
May we perhaps conclude that throughout at least the maritime tract of Southern Were
…
Extremely decadent traditions of the same kind are shown in the relics from the
…
the Mitannian group, in which case a remarkable Iranian ingredient.
…
Meyer,' Das erste Auftreten der Arier in der Geschichte,' 1907, p. 7. The later Ionian Miletos was traditionally a
…
names of dynasts but the worship of Indra, Varuna, and Mr. Hogarth failed to find a Minoan stratum at Ephesus.
…
531. But Professor Sayce has since shown himself quite this class, from the beginning of the Late Minofin Period,
64
The letter
…
That over and above the pre-existing race affinities there was an actual colonial
…
followed here, as apparently in Canaan, in Cyprus, in Sicily and the far West, in the wake
…
In view of these abiding traces of old Cretan connexion with the Western and
…
That the cnfrtara \vypd, written in a folding tablet, must be here taken -to mean some
…
' Compare the judicious observations of Dr. W. Leat,
65
MINOAN INFLUENCES ON THE ANATOLIAN SIDE 65
…
use in the Minoan colonies oversea, the tendency of colonial tradition being often,
…
It results from these considerations that comparisons based on the signs of the
…
in 1895, after the publication of my work on the Cretan tions. To-day, with thedeveloped linear scripts before us,
…
Pictographs, M. J. P. Six wrote: 'Je n'ai paseu de peine as well as the fuller materials for the hieroglyphic signary,
…
grandes entre les lettres lyciennes qui ne sont pas deri- also shown a due appreciation of the comparative value of
66
Minoan script must in their nature be somewhat eclectic. In the annexed comparative
…
1 The Lycian forms are given with Kalinka's values indicate the probable values of the letters. The smaller
67
MINOAN INFLUENCES ON THE ANATOLIAN SIDE 67
…
1 This sign, with its three upright strokes, is clearly to dard (B. M. Cat, Ionia, PI. Ill, 5,6). The simpler type
…
on the gold plate discovered by him at Ephesus (Archaic 46oav. J-C) The variant No. 9 appears (also with 1) on
…
Arlemision, ch. vi, ad fin.). the reverse of the same coin.
68
MINOAN CYPRUS AND THE INSULAR SCRIPTS
…
intensive shape than is to be found on the neighbouring Anatolian coastlands, we
…
Yet despite its mineral wealth, despite its position, within sight of the Lebanon
…
much to illustrate the connexions between the early
69
MINOAN CYPRUS AND THE INSULAR SCRIPTS 69
…
795, F'gs. 555, 556. * These were, apparently, cinerary urns. But the
…
1 As, for instance, the Late Minoan III ' stirrup-vase' s Ibid., PI. I.
70
Reasons, largely based on the Egyptian evidence, have been given by me
…
script.2 But the materials that have since then accumulated, and in particular the
…
an almost absolute conformity with Minoan types of the Linear Classes A and B. In
…
3 Myc. Cyprus, p. 216 and Fig. 13. The tomb was dis-
71
THE MINOAN
72
to certain quasi-pictorial forms of the ox's head; No. 7 is only a slight simplification
…
in"cavDrusS are' mcIeed, some indications that there existed among the indigenous population
…
occurring on a primitive steatite cylinder from the ' Copper Age' cemetery of Hagia
…
Nos. 2, 3, and 11 of Table III sufficiently demonstrate the real relationship of the
…
seen in the Cypro-Minoan or Cypro-Mycenaean signs may be due to the influence of
…
Cypriote This question has a crucial import, since, should the affinity be ascertained, an
74
Were the
…
whose sacred Grove was at Amathus, we see a very near relationship to the Mother
…
to show that at least the Mainland representatives of Minoan culture, as seen at
…
Much, no doubt, in ancient tradition would be explained by the hypothesis that
…
It must in any case be recognized that the Cypriote syllabary itself has every
…
the Greek colonization of Cyprus. It is true that by the Homeric Age the fame of the
75
MINOAN CYPRUS AND THE INSULAR SCRIPTS 75
…
the Cypriote cities known to later history, including some afterwards regarded as
…
Breastplates are represented on a series of clay tablets 7 The earliest direct mention of the inhabitants of a
…
Horn in Cyprus, PI. II, 872 a). where Wen Amon landed is given the name of Alashia,
…
cf. Engel, Kypros, i. 228. and Assyrians, which recurs in the Tell el-Amarna letters.
…
cf. Busolt, Gr. Gesckichte, i. 322).' Byblos. It looks as if some Phoenician plantation, per-
76
In any case, however, it is clear, from the evidence supplied by the Cypriote
…
sides, a Western extension on the Italian
…
In that case the followers of Agapenor
…
That there are some close correspondences between the two will be seen from
…
Cyprus Museum, p. 34 (Paphos). The type is given by
…
Carian signs and those of the Cypriote syllabary.
77
MINOAN CYPRUS AND THE INSULAR SCRIPTS 77
…
2 Zeph. ii. 5; Ezra xxv. 16. Elsewhere, however, the doth or Lappidotk=torches, the name of Deborah's hus-
…
eluded under the Philistine name. This would confirm pp. 387 seqq. These two tribes are the Kreti and Plethi
78
South Arabian trade route.1 Gaza itself bore in later times the title of Minoa
…
there. appear, architectural features of Cretan type.8 The old ideas of the indebtedness of
…
grounds for believing that the conquest took place about
…
1 For an excellent appreciation of the geographical
…
! For fresh evidence connecting the Philistines with
…
of the Sea' (B. S. A., viii. pp. 182 seqq.). In my original
…
Mr. R. A. Stewart Macalister, for the * Palestine Explora-
79
CRETAN PHILISTINES AND THE PHOENICIAN ALPHABET 79
…
Israel. But the Philistines also excelled in the arts of peace. The Hebrews were
…
is remarkable in many ways. It reveals to us a community, the earliest known
…
But what more immediately concerns our present subject, the Takkaras are Literary
…
* For the votive deposit of Petsofa, which included Sprache, xxxviii (1900), pp. 1-14).
…
tions, see J. L. Myres, B. S. Annual, ix. pp. 336 seqq. 9 Ibid., p. 17. A ' Head Page' of the Prince of Dor is
…
e Cf., too, 1 Sam. xxxi. 3. by the determinative of' dancing'.
80
Did the
…
the tombstone'.1 But the most striking passage in this connexion is where the
…
It may well be asked if some inherited knowledge of this kind, passed on from
…
are we to trace the impulse which, during the immediately ensuing period, resulted
…
' In my first work on ' Pictographs', 1895, pp. 95-7
…
returned in ' The Palace of Knossos in its Egyptian
…
is due an early recognition of the plausibility of this
…
however, appears to have been derived through the
…
0 Fick, Vorgriechische Orlsnatnen, p. 123. The same
…
' The cuneiform script stili prevailed in Syria, accord-
81
CRETAN PHILISTINES AND THE PHOENICIAN ALPHABET 81
…
such ' architectonic'. modifications and turnings about, the radical divergences are J^cts.
…
kunde' {Mitth. d. vorderasiat. Ges., 1901), after a review of to account for the rapid divergence of the Southern from
…
kingdom (Ma'ln) goes back at least to 1200 b. c. He Minaean letters were derived from the North Semitic in
…
earliest Sabaean forms, which do not go back beyond the forms from the Canaanite characters are in many cases
82
The natural inference from these phenomena is that both the North and the South
…
1900, H. 2). Dr. Peiser, however, puts forward the hypo-
…
The crude method of Hommel's comparisons is criticized
83
CRETAN PHILISTINES AND THE PHOENICIAN ALPHABET 83
…
A more definite trace of a Babylonian ingredient is indeed supplied by the fact
…
the arrangement of certain texts.
…
not a single one of the Phoenician characters is in the
…
It will be seen that in spite of the arbitrary rearrange-
…
of the * head ' signs. In the same way v
84
It will be seen that the attempts to trace the Phoenician alphabet to.an old
…
and how easily it can be worked out in the case of many of the Phoenician letters
85
CRETAN PHILISTINES AND THE PHOENICIAN ALPHABET 85
…
More recently, indeed, it has been suggested that the Semitic alphabet was
…
evolution. We recall Lucretius's judgement4 on the personal theory of the origin
…
The attempts hitherto made to derive the Phoenician letters from a Babylonian
…
supplied by a series of potsherds with engraved signs or marks found in the
…
in lectures (' Cours d'histoire') given in 1838, it did not with Aegean types, but owing to their simple forms the
…
supplied by him, in De Rough's Meinoire sur forigine recently discovered materials in any way added to the
…
Rouge in 1874, pp. 5 seqq.). specialized of these signs, No. 21, which approaches the
…
de l'origine des lettres pheniciennes comme definitive- * Professor Petrie's theory as to the origin of the
…
* De rebus Naturae, v. 1041,1043. the correspondence of certain primitive Egyptian signs
…
* F. S. Bliss, A Mound of Many Cities, or Tell-et-Hesy the existence of a widely diffused signary common to a
86
the Art of Writing, as illustrated by the letters of the Phoenician alphabet, is a far
…
Tsade is also very closely reproduced by a sign of Class A, the outline of
…
1 I may refer on this point to the judicious article of
…
1 In this Table, and Table VI on p. 89, S. Sem = South
…
received values in the later times.' From this
…
invariable to order as our own numbers, and force the
87
CRETAN PHILISTINES AND THE PHOENICIAN ALPHABET 87
…
with any show of probability. It is also absent from the conventionalized picto- 'wheel'
…
Phoenician teth. On the tablets of Class B, moreover, we find the pictorial figure of
…
follows it, is by general consent interpreted as the human head, and if derived from , he<.ad'!,oan
…
pi-'mouth'—it is natural to explain it as having originally represented the outline
…
word signifying the back of the head ; but Delitsch con- Cf., too, Peters, op. cit., p. 196.
88
a similar character should reappear as a common sign in both classes of the Minoan
…
thing like a proof that these names afford a real clue to the origin of the letters.
…
coincidences of the kind referred to above are actually found to occur in a succession
90
the form throws no obvious light on the name unless it be the triangular door
…
Ilfand Lenormant, that he in the Phoenician series is a differentiated form of cMth? the
…
evidently delineating a gate or hurdle. The Semitic he has only three bars,
…
under a more dignified aspect in formulas where it is associated with the sacred
…
kaph. series there are several hand and arm signs. Among the hieroglyphs appear either
…
■Fish/or The Hebrew nun means a 'fish', and the word in this sense is common to all
…
min. not obvious, though it has been suggested3 that this letter originated from the
…
certainly receives a striking corroboration from the ascertained history of a similar
…
1 This form also reappears as a letter of the Phrygian Evans, Ioc. cit.
91
CRETAN PHILISTINES AND THE PHOENICIAN ALPHABET 91
…
the Greek o—which is the common Semitic name for 'eye'. There are two main sisn~■"»•
…
5 See Kirchhoff, Einleitung, &c, p. 172. They appear analogies with the fl), V, and *f* are to be found in the
…
date. They must have been known quite as early at that if the Ionians adopted the South Semitic letter-forms
…
the complementary signs, including the Omega, are found as successful, dmega, however, has an independent
…
is a further proof of their still earlier existence in the
92
Ionian values of the X and t or V had already by that time differentiated, their
…
plementary signs, the <p in its archaic
…
to the Minoan signaries.
…
Phoenician able correspondence between old Semitic and Minoan characters. In many cases the
…
gave a series of figures of the probable pictorial originals
…
has disposed of the old Semitic derivations, but even in
93
CRETAN PHILISTINES AND THE PHOENICIAN ALPHABET 93
…
to the linear Classes A and B, there is some evidence of the existence of one or
…
These considerations are quite sufficient to explain such lacunas as exist in the Lacunas
…
be taken to show that many other signs have not a direct affinity. The fact that
94
Phoenician It will be shown in the course of this work that even the advanced linear signs
…
word-signs with a translated value. A Minoan sign, for instance, might represent the full
…
1 In an interesting conversation that I had with (eristics, and concluded with the remarkable expression
…
of these possibilities were discussed, he enlarged on the were at bottom of non-Semitic stock.'
95
The diffusion of the Philistine settlements through the Southern part of the indications
…
the evidences of Aegean intercourse become most abundant on the Italian side.
…
2 The Ashmolean Museum is now the repository of htriens und Dalmatiens zti //alien and Griechenland, 1904,
…
Egypt, due to the discoveries of Prof. Flinders Petrie and at Nesactium ; cf. R. Burrows, The Discoveries in Crete,
…
' The discovery in this district of extensive remains ; See especially the papers of Orsi in the Bidltllino di
96
The
…
only in the civic name Minoa, but in the cult of Eryx, whose Lady of the Dove held
…
again the evidence is associated with the appearance of linear signs. Some early
…
of the Minoan scripts. They should probably, however, be better classed with the
…
But a new chapter in discovery has been now opened by the recent investigations
…
4 Some of these are incised on the hard metal. Others
…
6 Some clay vessels and other objects in the Museum
…
notice of Prof. Paris's book in the Revue Arche'ologlque {v.
…
de la Grece historique.' For further discoveries of the same
…
interesting review of the materials will be found in Paul
97
the upper waters of the Jucar, to Alicante, and Murcia, and not least from the ancient
…
the actual selection was often of an indigenous kind—fit on to the characteristic
…
class of pottery, in at least its later phases, went on in Spain down to the days of
…
intention, and, though the heads are in no instance surmounted by the sacred
…
the comparisons that M. Paris had already instituted. ' Op. cit., i. pp. 141 seqq. The bulls' heads, now in the
…
L'Art, &c, T. VI., p. 940, n. 5. Corro, supported on one side by a ' Cyclopean' wall and
…
late Carthaginian. 8 The characteristic features (recognizable at once to
98
on Iberic
…
tions on
…
horns. It may be added in this connexion that a bronze figure in the Madrid
…
matters that concern the early culture of the Iberic
…
It is certain that both branches of the Iberic alphabet—Celtiberian and Tur-
…
5 Excluding the later ypsihn and omega. For summary
99
koph, which also present non-Phoenician types. The number of foreign forms thus
…
foreign signs of the Iberic
…
As the values of the May we
…
of Minoan influences on the
…
as the linearized derivatives of a pictograph representing the human head and neck,
100
derivative form which answers to the Phoenician koph these have been lost. It is,
…
Crete, as already observed, was never more densely populated than in the Third
…
doubtless a good deal of local dislocation. Thus at Knossos the ' House of Minos'
…
pletely superseded bronze for cutting purposes, and the Cretan ' Geometrical' style
…
1 See above, p. 92, note 3, under R. Knossos, pp. 133 seqq.). At some distance to the West
101
the fact that the new occupants of the site had lost, partially at least, the tradition
…
of Crete must, from the archaeological point of
…
but suggesting a kind of assimilation to a cremation-urn. The absence of arms and
…
continued knowledge of the linear form of script. This is a clay disk, reproduced
…
the survival of Minoan elements throughout the Geo-
…
- A preliminary notice of the Cemetery of Erganos
102
in the group f tf, which appears before the totals in lists and additions of accounts.
…
Dr. Taramelii opines that it came from the necropolis.
…
3 The Cretan towns enumerated in the Catalogue (ii.
…
9 Cf. p. 58. The ultimate triumph of the civic term
…
5 Mas Meyer (loc. cit.) writes of the double-axe as it
…
the double-axe itself was the fetish form of the God or
…
nexion between the first elements of >,a&ipii>8os and the
103
The Palace at Knossos proves to have been at the same time a sanctuary of
…
It is noteworthy that, except for the enumeration in the Catalogue of a certain Crete out-
…
100-4; 1903, pp. 35-8, &c. Mr. H. R. Hall, 'The both in its speech and constitution, took over the essential
…
parisons with the Egyptian Labyrinth, the work of Gortyna,' Halbherr, Man. Ant., i. 49). Dr. R. Meister
…
the form ' Labaris' being due to a kind of ' Volksety- should be remembered that the purest English is spoken
…
mologie'. by the Welsh, to whom it was originally an acquired
…
remarked that while Lyttos supplies an example of a speak the best High German.
104
The
…
The
…
hardly have completed itself even in Central Crete before the beginning of the historic
…
In view of this taking over of Minoan elements by the new-comers in the island,
…
There was then no inherent reason why in Crete, where the ethnic transforma-
…
archaic temple of Rhea at Prinia near Gortyna has (Comparetti, Leggi di Gorlyna, &c, p. 201), recalling the
…
discussed in my Cretan Pictograpks, &c, p. 91 [360]. The parison than that given in my former work is supplied by
105
no remaining trace, might certainly be urged the quite exceptional prevalence of the
…
It is still more inherently probable that a knowledge of the Minoan linear script Survival
…
comes to the conclusion that the language was Indo- s Suidas, AuBol (tai'luMe ra ypujijmra ana too *(.iWoe tou
106
Diodoros,2 the Cretans imparted the first knowledge of letters to the Phoenicians
…
Classical It may be suspected that the Cretan tradition of the invention of letters would
107
region. Plutarch, in his work on the Genius of Socrates,' relates with great circuiA- Inscribed
…
It is worth recalling, moreover, in this connexion, that the contemporary Hittites
…
passage by M. Salomon Reinach (Anthropologic, 1900, the penetration of 'Aegean' elements into Mainland
…
the Ketes of the Egyptians, belongs to the period of the 518, Sec; De Rouge, in Egger, Eludes historiques sur Us
…
correspond with the close of the Third Late Minoan i. 285; Wright, Enip. of Hittites, pp. 65 seqq.
108
Was the
…
of the
…
is possible that both the bracelet and the tablet found in the ' Tomb' of Alkmene
…
pp. 375 seqq.). The fact that the Governor of Crete is
…
in Byzantine writers such as Malalas (sixth century), the
109
remote from that in which it was professedly written—namely, the reign of Nero. Its
…
prove that the account of the discovery on the site of Knossos was itself a pure
…
and Crete was actually ravaged by an earthquake at that period.5 But the effect of an containing
…
inscribed tablets. The half-burned clay slips themselves might well be confused with quake at
…
attention to the statement of the professed translator of maxime inter tarn diversa loquendi genera consequi ac
II. The hieroglyphic or conventionalized pictograpgic script of Crete
111
THE HIEROGLYPHIC OR CONVENTIONALIZED PICTOGRAPHIC
…
In considering the origins of the conventionalized types of the Cretan script it Primitive
…
proper sense pictorial, it is of course easy to distinguish it from the more advanced
…
forms, the meaning of which is only traditionally known, are continually interspersed
…
noted, groups of such are already introduced beside the more elaborate and often the
112
to the most heterogeneous groups.
…
Good examples of these from the Aegean area are supplied by a series of marks
…
of script.
…
point of form, which, like the archaic linear figures of
…
recruited through the simplification of pictographic figures
…
That such linearized signs, rooted in a very ancient ar s on ots' y opi*
…
marks was not susceptible of such easy adaptation to the purposes of script. The
…
Moreover, the particular value of such primitive linear signs must have constantly
113
differed in various localities or families. That in the case of simple linear signs Their
…
with the Egyptians and other ancient races, the demand at last came for a more
…
the hieroglyphic figures before the elements of an advanced linear script could at °af^w f
114
with incised signs often of the simplest linear and alphabetiform character. But a
…
careful investigation of the origin of these linear signs, as illustrated by fuller
115
In the above Table we see a series of purely alphabetic forms closely resembling
…
glyphic forms rather than with the survival of their linear prototypes.
…
consisting of two hands raised as in adoration, we find linear sketches of the primitive
…
as the arms. The T sign again, which is found in the same First Dynasty types.
…
characters, a body of linear signs of very ancient derivation survived into the Dynastic ^assof*"
…
Rude linear pictographs and signs go back in Crete, as in other parts of the Primitive
116
as the prototypes of the three-sided prism-seals, which, at a later period, are so often
…
seen in Fig. 48, a type destined, as already observed, to become the progenitor of
…
obtained by the Italian archaeologist, Dr. Antonio Tara-
117
P.L. 5), shows on either side linear signs, one of which may be taken to repre-
…
monogrammatic fashion, and in this respect recalling the characters on a very early
…
other linear signs, is seen on a clay cylinder (Fig. 50, and
…
' In my first work on Cretan Pictography (pp. 56 [325]
…
belong to the Second Early Minoan Period. The single
…
characteristic of the early ossuaries of Hagia Triada and
…
by a motive on a button-seal (p. 58 [327], Fig. 49 A).
118
from the same deposit1 (Fig. 51; PI. I, P.L. 4) exhibits two linear signs, the first of
…
Whorl On one side of this whorl (a) the principal design appears to be a rude
…
signs from by a single sign like a V, with a square handle. On the other side we see what
…
might be transliterated H C I A/. Of these the first and second appear on the later
…
linear scripts of Minoan Crete; I is a common mark of division on them, and the
…
develop- produce more pictorial and decorative figures than those that appear on the class
…
broader and fuller intaglio, more will be said in considering the rise of the ' hiero-
119
as of the ' primitive pictographic' class. In this class must also be included many
…
ponderate, and the most advanced types show only incipient traces of polychromy.
…
the characteristic features of certain early figures found at Nagada and other pre-
…
interments like those of Mahasna, north of Abydos, belonging to the Sixth Dynasty
120
way by the people with whose remains the great ossuary chamber of Hagia Triada
…
It is also noteworthy, as additional evidence of relations with the African side
…
a suspension vase like those from the lowest strata of Hissarlik, and early seal types
…
and engraved on their upper and lower surface (Fig. 53) '; half-cylinders with designs
…
a perforated knob above,5 and 'button-seals'.' About the close of the period repre-
…
other types characteristic of the early Cretan ossuaries,
…
Figs. 25,26. This example is from the Tholos Ossuary
121
seal' is the immediate predecessor of a more elongated form which occasionally
…
chain of connexion. The parallelism thus supply a
…
the immediate predecessors of the more
…
1 One such specimen was found in the Hagia Triada stable, 1906, p. 51. Mr. Newberry lays stress on the part
…
1 See Percy Newberry, Scarabs, an Introduction to the cylinder type into Egypt.
122
The characters on this class of cylinders, though they contain many signs common
…
a grotesque pygmy form—recalling the embryonic Ptah-Sokar-Osiris—which also
…
see evidence of borrowing both from Asiatic and dynastic Egyptian sources—the
…
like the occurrence of compound animal
…
work in Figs. 55, 56, 57, The shape of the cylinders themselves, which are cut out
123
Crete about the close of the Early Minoan period. A specimen of the type in
…
seems to be some warrant for supposing that the horned man of the prism
124
those on Cretan seals of various periods. Among these we have seen that the
…
their immediate inspiration from some less ancient source, but the indications supplied
125
marked by this Nilotic influence on Cretan culture—of which there are other evidences
…
Liguria (in the lilorelli Collection at Genoa}, b.
…
Rossi, Tav. II. 5, 6.) c. Terramara of Montale {in the
…
called attention to the parallels presented by these
126
The
…
the constantly recurring maeander or key pattern, we may with great probability detect
…
steatite and ivory rings—they are by no means dominant, as in the contemporary
…
Trans- It seems, however, that we may trace the influence of the incoming fashion in
…
happened in the history of spiraliform ornament, it is angularized and translated into
…
Thanks to the courtesy of the explorers, I had been able
…
land (Moscow, 1906), where a good deal of the material
127
keys and maeanders, the prototypes of the labyrinth in art. Such maeander patterns
…
It will be seen from the annexed diagrammatic Table, XII (Fig. 65), that a variant The
…
r. Istilufo Lombardo, xsi (1904), PL X, Figs. 25, 26. PI. XXV, Y, no, and p. 40. A part of the back of one of
…
4 J. Garstang, El Mahasna, PI. XXXIX, 43 and p. 33. Candia and found in the neighbourhood.
129
of the Egyptian design. These secondary stages had, moreover, been reached on the
…
interest, inasmuch as it anticipates the
…
a dog. A very important feature about this hemi-cylinder is that the figure of the
130
II. § 3. THE EARLY PRISM-SEALS OF CRETE WITH
…
to the Sothic system ol Egyptian chronology, would carry back the seals in question
131
THE EARLY PRISM-SEALS OF CRETE
…
summarize the indications supplied by the materials. Together with the more com-
…
on early
132
in reversed positions, followed on the sides by a wild goat, and two fishes; but it does
…
selections from the Zodiac, namely, Gemini, Capricorn, and Pisces.:t
…
(Fig. 71 b), also probably indicates a hunter of the Cretan agrimi, like the archer on
…
The other faces of this seal seem to refer to the potter's
133
THE EARLY PRISM-SEALS OF CRETE
…
enclosure. The animal shown on the second face of this stone bears some resem-
…
conjoined, stand for a hunter. The ship on other seals denotes the seafaring craft of
134
appears, a stout-legged long-necked bird (Fig. 75 a) on one stone may be identified
…
the Libyan Sea.. On the protodynastic cylinders of Egypt the ostrich is constantly
…
II. § 4. SEALS AND SEALINGS OF THE CONVENTIONALIZED
…
The stones themselves are almost invariably2 of the
135
faces b and c are occupied by figures of a dog and a spider, both taken from the
…
These most primitive types of the seal-stones presenting the Conventionalized
…
This early class seems, however, to have at least partially overlapped the Twelfth
136
seals of the present class, together with some advanced types of Cretan button-seals or
…
be gainsaid. Of the two examples c and/given in Fig. 78, c, from a scarab found at
…
Such coils and flourishes, in fact, play an important part in the elaborate polychrome
137
Egypt about the middle of the Twelfth Dynasty, and continued in vogue during the type with
…
scarabs of this class were occasionally made use of by the insular engravers had
…
We thus see that Cretan seals of Class A, presenting the hieroglyphic script in Class A
…
This conclusion receives a striking corroboration from the discovery—already Seal-im-
…
But a new fixed point in this connexion has now been supplied by the Abydos Tomb,3 The new
138
Minoan association with an imported polychrome vessel belonging to the close of the Second
…
Of the two sealings from the early Deposit in question, one appears to be from
…
inlaid, are practically identical with those from the earliest metal age graves of the
…
in the case of certain early seals. On the other hand, a series of vase types included
…
II. § 5. SEALS EXHIBITING THE CONVENTIONALIZED PICTO-
…
* In his Nachtragc zur aegypiischsn Chronologic (1908), the limits of this Dynasty.
139
SEALS EXHIBITING SCRIPT OF CLASS B 139
…
One broad distinction affecting this later group may at once be made. While the
…
which evidences extraordinary perfection in the gem-engraver's art. We note, moreover,
…
specimen of this form, engraved on two of the sides, was found in the Vapheio Tomb.2
140
fore-parts of the lions more clearly indicated, is in the Pauvert de la Chapelle Collection,
…
shown in Figs. 82 a, 82 b. It is of white cornelian.2 A coarser type of the same
…
The stem is often of a highly decorative character, spirally grooved and faceted.
…
1 E. Babelon, Collection Pauvert de la Chapelle, No. 72 * The lower face of this is also given in PI. II, P. 33.
142
ynasty; and it is therefore of particular interest to note that the coiled cruciform
…
Two other circular stamps, probably from signets of the above class, on clay
…
It is there compared with an early sealing from the hoard
143
SEALS EXHIBITING SCRIPT OF CLASS B 143
…
These naturalistic associations are strikingly confirmed by the contents, already
…
of horned sheep or moufflons in a style identical with that of the primitive prism-seals
…
Nevertheless, it must be said that, in spite of the persistence above noted of ^,ge'
…
decoration found in the West Building at Knossos my general work on the ' Palace of Minos *■
144
The use of seals, moreover, as inscribed stamps had almost entirely gone out/ and
…
ments in the linear script of Type A.
…
Type A has been recently found in the ' Little Palace' at
145
stage in the Palace history the records of the hieroglyphic script have entirely given
…
sides, (d) a perforated bar or ' prism' with three sides, and {e) oblong tablets. The
…
which the string passed by which the box or document was secured. This form
146
a work of art. The two hieroglyphic characters—one of them a lyre—contained
…
Fig. 92 shows a variant form presenting inscribed characters on its flat and narrow
…
in § 15 below to a sealing of this class in which the counter-stamp shows the
147
a hunting scene. There also appears the corner of a fifth impression, from a rect-
…
In only one case is there any obvi ous correspondence of the sign-groups engraved
…
a perforation through the valve (see Fig. 95). They were obviously intended to be Iabels-
…
1 For this sealing see above, p. 22. Its lower face, where the graffito inscription would have been, is broken away.
148
the case of P. 102, they appear on only two sides. The flat bases of some of the bars
…
example of this class of inscribed bar has been preserved, P. 119. The remaining
…
(e) Clay tablets of oblong form.— Only one specimen of this type occurred in the
149
HIEROGLYPHIC) INSCRIPTIONS ON SEALS AND SEALINGS
…
P. 3. Steatite prism. Crete: Copenhagen Museum, a. Two hippocamps. The trumpet-like scrolls on b a
…
P. 4. Yellow Steatite prism. Elunda (Olous). b is a decorative design derived from the 'double sickle' of the
…
locality, c may be the sea-horse
150
P. 4**. Black steatite. Mallia, Crete. There is no trace of any rigging on the aft part of the ship on a
…
P. 5. Brown steatite prism. Crete. Bought in Candia (A.J. E-). For formula on a cf. P. 2, &c.; for b s
151
abraded, a appears to be the leg sign. As the lower part of ft was much worn away the sign here may really have
…
P. 10, Sealing from hoard found in House A, Kato Zakro. The coil to the right is probably decorative. (PI. I.)
…
P. 13. Flat rectangular bead-sea!, green steatite. Central Crete. On face a is an 03 and a branch or tree.
152
P. 14. Natural ' finger' of yellow steatite, the base of which has been cut fiat and engraved as a seal. Kalamafka,
…
P. 15. Fragment of sealing. SE. Pillar Room, Knossos. The characters are of very primitive type, and the
…
The ' trowel' and eye signs (Nos. 18 and 5) are also seen in conjunction
…
Green jasper prism. Mirabello Province (A.J. E.). The sign in the left upper corner of face b seems to
153
P. 21. Red cornelian prism. Province of Siteia (A. j. E.). On face a the sign after the ox-head resembles a
…
indicate some such title as ' Keeper of the Swine'. The a:_.... ._
…
P. 33. Red cornelian prism. Central Crete, 1898. This remarkable seal may contain the name and titles of
…
P. 34. White cornelian prism. Eastern Crete. The second sign
…
,) On c it is seen without the
154
The group on a is the recurring formula, probably a title, seen on 18 c, 20 c, 23 b, and 30 d. The third sign on bis
…
a and c are slightly larger than the other two. The X on faces a, c, d, and of which a trace seems to exist at the
…
the repeated plough sign was interpreted as pairs of wrestlers, the goa
…
head compared to an apluslre, and the ship
156
P. 30. Four-sided bead-seal of green jasper. From Xidha, near site of Lyttos. Faced shows the familiar +, leg
…
irrence in a graffito formula on the clay bar (P. 117 a below).
…
P. 34. Chalcedony bead-seal with convoluted back as preceding. Gortyna. (See above, p. 140, Fig. 83.) The two
…
P. 35. Red cornelian bead-seal of the same type as P. 33 and 34. An owl with scrolls on each side of its head
…
P. 36. Green jasper 'signet' (for upper side see p. 140, Fig. 84). Goulas. The animal is of the cat-like kind
…
P. 37. Green jasper'signet'. Knossos, 1898. We have here a more perfect example of the figure seen on P. 35,
…
already been noted that the mallet and goat's head appear with the plough and mountains sign on P. 26 b, perhaps
…
P. 39. White cornelian 'signet'. Kalochorio, near Kritsa (A. J. E.). The 'strainer' (No. 54) and arrow-head
157
P. 40. Red cornelian signet. Kentri, near Hierapetra. (See Fig. 86, p. 141.) The wolfs or dog's head with the
…
P. 40*. Red cornelian signet. Central Crete. It shows the star sign of eight rays within circle with floral offshoots.
…
P. 43. Stamp of circular seal of which two examples were found impressed on cup handles at Palaikastro.
158
P. 46. Green jasper prism-seal from Kordakia near Kavousi. (From sketch by A. J. E.) Sides b and c are the
…
P. 47. Cornelian. Mirabello Province. (Now in the Fitzwilliam Museum at Cambridge.1) Sides a and b show
…
P. 48. Green jasper. Mirabello Province. (Fitzwilliam Museum.) a shows the leg and gate, followed by
…
o almost flat faces. Found at Hellenika, Knossos. On face a
…
within incised circle, double axe, sepia (No. 60), and a bifoliate figure. On face b, also within incised circle,
…
1 The kindness of the Director h;
159
P. 49*. White cornelian prism. Mirabello Province: in the possession of Mr. R. Seager. Face a shows
…
P. 50 a. Impressions of suboval seal, probably prism. The sign to the left seems t>
160
. Impression of prism- or four-sided bead-seat. The ' ciub' sign here separates the ' trowel' and eye.
…
P. 54 a. s. Impression of prism- or four-sided seal. This again shows the ' trowel' and eye, but between them is
…
P. 56 a. Part of the impression of a prism-seal. This shows the ' mouth' sign (No. 6) coupled with the same
…
P. 59 a. 1 and 2. Repetitions of the same impression, probably from a prism-seal. For the formula compare
…
Impression, probably of a prism-seal. The sign on the right s
…
• . ui ». . ..... u. .... impression Irom a prism-seal, showing the eye and the lower
…
partof the'trowel* sign. (PL III.)
161
P. 63 a. r. Impression of signet showing ship, the initial X mark, ai
…
I the branch sign (No. 101}, probably of a
…
jf metal. (See pp. 142,146 above.) It shows the
…
P. 66 a and 67 a. Impressions from the same face ot a four-sided bead-seal. The uppermost sign possibly
…
P. 69 a. 1. Impression, probably of four-sided bead-seal. The first device to the left appears to be a decorative
…
P. 70 a. Impression of'signet' seal, showing the double-axe sign. (PI. III.)
162
P. 71 d. 1. Impression of a prism- or four-sided bead-seal with the recurring f, leg and gate formula.
…
above, P. 7*. At the two extremities of the field are groups of dots, seven and five in number respectively. (PI, III.)
…
by hound: from a lentoid gem. 3. Impression of prism- or four-sided seal. The first sign appears to be the dog's
…
ornamental adjuncts. For the ' trowel' and arn
…
and nest to it the ' bee '. (PI. III.)
164
P. 55 b. The inscription has the initial sign X, and reads from left to right. (PI. IVa.)
…
P. 64. This is the largest of all the clay sealings found in the Knossian Palace (see above, p. 145) and is distinguished
165
1 c, which frequently stands by itselt on the small side
…
P. 72 b. Only the ' gate' sign c
…
with graffito inscriptions. The sign to the left of a, after the initial mark, appears to be a glove. It is suggested
166
P. 77. There is no seal-impression and no other sign-group on this clay sealing. The first sign on the left seems
…
P. So a. The initial sign X shows that this reads from left to right. A second X after the first group of three signs
…
P. 81 a. A roughly executed group consisting of the arrow-head, plough, and apparently a saffron flower. (PL V.)
…
P. 83 a. This reads from left to right. After the initial X is a shed on piles, probably a storehouse, followed by
167
P. 84 a. Slightly broken. The ' angle' sign and ' double
…
P. 84 b. For the double J and ' double-axe' conjunction see P. 108 a. (PI. VI.)
…
twice repeated, and is followed, as on
…
I he double-axe and dog's head signs that begin the inscription may possibly convey the name or title of an official.
169
P. 92 a. The inscription, beginning from the initial X, reads from right to left. It is followed by numbers (= 33).
…
P. 93 a. In spite of the direction of the goat's head this inscription must be taken to read from left to right. It is
…
P. 93 b. This also reads from left to right. The first sign seems to be a variant of the ' sepia', the second is the
…
P. 94 a. This inscription again, notwithstanding the direction of the goat's head, must be taken to read from left
170
P. iao'a. This face, as indicated by the initial X mark, reads from right to left, and is divided by a cross-line into
…
P. iooi. The beginning here is to the left, and this face is divided into three sections. In the firs: of these the
…
This bar is practically complete. As pointed out in § 13 below the total numbers = 11000.
171
P. loirt. The upper line reads from right to left, beginning with the initial X mark. The tour signs of line I
…
P. 102A. Reads from left to right. The third sign is the ' zigzag't
172
P. 103 a. This reads from right to left, the second group beginning with
…
____, the line
…
P. 104 a. Reads from right to left. In this case the ' bust' (No. 3) is doubly associated with the ' olive spray'
…
P. 104 b. Both lines here seem to read from left to right. The three numerical signs of line 1 with the double
173
P. 105 a. The inscription, reads from left to right, only the numerical part of the first group being preserved (=60).
…
P. 107. This bar is perfect. The inscription on face a, beginning with the X mark, reads from left to right. The
…
P. 1076. This reads from right to left, beginning with the initial X mark. The 'store-house'sign (No. 43) recurs
174
P. 108. The lower half only of this bar is preserved, with an inscription on the butt (e).
…
P. 108 e. The base of the bar. The inscription beginning with the ' cross', after the initial X, reads downwards
…
P. 109*. This reads from left to right: the same sign-group Of, flower, }) occurs in the same order on P. 104 d.
175
P. no, A part of the larger end of this bar is broken away. The top
…
P. in. Perhaps a third of this is wanting at the larger end. This and the three succeeding examples, P. iia,
176
The next is the jar and olive spray
…
P. iiarf. We have here, perhaps, the end of a branch like that of c. (PI. X.)
…
P. 113 a. The first sign seems to be the same as P. 111 a. The ¥ "f, followed by a stroke, in the second section
…
P. 113 A. Forthe'fig-branch'and two following signs compare P. 111 b and 112 c The first sign is unique. (PI. VIII.I
…
P. 114 a. This line apparently reads from right to left. The second group ¥ 4- recurs on P. 113 a. (PI. VII.)
…
P. 1153. The first sign here is the
178
P. iiSff. Probably reads from right to left and exhibits two sign-groups. The first consists of a serpentine form
…
P. 119 a. The' plane' (No. 22) is here twice repeated. (PL VII.)
179
•P. 120, line 1. This line reads from left to right. The first character is imperfect, and neither it nor the second-
…
1 This downward line appears as two separate strokes in the copy of the inscription in Mom. Antic/ti, and its
180
P. 122. Tablet with large perforation and signet impression on the side. (See Plate XI,)
…
rounded, the other oblong. On side c are two oblong impressions and
181
1. The ideograph of a man standing with both arms held downwards is seen by
…
A closely allied type appears as an ideograph—the ' man' sign—in the Linear
…
2. The crouched human figure 2 a with one hand raised occurs at the beginning
…
posture with one knee drawn up and the buttock resting on the heel ^ch
182
reproduced above,1 which seems to stand as the ideograph for 'speech'.2 A closely
…
Cycladic and Minoan graves. It is only found in the graffito inscriptions, and in two
…
The human eye seems to have the natural signification of oversight' or in-
183
the circles with tangential lines and curves are better grouped with the solar and
…
ir-t, and the single or double pupil o, 00 (= ' Eye'—' to see *, ' to watch'; with the
…
The crossed arms. This seems to be an ideograph taken from gesture language.
…
The forepart of the arm with extended palm is seen on one of the Jerabis inscriptions
…
Derivatives of this sign are found in both varieties of the linear script.
…
Human hand, palm outwards, or glove. The fact that in other presentations
184
of the hand, both pictographic and linear, the fingers, or some at least of them, are
…
This appears to be the human hand seen partly in profile and as if in the act
…
The human leg. The bent leg as an Egyptian hieroglyphic is used as a determina-
185
The perforated single axe is rare among Minoan remajns. The pictograph is best
…
The arrow is one of the most constantly recurring signs. Usually only the head
…
The 'arrow' is often coupled with the 'trowel' (No. 18). (See § 21, below.) On
186
P. 112 it appears twice with the A (No. 130). On P. 94 a and 76 b it is connected with
…
Lance or dart. The primitive type a, which certainly resembles ;
…
a lance with a segmented shaft, apparently of cane. It appears on two sides of the
…
Fig. 33 d- The dagger symbol appears in two forms among Egyptian hieroglyphs,
…
It is a noteworthy fact that the sword, which is typologically an outgrowth of the
…
Arm holding curved instrument. It may be compared with the Egyptian ^_4,
187
on P. 86 a with the ' saffron' {No. 88) and the ' plough' sign.
…
Perhaps a trowel. This figure, which is the most abundant of all the hieroglyphic
…
form (No. 21), and it is noteworthy that this latter tool, coupled with the saw, forms the
…
The 'template' sign. In my first work on Cretan Pictographs (p. 36 [305] and
…
In confirmation of this I was able to cite a gem from Goulas of the convoluted
189
The graffito type d is probably a linearization of the more pictorial forms of this
…
Adze with handle of an Egyptianizing form, recalling the hieroglyphic character
…
Apparently a kind of plane. This figure is repeated, but less clearly, on the same
…
Saw of Egyptian form resembling the pictorial original of the hieroglyph
190
The mallet. Type a, on a prism-seal of Class A, shows the earliest form. The
…
buildings or a town, is frequently associated with the 'mountains* or territorial sign
…
Ring-handled instrument, perhaps of metal. It is distinct in form from the
…
Peg, mace, or sceptre. Compare the Egyptian \
…
Plough of primitive form with the pole and share beam in one piece. The type
191
resembles that in use in early Greece and Italy, and of which a design dating from the
…
an entirely new type, apparently standing in the same relation to the Asiatic horn-bow
…
Further light may eventually be thrown on this enigmatic figure.
192
Lyre. This occurs in conjunction with y on the fine signet impression P. 64 a.
…
Pronged instrument of uncertain use. It is of frequent appearance both on the
193
the 'template' (No. 19) and the V sign (No. 92). On the clay bar P. 104 c it is also
…
This has the appearance of a suspended tablet.
…
The crook or hook. This sign, resembling a capital J, is placed in any position.
…
Types/and k, with a kind 01 spur at the bottom of the upright stroke, might also
194
A much closer comparison is supplied by the early type of the Egyptian
…
with three bars (No. 35). This differentiation of the meaning of signs by the addition
…
developed form, probably a shepherd's crook. This artificial modification of the
…
The single-barred crook. This is evidently a differentiated version of the pre-
…
Spoked crook. Both a and b occur on P. 112 c and are there clearly distinguished
…
35- Three-barred crook. This sign occurs on P. in, preceding the number 32
196
The hieroglyphic formula, in which this sign is coupled with the 'trowel' (see
…
Museum Cat., PI. I. 22) shows an altar table on which an ox is being sacrificed, the
197
39. This sign greatly resembles the Egyptian ankh, the symbol of ' life' and
…
the Egyptian libation vases, >Q qebeh, except that it has a handle, the handle being a
…
This sign is identical with secondary forms of the Egyptian hieroglyphic for
…
This is represented by ' a nearly square enclosure, the wall of which is carried half-way
198
along the front and then turns in at a right angle enclosing an inner court'. The tower
…
over from the Egyptian series.
…
An angle, perhaps of a building. It occurs on the two faces of the clay bar P. 104,
…
Hut on piles, probably a storehouse. This sign occurs in both cases in the same
199
The ' gate' sign, which may also signify an ' enclosure' generally, is one of the most
…
and that no trace of this four-barred version is to be found in the Semitic series.
…
be a differentiation of the preceding, with which it is closely allied. It is found in
200
Fence or trellis-work. On the clay impression P. 50 a it is coupled with the
…
on prism-seals of Class A, where they are an inheritance from the more primitive
…
Two-handled vase with olive spray. The outline of the vessel closely resembles
201
This sign is only found on the clay bars P. in, 112, presenting very similar inscrip-
…
This sign seems to be a handled vessel, the contents of which are indicated by
…
The 'grain'or'honey jar'. This jar is here seen in section, asNos. 48 and 49, with
…
indicated within it, as in the preceding.
202
Measure of grain. The circle with three, four, or, more rarely, two dots is found in
…
Possibly a barrel or store jar ('pitkos'). The cross lines may indicate the hoops
…
with the arrow sign (No. 13). Thus it occurs in groups with the arrow and mallet
203
55. This figure occurs on the early lentoid P. 12, together with the vase (No. 47 c}
…
This seems to be the ' ingot' sign, very frequent on the tablets of the Linear Class B.1
…
In my earlier work on the Cretan Pictographs 41 had suggested that the sign might
…
The ship. Types a, a, a belong to the more primitive class, A. There is absolutely
204
show a great resemblance to those which appear on a Late Minoan class of lentoid
…
This figure, however, has been here included among the more enigmatic characters.
…
Tunny fish. The general outline of a and the tail of b are characteristic. On
205
P. 28 it stands alone as an ideograph, on the seal-impression P. 45 it is grouped with
…
In this frequently repeated sign I venture to recognize the small eatable sepia or
206
'serpent* (No. 84) and the cross pommde (No. 112). In two other instances (P. 108e,
…
61. Rude figure of an ox on the primitive ' tabloid' P. 13 a
…
Ox-head seen in profile. Type a is associated with two goats' heads on a prism-
…
63. a, P. L. 5 (on early pendant); b, P. L. 3 (Phaestos whorl); c, P. 21 a; d, P. 21 c;
…
Ox-head. It is noteworthy that the facing ox-head type of the Middle Minoan
207
Type a represents a primitive linear type of this sign seen on the steatite pendant
…
The goat's head is of constant recurrence. In three places it is placed between
…
It is impossible to say whether the sign refers to the wild goat or Cretan Agrimi
…
A kid or doe. This is coupled with the single axe on P. 22 b. The sign shows
…
Head of horned sheep. This is perhaps the moufflon, representations of which
208
occur on Late Minoan gems. Type a occurs on two sides of a prism-seal of Class A,
…
Apparently an ass's head. Compare the characteristic Hittite sign 4
…
69. The pig or boar as a whole figure occurs in association with the gate on
…
70. Fore-part of an animal grouped with the fence (No. 46) and rayed disk or
…
Dog's head. This head does not show the fangs and protruding tongue of No. 73,
209
on the Minoan gems, often with collars round their necks. A seal-impression from
…
Wolfs head with protruding tongue. This sign appears on P. 44 with the arm
…
(see below, p. 264). In its graffito form it is associated with the cross pommee
…
Cat. This pictorial sign appears in connexion with the official formula f, leg and
…
76. Apparently the head and neck of a long-necked animal. Coupled with the
210
77. Apparently an animal's foreleg and shoulder. On P. nob, associated with
…
81. Waterfowl, perhaps swan, in the act of taking flight. On the clay impression
212
The spider. Type a appears by itself on a prism-seal ol Class A; bis attached to
…
The bee. The large abdomen and the indications of the proboscis enable us to
213
the bee' or, perhaps originally 'the Bee-Keeper'. A high official also had the title of
…
87. An uncertain flower, probably a lily with recurved petals. The sign appears
…
To judge by the more detailed reproduction on the Minoan frescoes this flower,
214
The lily, which evidently had a religious value in Minoan cult, is distinguished
…
there certainly an ideographic value, as referring to the plant itself.
…
89. This sign, which appears on the clay label P. 86 b in association with the
…
The fleur-de-lis. Type b, which probably represents the most correct form of the
215
The f, or pst sign as it may be conveniently termed, represents a plant. We have
…
1 L. Mtliler, Numismatique de Fancknne Afrique, I. p. 9, upper part of the plant. The gem is a chalcedony
216
and twice with the 'mountains' or territorial sign (P. 77, 103 c). In the case of
…
Heart-shaped figure with specks or grains; possibly the heart-shaped fruit of the
…
The suggestion is offered that we have here the heart-shaped fruit of the silphium,
217
makes it possible that, like many other North African plants, it was indigenous in the
…
numbers. Thus on P. 82 it is followed by the number 3, on P. 85 b by 32, on the Phaestos
…
96. Apparently a gourd or pod. This sign is only found on P. 26 c. It is there
…
Tree with ascending branches. It is repeated sis times on P. 26 a, combined with
218
gem from the Idaean Cave, now in the Museum at Candia, a votary is seen blowing
…
The parallel branches. Type a stands by itself on a prism-seal of the more
…
This seems to be a forked branch or double spray, with its foliation only on one
…
It is probably a vegetable figure—a kind of forked or bent branch, but the evidence
219
Perhaps a palm branch. This sign is distinguished by showing off-shoots on only
…
The olive spray. The resemblance of the better executed of these sprays to the
220
the plough and the ' mountains' on P. 64 d.
…
Branch of fig-tree. The characteristic form of the leaf is traceable in a, and it is
…
104. Possibly another vegetable sign. It is coupled with the 'arrow' on the
221
106. Spray in a kind of gable. This sign is coupled with the ' cross pommee' and,
…
107. a, P. 68 a; b, on signet-seal; c, P. 50 a; d. P. 40*.
…
Day-star or sun with revolving rays. The graffito type d, which is grouped with
…
Solar disk without rays. This sign obviously stands in close relation to the
222
Type b is identical with the Egyptian hieroglyphic for 'sun' and 'day'. It is
…
The crescent moon. Two crescents which apparently have the value of separate
…
The cross pommee. The knobbed ends of its limbs distinguish this character
223
The simple cross is widely diffused in primitive pictography, notably among the
…
on the sealing P. 70b, together with No. 117 below, and the 'branch' or 'tree'
…
Vertical lines descending from a more or less horizontal figure representing the
…
The ' Mountains' or Territorial sign. We have here a widely distributed picto-
224
The Egyptian p^") men = mountains is applied in the same way as a determi-
…
As is noted below (see p. 262), this sign is grouped in a special way with the
…
Type a with the closed ends seems to be the most perfect form of this sign. Its
225
reduced to mere S-shaped forms and with the intervening dots omitted recurs in both
…
More especially in its glyptic form, a, this sign resembles the forepart of a ship
…
117. This enigmatic sign occurs on the clay sealing P. 70b, between the 'tree'
…
118. This sign is grouped with the ' gate ' and ' human leg' on the clay label
…
119. This somewhat complicated sign is only found with No. 60 £ and No. 125 on
226
121. This sign is found on P. in c after No. 134.
…
The meaning of this character remains uncertain. Type a is associated with the
…
This figure somewhat resembles an CO. Type a is grouped on P. 102 a with the
…
On P. in c this sign is found with another uncertain figure (No. 121). On P. 87 c
…
125. This sign occurs on the clay label P. 95 a with Nos. 119 and 60 k.
227
127- This character, the lower angle of which to the right is conjecturally com-
…
128. a, P. 122; b, on clay label from Idaean cave; c, P. 88 b.
…
Type a is found on the Phaestos whorl; b occurs with g and E on the early prism-
…
A sign closely resembling this is abundantly represented in the two Linear
228
The delta sign is well represented on the graffito documents. In four cases (P. 90 b,
…
This character consists of a combination of a Z with the preceding delta sign, and
…
132. The E-like sign is seen on the early prism-seal P. 8 b. The incision was
…
233. This sign occurs with an unit on the tablet P. 120, where it is followed by
…
The N sign is found, both on the Phaestos whorl and the sealing P. 53 b, associated
229
with a simple vertical stroke which in the former case appears to be a sign rather than
…
preceding the common 'template', ¥ and leg formula—on a small prism-seal in the
…
It must further be remarked that, in addition to the above list of signs, other devices
…
There are however certain other figures, in the form of scrolls, coils, and sprays,
230
the clay bars, labels, and sealings we may justly infer that in the case of the seals they
…
The S sign should perhaps be simply regarded as a decorative flourish. In P. 22 c
…
The 'trumpet* or coil is in much the same case as the S sign. It is also seen
…
This does not appear as a character in either of the later linear classes.
234
II. $ 10. ANALYSIS OF THE HIEROGLYPHIC OR CONVENTIONALIZED
…
To these may be added at least four other hieroglyphs, three on P. 120 and the
…
47>> 51 (on steatite reliefs of doubtful attribution), 64 (van- s See Fur/her Discoveries, Sec., 1898.
…
(cf. 51). hand, the ' lion's mask* and the 'cat' (Nos. 74 and 75)
235
ANALYSIS OF THE HIEROGLYPHIC SIGNARY 235
…
It is possible that a small minority in either class may be confined to the seals
236
The condi- Why then, it may be asked, should a more pictorial form ot writing thus interpose
…
by a mere process of hasty writing we recognize the real process that gave birth to
…
duced the hieroglyphic script of Crete was largely due to Egyptian example.
…
the early
237
ANALYSIS OF THE HIEROGLYPHIC SIGNARY 237
…
such as the half-cylinders, the ' button'-seals, and with them the three- and four-
…
C M&£^^§T\ car'y evidences of relations between Crete and the
…
To a certain extent it is possible to watch the actual transformation of the earlier Trans-
…
examples, the linear group (A) occurs on a steatite seal-stone of distinctly earlier fabric
238
ence on
…
from seals of much more advanced technique, executed on harder materials. Here,
…
them in its own fashion. The insular position of Crete was, in fact, of great value in
239
ANALYSIS OF THE HIEROGLYPHIC SIGNARY 239
…
are best explained by religious influences. Among these are the ankh or life sign a, in The ankk.
241
ANALYSIS OF THE HIEROGLYPHIC SIGNARY 241
…
It is true that some of these tool-signs, though they certainly imply the indebted-
…
In view of these comparisons, it seems legitimate to infer that, over and above the special
…
* On the Mastaba of Ptahhetep (F. LI. Griffith, Ptahhetep,
242
signs given above. Such, for instance, are the hand holding a curved instrument
…
It must also be borne in mind that the chronological discrepancy seems to be
…
1 Wright, Empire oj the Hiilites, PI. XVIII. 1-8-
243
ANALYSIS OF THE HIEROGLYPHIC SIGNARY 243
…
It is well to remember, however, that, though from one cause or another the Con- Inherent
…
and yet to admit that the general character of the conventionalized pictography of
244
essentially early civilization of the island as it existed about the end of the third millennium before
…
arts°'aid an<* implements are Passed in review, and we see the tools, some of them obviously of
…
Among domesticated animals we see more than one kind of ox and may watch the
245
II. 6 ii. CHARACTERISTICS OF THE HIEROGLYPHIC SCRIPT
…
A certain number of the signs that appear on the clay documents of the hiero- A few signs
…
contents may be placed in this category. At most, however, it seems that a very small but the
…
words or ideas, though the same signs when found in groups may have had a purely
246
there is no mark of division between the 'gate ' and the succeeding signs. The 'gate'
…
The ' human eye' is an appropriate ideogram for the functions of an ' Overseer'.
…
1. Isolated word-signs, sometimes repeated, as in the case of Egyptian hieroglyphs,
…
2. Word-signs of kindred meaning grouped together for the more comprehensive
247
CHARACTERISTICS OF THE HIEROGLYPHIC SCRIPT
…
A variety of considerations lead to the conclusion that, apart from the ideographic Evidences
…
But when we come to analyse in detail the sign-groups on the seals and tablets it Disparate
248
cations as the following :—
…
Taking now for comparison the first 200 groups of hieroglyphs in Erman's
…
In Nos. 47-50, however, we see the vase sign differentiated by a separate indication of
249
CHARACTERISTICS OF THE HIEROGLYPHIC SCRIPT 249
…
This sign is linked in a special way, as is seen in the Phaestos Tablet, with some
…
It is interesting to observe that the same &
…
depicted objects in a rude infantile style of art—compared above to the child's nary"
250
the transition from the pictorial to the linear figure. In many other instances, however,
…
of the in-
252
of arrangement. These comparisons show that though the direction in which the
…
Example of Boustrophedon Order on Prism-seal.
…
Fig. 108 a (from P. 109 a). Shows sign-group followed by numbers (= 250) starting from the initial X-mar'{at '^e
…
Fig. 108 b (from P. 103 d). Shows the same sign-group starting in the same way as « from the perforated end of
253
ARRANGEMENT OF THE HIEROGLYPHIC INSCRIPTIONS 253
…
Fig. 108 c (from P. 89 b). The same group starting from the X-mark on a clay label, left of the perforatio
…
Fig. 109 b (from P. 102 a). The same sign-group is seen, starting from the X-mark, here at the perforated end of the bar,
255
ARRANGEMENT OF THE HIEROGLYPHIC INSCRIPTIONS 255
…
inverted position. Such designs therefore often supply a trustworthy clue as to the
…
figures stand to the direction of the inscription itself. In the Egyptian hieroglyphic directionof
256
the dogs' heads on P. 86 a and 89 a, of the goats' heads on P. 101 b, 104 a, 107 d,
…
II. § 13. THE HIEROGLYPHIC NUMERATION
…
Less assistance than might have been expected is here obtained from the numeral
…
1 Two C's superposed sometimes are made a continuous eight, the 10 up to nine, the unit to eight,
257
THE HIEROGLYPHIC NUMERATION 257
…
the tablet would be nf. An angular sign possibly, representing the same figure
258
P. 103, which is also completely preserved, supplies the following sums :—
…
The total is here 1972, and in this case again the successive amounts do not show
…
Sums of On P. 107, where the inscription is again perfect, we reach a more definite result :—
…
The total amount is therefore here 100, a result which corresponds with a repeated
259
THE HIEROGLYPHIC NUMERATION 259
…
The total is thus 1100, a being 100, and b and c together 1000.
…
The total here is 11000, or just ten times the sum (1100) arrived at from the
260
II. $14. CORRELATION OF THE GLYPTIC AND GRAFFITO
…
Although one class of hieroglyphic inscriptions appears on seals and the other on
…
That certain ' canting' personal badges, to be described in the succeeding Section,
…
1 In order to simplify the comparisons the signs are left to right, with the exception of a, which should be read
…
or the
…
son of the
261
Just as some of the formulas on the signets are absent from the graffito series,
…
SIGNS ON
…
SIQNS ON ON CLAY
…
maintained. It might have been supposed, for instance, that the signs of the
…
sometimes change their positions. But this is not the case. The evidence tends to
262
pronged sign, V, is consistently in the middle. In the same way b and/of Table XX
…
e, P. 81 a, 86a, 100b; /, P. 1040; 1096; g, P. 766,93a, ioSrf; k, P. 93a, 109a"; k, P. 108*, n6«. The arrows
…
Of these it wiil be seen that b is repeated five times, d four, e and g three. For the undulatory arrangement of c
…
' angle' between the double axe and arrow in Table XIX, h. So, too, on P. 96 a we see
263
In Table XXI (Fig. 118), a 1 and a 2, from P. 107 b and 83 a respectively, the oxvs Instances
…
been above recognized as the fig-branch sign, and composed of very similar elements,
…
spurs, and other simple modifications. The remaining sign, resembling a A with a Z
…
CANTING BADGES ON THE HIEROGLYPHIC SIGNETS
…
especially the useful work of Mr. Percy Newberry,
264
in more than one region, that the need of expressing by a kind of rebus the names of
…
It is, therefore, a highly suggestive phenomenon that we find, especially on the
…
Head of a long-eared animal, probably an ass: on the fractured prism-seal P. 48 c.
…
Dove preening her wings: standing by itself on face a of the three-sided bead-
265
OFFICIAL TITLES, ETC., ON THE HIEROGLYPHIC SIGNETS 265
…
recurrence on seals, we have good reason for identifying with official titles.
…
the various connexions in which the 'canting' badges in question stand with these
268
mask itself was rather the personal badge or appellative. That the animal figures
…
It is interesting to observe that the oldest examples of the gate and leg series,
…
Place of the
…
the crouching dog and the spider. The animal figures, occurring thus on a signet type
269
OFFICIAL TITLES, ETC., ON THE HIEROGLYPHIC SIGNETS 269
…
3 Cf.' Pharaoh, King of Egypt,' Exod. vi. 11, &c. See * Petrie, Royal Tombs of the First Dynasty, Part I, p. 36.
270
connected with the first attempt at human portraiture. The signification of Guardian
…
any other known product of this ceramic style (Fig. 122). It must be said of the
III. The Phaestos Disk
274
Disk found the Linear Class A first appear, and it is therefore of special interest to note that
…
thTcharac- characters were stamped in relief with punches when the clay was wet, each
…
Fig. 129) presents in the same way 30 groups and 118 signs. The total number of
…
1 Op. cit., pp. 266 seqq. and Fig. 10. The signs present
…
given by Dr. Pernier on p. 269 (Fig. 11).
…
1 Op. cit, p. 278. Dr. Pernier does not think that the
…
Compare, for instance, P. 100, 117. At the same
275
III. § 2. THE HIEROGLYPHIC SIGNARY OF THE PHAESTOS DISK
…
CATALOGUE OF SIGNS ON PHAESTOS DISK (see Table XXIV)
…
2. Head of a man in close-fitting crested helmet. For comparisons with the head-
…
mark is visible on the cheek. This, as Dr. Pernier has suggested,1 may indicate
…
5. Naked male child. The characteristic outlines of the forepart of the body,
…
He notes the signs of' organic weakness', which naturally i Op. cit., p. 292 (No. 39). * See p. 291.
277
THE HIEROGLYPHIC SIGNARY OF THE PHAESTOS DISK 277
…
(Fig. 127 a2, bs). Fig. 127 b shows an early form of the Persian mitra.
…
Jerabis.8 He remarks : ' If the Phaestos Disk be a matrix, then this sign in its positive
…
ire/wos seen from above. It is not without hesitation that I would put forward the
…
14. The flat tops of the two prominences in this figure as well as the slots in the
278
18. A carpenter's angle. This occurs in the regular Minoan series (No. 42).
…
21. A curious double comb or rake, perhaps connected with the weaver's craft.
…
instrument of this character {Svirala) is in use among the Serbian and Croatian peasants.1
…
is also seen hanging from the forepart of the 'arrow'. The vessel has a well-
…
As noted above in Part I/' the absence of .a mast distinguishes the ship on the
…
'double pipes' that they differed from the ancient tibiae in * See above, pp. 25 seqq.
279
THE HIEROGLYPHIC SIGNARY OF THE PHAESTOS DISK 279
…
29. Head of an animal of the feline genus, seen in profile. The comparatively
…
30. Head of a horned sheep or perhaps a moufflon, seen in profile. The facing
…
The linearized representation of a flying eagle, but without the serpent, occurs in
…
36. The forked spray here shown closely resembles certain varieties of what
…
37. A plant with a fan-shaped flower and buds on either side of the stalk.
…
'he line of oars and, apparently, two small towers on primitive attempt at perspective,
282
with the 'armed fist' on the Disk refers to the sex of the prize-fighters. The Minoan
…
the female breast is seen as the most natural emblem of a kindred divinity, and
…
a belonging to the First Middle Minoan Period
283
ANALYSIS OF THE SIGN-GROUPS ON THE DISK 283
…
Of this usage there are several indications analogous to those that are found on Evidences
…
4. By a process of subtraction of elements such as the above it may be seen
…
That there is a decided ideographic element among the characters on the Disk But
284
Making a liberal deduction for the signs that seem to be here used with ideo-
…
For purposes of comparison the equivalent of these figures in percentages is given
…
It will be seen from the above comparisons that the number of cases in which we
285
HI. § 4. NON-MINOAN CHARACTER OF THE HIEROGLYPHIC
…
Dr. Pernier, indeed, in his account of the Disk, while admitting2 that the signs
…
As regards this last argument it may be fairly observed that the difference in the Objections
286
the normal
…
the Linear
…
seen on
…
curiously identical physiognomy in the different regions. The phenomena with which
…
a foreign system of architecture. Enough has already been said above7 as to the
287
ments of the later invaders of the Delta from the Southern Coasts of Asia Minor and
…
IN THE INSCRIPTIONS ON THE DISK
…
below, the distinguishing strokes beneath certain signs afford a further proof. It is concluding
288
on both faces. Adopting this as a working hypothesis, Face B really contains the first
…
A distinctive feature which at once strikes us in examining the Phaestos Disk is
…
Such marks are always appended to the initial sign of a group, and there are 15 in
…
characters might perform an analogous function to the short lines or dots which
…
But further examination of the material shows that this explanation will not hold.
…
9 The lower part of the 'fist and cestus' sign in A 25
289
According to this view the inscription on Face A is divided into 10 sections, and
…
Fig. 130 (Table XXV). Signs in Similar Collocations with or without the Distinguishing Marks.
…
It will be seen at once that there is a certain- parallelism in the above two tables.
290
divided again on both faces into two sets of six by the long descending line after No. 18.
…
series, and the same exceptionally long 3
…
;roup appears in the third place. So, too,
…
Have we here a kind of refrain ? It is noteworthy that one of the sections
291
III. § 6. THE INSCRIPTION POSSIBLY A RELIGIOUS CHAUNT
…
This 'breast' sign coupled with the enigmatic figure, o. 45, begins the whole
292
element on
…
elements that seem to be discernible on the Phaestos Disk to some Anatolian sanctuary
…
It is, moreover, at least conceivable that in Minoan Crete, as in both the Orthodox
…
It has been already ramarked that several features among the characters of the
…
1 There exist certain late Greek moulds in the form of
…
the sunken designs are of a bolder character, and there
Analytical index
294
THE PRE-PHOENICIAN SCRIPTS OF CRETE. THEIR MEDITERRANEAN
…
Signs on vase handles found by Tsuntas . . i
…
The Iberic Peninsula and N.Africa. . 5
…
Pictorial survivals in Hittite script ... 7
…
§ 2. Discovery of the Successive Types of
…
The author's explorations in the island in 1894 10
…
Early graffiti on vases in advanced Linear Script 12
…
The Minoan Nature-Goddess and Infant Son . 13
…
The exploration of Knossos facilitated by the
…
The hill of Kephala: signs on ancient blocks . 16
…
The Palace of Minos..... 17
…
§ 3. The Hieroglyphic Archives of Knossos:
295
§ 4. The Hieroglyphic Disk from Phaestos:
…
Peculiar ship on Phaestos Disk
…
The Disk perhaps a record of peaceful con-
…
Earlier than the Egyptian records of maritime
…
The ' Era of Tanis' (Zoan) and the Hyksos
…
Wide extension of this form of script
…
Contents of the inscriptions ....
…
Inscriptions on seals, replaced by graffiti on
…
The Grammarian at work .... 40
…
Deposit of the Chariot Tablets, ... 42
…
Hoard of the Arsenal ....
…
Titles on back, like books .... 46
296
The Kefts and their offerings .
…
Indigenous tradition still in the main
…
Decadence of the Minoan and My.
…
The 'Kadmeia' of Thebes and the Palace of
…
Its signs fit on to earlier Cretan systems . . 58
…
Was knowledge of Minoan script thus diffused ? 61
…
The letter of Proetos to Lycian King
…
§ 9. Minoan Cyprus and the Insular Scripts
…
with the later Cypriote syllabary .
…
Were the Cypro-Minoan settlers Greek?.
297
§ 10. Cretan Philistines and the Phoenician
…
Did they bring with them a Minoan script ?
…
Did the Philistines contribute to formation of
…
The South Semitic alphabets .
…
Is it to be found in the Minoan script? .
…
The complementary Greek letters and
…
Lacunas in the evidence.....93
…
The Minoan tradition in Sicily.
…
Minoan influences on Iberic culture precede
…
and the Tradition of the Native System
…
The Dorian adoption of Minos
298
Surviving records of old Cretan script
…
Absence of Minoan records on metal explained 107
…
The unknown script interpreted as Dictys's
…
THE HIEROGLYPHIC OR CONVENTIONALIZED PICTOGRAPHIC SCRIPT OF
…
Linearized pictographs of the Reindeer Period
…
sufficient to generate a system of script
…
On rude pendants, bead-seals, and whorls
…
Libyan Influences on Cretan Seal-
…
Connexion with the Delta . . . .121
…
Egypto-Libyan parallels on Minoan seals . 123
299
The maeander and spiral .
…
The 'double sickle' pattern. Taken over in
…
§ 3. The Early Prism-seals of Crete with
…
Pictographic figures on early prism-seals .
…
The new evidence for Middle Minoan chrono-
…
§ 6. The Clay Documents exhibiting Graffito
…
on Seals and Sealings:
…
on Clay Sealings, Tablets, Bars, and
300
Decorative elements on the signets . . . 229
…
The new materials . . 234
…
Minoan hieroglyphic script largely derived from
…
The conditions unfavourable for application of
…
Character of Egyptian influence on Minoan
…
The ankh........239
…
Were the Minoan and Hittite hieroglyphs
…
§ n. Characteristics of the Hieroglyphic
…
but the bulk also phonograms . . . 245
…
Evidences of the phonographic element . . 247
…
§ 12. Arrangement of the Hieroglyphic In-
…
Various directions of the inscriptions . 250
301
Sign-group occasionally carried on into suc-
…
§ 13. The Hieroglyphic Numeration:
…
Position of numbers on tablets .... 259
…
§ 14, Correlation of the Glyptic and Graffito
…
Certain signs peculiar to one or the other class 260
…
Comparison of the same sign-groups in glyptic
…
Names, and Canting Badges on the
…
Personal badges or cognomina on Cretan signets 264
…
THE PHAESTOS DISK
…
Catalogue of signs on Disk .... 275
…
§ 4. Non-Minoan Character of the Hiero-
…
System on Disk not a local Phaestian variety . 285
Tafel I-XIII
Evidences
of suc-
cessive
types of
script in
Knossian
archives.
Antiquity
and dura-
tion of Art
of Writing
at Knossos.
t8 scripta minoa
it, which I at once recognized as presenting the same form oflinear script as that of
the fragmentary clay slip seen in 1895. The work of the succeeding days produced
a series of these from what proved afterwards to be the second West Magazine, and on
April 5 there was found in a small chamber near the South Propylaeum a bath-shaped
vessel of terracotta containing a whole hoard of inscribed tablets, several in a perfect
condition, which referred to various cereals. The tablets were arranged in rows, and
from the charred wood in which they were embedded, it seems probable that their
immediate receptacle had been a wooden box. From this time onwards similar finds
continued at intervals throughout the whole course of the excavations. The written
documents from the Palace of Knossos and its immediate dependencies now amount
to nearly two thousand.
The overwhelming majority of these clay documents, including the first discovered,
presented an advanced type of linear script—referred to in the present work as
Class B—which was in vogue throughout the whole of the concluding period of the
Palace history. But the course of the excavations brought out the fact that the use of
this highly developed form of writing had been in turn preceded in the ' House
of Minos* by two earlier types—one also presenting linear characters, described below
as Class A, the other, still earlier, of conventionalized pictorial aspect, recalling
Egyptian hieroglyphics. The archaeological stratification of the site reveals two dis-
tinct Palace eras, and, on the eastern slope, remains of a still earlier building. Beneath
the most ancient remains of the Age of Palaces there came to light, moreover, layer
after layer illustrating the stages of a still more primitive culture, from the earliest
Neolithic times onwards. We are thus enabled to trace the whole evolution of the
Art of Writing in a manner for which perhaps it is impossible to find an adequate
parallel on any other ancient site. The consecutive phases of Minoan culture covered
by the several stages in the history of the building are seen in each case to have
been the gradual outgrowths of long generations of civilized life. We watch the rise,
the bloom, and decadence of successive schools of art, and the fuller the volume of
our detailed knowledge grows, the greater is the tale of years demanded to explain the
phenomena before us. We shall not err on the side of exaggeration in estimating
the period covered by the successive types of developed script on the Palace site at
Knossos at over a thousand years. It must at the same time be observed that
the latest of the Minoan documents discovered on this site, those namely dating from
the period of decline, when the Palace as a Palace had ceased to exist, are older
by several centuries than the earliest known records of Phoenician writing. The
twelfth century before our era may be regarded as their latest limit.
of suc-
cessive
types of
script in
Knossian
archives.
Antiquity
and dura-
tion of Art
of Writing
at Knossos.
t8 scripta minoa
it, which I at once recognized as presenting the same form oflinear script as that of
the fragmentary clay slip seen in 1895. The work of the succeeding days produced
a series of these from what proved afterwards to be the second West Magazine, and on
April 5 there was found in a small chamber near the South Propylaeum a bath-shaped
vessel of terracotta containing a whole hoard of inscribed tablets, several in a perfect
condition, which referred to various cereals. The tablets were arranged in rows, and
from the charred wood in which they were embedded, it seems probable that their
immediate receptacle had been a wooden box. From this time onwards similar finds
continued at intervals throughout the whole course of the excavations. The written
documents from the Palace of Knossos and its immediate dependencies now amount
to nearly two thousand.
The overwhelming majority of these clay documents, including the first discovered,
presented an advanced type of linear script—referred to in the present work as
Class B—which was in vogue throughout the whole of the concluding period of the
Palace history. But the course of the excavations brought out the fact that the use of
this highly developed form of writing had been in turn preceded in the ' House
of Minos* by two earlier types—one also presenting linear characters, described below
as Class A, the other, still earlier, of conventionalized pictorial aspect, recalling
Egyptian hieroglyphics. The archaeological stratification of the site reveals two dis-
tinct Palace eras, and, on the eastern slope, remains of a still earlier building. Beneath
the most ancient remains of the Age of Palaces there came to light, moreover, layer
after layer illustrating the stages of a still more primitive culture, from the earliest
Neolithic times onwards. We are thus enabled to trace the whole evolution of the
Art of Writing in a manner for which perhaps it is impossible to find an adequate
parallel on any other ancient site. The consecutive phases of Minoan culture covered
by the several stages in the history of the building are seen in each case to have
been the gradual outgrowths of long generations of civilized life. We watch the rise,
the bloom, and decadence of successive schools of art, and the fuller the volume of
our detailed knowledge grows, the greater is the tale of years demanded to explain the
phenomena before us. We shall not err on the side of exaggeration in estimating
the period covered by the successive types of developed script on the Palace site at
Knossos at over a thousand years. It must at the same time be observed that
the latest of the Minoan documents discovered on this site, those namely dating from
the period of decline, when the Palace as a Palace had ceased to exist, are older
by several centuries than the earliest known records of Phoenician writing. The
twelfth century before our era may be regarded as their latest limit.