INDEX.
245
Establishment
Shortage of staff — Opinions for and against
increasing establishment {Gait) 14238, 14328,
14619-20 {Streatfeild) 14709 p. 21 {Old-
ham) 14844 p. 26, 14993 {Peary Mohan)
15211 {M. C. Nandi) 15263 p. 42 {Mad-
husudan Das) 15494 (K. Ghosh) 15940 p. 66
{J. N. Mukherjee) 16307 p. 79 {Kristo Das
Law) 16475 {Ranajit Sinha) 16791 {Knyvett)
17035-6 {Lyall) 17183, 17206-8, 17314, 17329-
39 {McIntosh) 17407 p. 120, 17443, 17446
{Dulce) 17696 p. 133 {Slacke) 18468, 18482-3,
18649-51 {Allen) 17920, 17928-30 {Bhupendra
Nath Busu) 18075 p. 151 {Macpherson) 18800,
18827-30,18863-5.
Larger powers for executive officers as alter-
native, question of {Duke) 17721-4.
Lieutenant-Governor, larger powers for, in regard
to both permanent and temporary establish-
ments proposed {Macpherson) 18800, 18801.
Results of undermanning {Allen) 17920 {Slacke)
18468, 18484, 18499-501. 18692, 18715-7 {Mac-
pherson) 18800 p. 181.
Sanction already given for large increase in
Provincial Executive establishment {Slacke)
18653.
Subordinate establishments {Duke) 17817 {Allen)
17930.
Subordinate establishments, not competent enough
to admit of Complete delegation of powers to
Commissioner, &c. . {Slacke) 18511-4, 18534,
18619-20.
Estates
Commissioner, extension of powers, suggested
{Tarini Persad) 15798-800.
Definition of an “ estate,” modification of, so as to
bring under Court of Wards important estates
not paying revenue to Government {Tarini
Persad) 15788, 15797, 15863-6.
Encumbered estates, taking over by Government
{Slacke) 18586-91.
Government estates, management of {Bompas)
16221 {Slacke) 18655-61, 18725.
Partition of estates {Bompas) 16253-4 {McIn-
tosh) 17572-5.
Proportion of estates in Bengal {Slacke) 18655.
Salami, taking of, prohibited {Slacke) 18607-8.
Suspensions and remissions, powers of Commis-
sioners and Collectors—Question of increased
powers {Slacke) 18721-30.
Excise
Establishment, opinions with regard to an exclusive
staff {Baikunta Nath Sen) 18279, 18281 {Macpher-
son) 18870,’ 18871.
Government of India control {Bhupendra Nath
Basu) 18147-8.
Officers and authorities connected with excise,
position of
Collector {Gait) 14414-6 {K. Ghosh) 15968
{Lyall) 17247-9 {Macpherson) 18872-4.
Deputy Collector (S. Bhattachaijee) 16082-4
{Duke) 17769-71 {Macpherson) 18870-1.
Divisional Commissioner {Slacke) 18525-6
{Macpherson) 18874-6 {Sarfaraz Hosein) 19046
19086.
Excise Commissioner, abolition of, might be
possible {Gait) 14643.
Separate Superintendent scheme, question of
{S. Bhattacharjee) 16083 {Bompas) 16214-6.
Policy dominated by revenue considerations {Bhu-
pendra Nath Basu) 18096-7.
Explosives Act, rules and'regulations under
Conference of officers of the different Governments,
opinion against {Gait) 14546-8.
Desirable that rules should be issued by Govern-
ment of India—Procedure {Gait) 14542-5.
F.
0
Famine Relief
Relations proposed between Central and Provincial
Governments {Bhupendra Nath Basu) 18075.
Ferries
Establishment of—Local Government too much
. dominated by considerations of revenue {Peary
Mohan) 15211, 15212, 15229-31.
33263
Financial and Municipal Department
Appeals to Government {Oldham) 14974-6.
Secretary
Experience prior to becoming Financial Secretary
{Oldham) 14845-53.
Functions {Oldham) 14854-6, 14863-4.
Relations with Provincial Government {Oldham)
14999.
Financial Relations between Government of India
and Provincial Governments—Existing con-
trol of Provincial Governments and question
of delegation of powers
Accountant - General — Relations with Provincial
Government, interpretation of financial rules, •
&e. {McIntosh) 17535-7, 17541-3, 17547-52,
17603-6.
Additional powers for Local Government sug-
gested {Gait) 14251, 14567-70, 14574.
Opinion against over-ruling Accountant-General
by Provincial Government {McIntosh) 17538-
40, 17598-9.
Government of India, references to—Opinions
and suggestions (Gait) 14250, 14253-6, 14463-7,
14520-5, 14705-6 {McIntosh) 17544-6.
Appointments, Pay, &c., see those titles.
Budgets
Alterations and reductions by Government of
India {Oldham) 14844, 14872-4, 14883-8,
14979 {McIntosh) 17515-22.
Authority of Local Government should be more
final than at present {Oldham) 14844,
14890-3.
Date of information with regard to allotments
{Duke) 17785-7.
Discussion of budget before submission to Govern-
ment of India—Suggestions {Tarini Persad)
15895-900 {K. Ghosh) 16000 {McIntosh)
17638-42.
Discussion with non-official Members of Council
{Gait) 14483.
Hampering of work of Provincial Government
by existing budget system—Lapses, &c. {Duke)
17696 p. 132, 17706-8, 17743-4.
Preparation of budget {McIntosh) 17603-7.
Reappropriation {Oldham) 14980-2 {McIntosh)
17553-5.
Submission of budget to Government of India,
opinions for and against {Tarini Persad) 15788,
15795, 15821, 15888-92 {McIntosh) 17610.
Surplus—Local Government should be allowed to
spend any accidental surplus {Oldham) 14876,
14887.
Criticism of imperial finance forbidden to Members
of Provincial Councils—Removal of restrictions
proposed {larini Persad) 15788, 15795, 15858-9,
15817-9.
Existing financial relations—No material change
required {Gait) 14238, 14245-7 {Streatfeild) 14709
(K. Ghosh) 15940.
Extension of powers of Provincial Government-
Freer hand with regard to details, &c.
Opinion against {Sitanath Roy) 16885 (A. C,
Mazumdar) 19143 p. 192.
Opinion in favour of {Gait) 14238, 14248-9
{Oldham) 14844, 14875 (S. Bhattacharjee) 16063
p. 69 {J. N. Mukherjee) 16307 p. 78 {McIntosh)
17407 p. 120, 17514, 17556-61,17602 {Bhupendra
Nath Basu) 18075, 18129, 18132-4 {Moti Lal
Ghose) 18398 pp. 164, 166 ; 18400 {Macpherson)
18800,18801; App. IL, p. 199.
Loans, see that title.
Lump sum grants, usefulness of {Bompas) 16125
p. 72.
Principles which should govern financial relations
{Bompas) 16125 p. 71.
Separation of provincial from imperial finance —
Existing position, opinions for and against sepa-
ration {Oldham) 14844 {Ban Bihari) 15100{Tarini
Persad) 15788 {Ranajit Sinha) 16791 {Sitanath
Roy) 16908-9 {McIntosh) 17525 {Duke) 17696
p. 131, 17735-8 {Bhupendra Nath Basu) 18130-1
{A. C. Mazumdar) 19143 p. 192.
Settlement—Financial
1904, settlement of {K. Ghosh) 15940, 16029-38
{J. N. Mukherjee) 16411—2 {McIntosh) 17596-7.
1906, settlement of on same lines as settlement of
1904 {K. Ghosh) 16039-40.
Existing lines of settlement reasonable if per-
manence could be guaranteed {Duke) 17741-2.
2 i
245
Establishment
Shortage of staff — Opinions for and against
increasing establishment {Gait) 14238, 14328,
14619-20 {Streatfeild) 14709 p. 21 {Old-
ham) 14844 p. 26, 14993 {Peary Mohan)
15211 {M. C. Nandi) 15263 p. 42 {Mad-
husudan Das) 15494 (K. Ghosh) 15940 p. 66
{J. N. Mukherjee) 16307 p. 79 {Kristo Das
Law) 16475 {Ranajit Sinha) 16791 {Knyvett)
17035-6 {Lyall) 17183, 17206-8, 17314, 17329-
39 {McIntosh) 17407 p. 120, 17443, 17446
{Dulce) 17696 p. 133 {Slacke) 18468, 18482-3,
18649-51 {Allen) 17920, 17928-30 {Bhupendra
Nath Busu) 18075 p. 151 {Macpherson) 18800,
18827-30,18863-5.
Larger powers for executive officers as alter-
native, question of {Duke) 17721-4.
Lieutenant-Governor, larger powers for, in regard
to both permanent and temporary establish-
ments proposed {Macpherson) 18800, 18801.
Results of undermanning {Allen) 17920 {Slacke)
18468, 18484, 18499-501. 18692, 18715-7 {Mac-
pherson) 18800 p. 181.
Sanction already given for large increase in
Provincial Executive establishment {Slacke)
18653.
Subordinate establishments {Duke) 17817 {Allen)
17930.
Subordinate establishments, not competent enough
to admit of Complete delegation of powers to
Commissioner, &c. . {Slacke) 18511-4, 18534,
18619-20.
Estates
Commissioner, extension of powers, suggested
{Tarini Persad) 15798-800.
Definition of an “ estate,” modification of, so as to
bring under Court of Wards important estates
not paying revenue to Government {Tarini
Persad) 15788, 15797, 15863-6.
Encumbered estates, taking over by Government
{Slacke) 18586-91.
Government estates, management of {Bompas)
16221 {Slacke) 18655-61, 18725.
Partition of estates {Bompas) 16253-4 {McIn-
tosh) 17572-5.
Proportion of estates in Bengal {Slacke) 18655.
Salami, taking of, prohibited {Slacke) 18607-8.
Suspensions and remissions, powers of Commis-
sioners and Collectors—Question of increased
powers {Slacke) 18721-30.
Excise
Establishment, opinions with regard to an exclusive
staff {Baikunta Nath Sen) 18279, 18281 {Macpher-
son) 18870,’ 18871.
Government of India control {Bhupendra Nath
Basu) 18147-8.
Officers and authorities connected with excise,
position of
Collector {Gait) 14414-6 {K. Ghosh) 15968
{Lyall) 17247-9 {Macpherson) 18872-4.
Deputy Collector (S. Bhattachaijee) 16082-4
{Duke) 17769-71 {Macpherson) 18870-1.
Divisional Commissioner {Slacke) 18525-6
{Macpherson) 18874-6 {Sarfaraz Hosein) 19046
19086.
Excise Commissioner, abolition of, might be
possible {Gait) 14643.
Separate Superintendent scheme, question of
{S. Bhattacharjee) 16083 {Bompas) 16214-6.
Policy dominated by revenue considerations {Bhu-
pendra Nath Basu) 18096-7.
Explosives Act, rules and'regulations under
Conference of officers of the different Governments,
opinion against {Gait) 14546-8.
Desirable that rules should be issued by Govern-
ment of India—Procedure {Gait) 14542-5.
F.
0
Famine Relief
Relations proposed between Central and Provincial
Governments {Bhupendra Nath Basu) 18075.
Ferries
Establishment of—Local Government too much
. dominated by considerations of revenue {Peary
Mohan) 15211, 15212, 15229-31.
33263
Financial and Municipal Department
Appeals to Government {Oldham) 14974-6.
Secretary
Experience prior to becoming Financial Secretary
{Oldham) 14845-53.
Functions {Oldham) 14854-6, 14863-4.
Relations with Provincial Government {Oldham)
14999.
Financial Relations between Government of India
and Provincial Governments—Existing con-
trol of Provincial Governments and question
of delegation of powers
Accountant - General — Relations with Provincial
Government, interpretation of financial rules, •
&e. {McIntosh) 17535-7, 17541-3, 17547-52,
17603-6.
Additional powers for Local Government sug-
gested {Gait) 14251, 14567-70, 14574.
Opinion against over-ruling Accountant-General
by Provincial Government {McIntosh) 17538-
40, 17598-9.
Government of India, references to—Opinions
and suggestions (Gait) 14250, 14253-6, 14463-7,
14520-5, 14705-6 {McIntosh) 17544-6.
Appointments, Pay, &c., see those titles.
Budgets
Alterations and reductions by Government of
India {Oldham) 14844, 14872-4, 14883-8,
14979 {McIntosh) 17515-22.
Authority of Local Government should be more
final than at present {Oldham) 14844,
14890-3.
Date of information with regard to allotments
{Duke) 17785-7.
Discussion of budget before submission to Govern-
ment of India—Suggestions {Tarini Persad)
15895-900 {K. Ghosh) 16000 {McIntosh)
17638-42.
Discussion with non-official Members of Council
{Gait) 14483.
Hampering of work of Provincial Government
by existing budget system—Lapses, &c. {Duke)
17696 p. 132, 17706-8, 17743-4.
Preparation of budget {McIntosh) 17603-7.
Reappropriation {Oldham) 14980-2 {McIntosh)
17553-5.
Submission of budget to Government of India,
opinions for and against {Tarini Persad) 15788,
15795, 15821, 15888-92 {McIntosh) 17610.
Surplus—Local Government should be allowed to
spend any accidental surplus {Oldham) 14876,
14887.
Criticism of imperial finance forbidden to Members
of Provincial Councils—Removal of restrictions
proposed {larini Persad) 15788, 15795, 15858-9,
15817-9.
Existing financial relations—No material change
required {Gait) 14238, 14245-7 {Streatfeild) 14709
(K. Ghosh) 15940.
Extension of powers of Provincial Government-
Freer hand with regard to details, &c.
Opinion against {Sitanath Roy) 16885 (A. C,
Mazumdar) 19143 p. 192.
Opinion in favour of {Gait) 14238, 14248-9
{Oldham) 14844, 14875 (S. Bhattacharjee) 16063
p. 69 {J. N. Mukherjee) 16307 p. 78 {McIntosh)
17407 p. 120, 17514, 17556-61,17602 {Bhupendra
Nath Basu) 18075, 18129, 18132-4 {Moti Lal
Ghose) 18398 pp. 164, 166 ; 18400 {Macpherson)
18800,18801; App. IL, p. 199.
Loans, see that title.
Lump sum grants, usefulness of {Bompas) 16125
p. 72.
Principles which should govern financial relations
{Bompas) 16125 p. 71.
Separation of provincial from imperial finance —
Existing position, opinions for and against sepa-
ration {Oldham) 14844 {Ban Bihari) 15100{Tarini
Persad) 15788 {Ranajit Sinha) 16791 {Sitanath
Roy) 16908-9 {McIntosh) 17525 {Duke) 17696
p. 131, 17735-8 {Bhupendra Nath Basu) 18130-1
{A. C. Mazumdar) 19143 p. 192.
Settlement—Financial
1904, settlement of {K. Ghosh) 15940, 16029-38
{J. N. Mukherjee) 16411—2 {McIntosh) 17596-7.
1906, settlement of on same lines as settlement of
1904 {K. Ghosh) 16039-40.
Existing lines of settlement reasonable if per-
manence could be guaranteed {Duke) 17741-2.
2 i