Payne, Humfry
Necrocorinthia: a study of Corinthian art in the Archaic period
— Oxford, 1931
Zitieren dieser Seite
Bitte zitieren Sie diese Seite, indem Sie folgende Adresse (URL)/folgende DOI benutzen:
https://doi.org/10.11588/diglit.8577#0115
DOI Seite / Zitierlink:
https://doi.org/10.11588/diglit.8577#0115
Titelblatt
Preface
VII
THE greater part of this book is devoted to the vase-painting of Corinth in
…
lished in 1892, did not set out to cover the ground, and even within its limita-
…
plications which are no small part of the history of Corinth in the narrower
…
that is, to classify and characterize the vases irrespective of their merits, in
…
Although I have been able to treat the subject in some detail, I have
…
It is only in recent years that the ground has been prepared for a correct
VIII
time, to interpret the archaeological material in the light of racial and psycho-
…
words are taken (p. 80 of Furtwangler's Gemmen) is worth quoting in full, as
…
since that was written; it would be easy to mention quite recent works in
…
the Peloponnese was mistaken; that Corinth in particular never depended on
…
though they may occasionally betray Ionian influence by small details, were in
…
that in the early archaic period there were three primary forces at work:
…
2, Crete; 3, Corinth and Sicyon. At any rate it is in relation to one or
…
pottery are still being found; but I have principally in mind two other sources
IX
enabled me to study in some detail, are of interest from more than one point
…
tion of the view, for which I have argued in Chapter III, that Protocorinthian
…
and Archaeology, 1930, pp. 195, 257; and 'Archaeology in Greece' in J.H.S.
…
in the first place, of a vast quantity of sherds, few, if any, of which were
…
figurative decoration in the 'middle' Protocorinthian style, the style, that is, of
…
represented. This is no place to mention individual pieces; but in passing
X
subject shown in fig. 45b), and a fragment which gives the first exact parallel
…
In addition to the bronze there was a good deal of ivory: spectacle-fibulae,
…
remarkable number of scarabs and other imported Egyptian objects, sixty in
…
dealt with, though in summary fashion, in the first appendix. Of the earlier
…
category in this and other departments. By this, however, I do not mean to
…
the few paragraphs in Beazley's chapter in the 'Cambridge Ancient History',
XI
The first of many obligations which I have incurred in the course of my
…
of what I owe to his interest in the undertaking. I wish also to express my
…
British Academy (in connexion with which I am indebted to the kindness
…
kindly given me permission to publish vases or other objects in museums, or
…
B. H. Hill for his kindness in making accessible to me the material from the
…
material from Rhitsona; to Mrs. Beazley for the photographs reproduced in
List of the chief abbreviations
I: Early protocorinthian vase-painting
1
vase-painting in this book. The subject has been so fully treated by Johan-
…
in isolation, for the first and one of the most important questions concerning
…
included in Johansen's book, accumulated in course of time; and then, there
…
interest of contemporary Attic work; in fact they form a colourless, unambi-
…
them have been found at Delphi (in fragments); and Thera, Boeotia, Aegina,
…
1 p. 13. 2 Johansen p. 10. pi. 2, 4, but with zigzags in place of maeander and
2
doubt that the home of this fabric was in the North East Peloponnese.
…
pendent evidence for the origin of the geometric vases. In my opinion the
…
was found at Corinth in the course of the American excavations some
…
It is quite evident, and indeed it has never been denied, that in technique
…
fig. 1 b-c {ibid. pis. 12, 14, 15 and p. 415 fig. 2) have their counterparts in
…
vases in the Woodhouse Collection, now in the British
…
tions began in 1896: cf., for instance, AJ.A. 1903,
…
proved a handicap in the task which i have under-
3
resemblance, but it is very much more restricted in scope than that of the
…
broad and narrow bands of black in sober alternation. Now this is the system
4
an analogous development evidently took place in the Argolid,1 make it diffi-
…
mainly geometric, but Johansen is certainly right in regarding them as a later
…
part of the vase are finer than in most earlier vases; and that figurative decora-
…
entirely in Corinthian hands.2 The western colonies give us the first evidence
…
published in the Danish edition of Poulsen's book
…
sented in Sicily and Italy: very often these imported
…
and many vases of Creto-Cycladic type in Mon. Ant.
5
ment of the Protocorinthian industry. It may well have been in the Cyclades,
…
from Crete.2 The appearance of the round aryballos at this moment in the
…
the Cretan connexion; for the shape has a long history in the Creto-Cypriot
…
numerous in Thera (see Thera ii, 177 ff.; Pfuhl in
…
in both cases the style agrees well with these indi-
…
it has a very close parallel in Candia, from Afrati—
…
Cretan strain in the population of the colony, for
…
that the former was the regular use in the early
6
aryballos changed comparatively little in Crete throughout the course of
…
character was given to the vase. Simple 'mathematical' forms, whether in
…
and though it often appears in Crete
…
from the later bronze age, which in its turn inherited the shape from a much
…
The primitive ovoid vase from Syracuse pi. i, 2, which was found in the
…
If the aryballos was a scent vase in the early
…
fabrics made aryballoi in the seventh century, and
…
at one period Corinthian scent was greatly in demand
…
less, but a type with a small foot, as in Protocorinthian,
7
aryballos assumes an ovoid form, like that illustrated in pi. 1, 6; the drawing
…
The several friezes in which the decoration is arranged are still divided
…
portant technical advance has now been made; the figures are drawn, not in
…
probability in the technique of engraving designs on bronze, and it seems very
…
but the Protocorinthian was the only early style in which engraving was
…
and discusses the vase on p. 73. mon in Crete at this time, though, of course, on a
…
3 See Johansen p. 27-8. several others of the same shape in the find from
…
There is a Cretan vase of a somewhat similar type in
8
of 'subgeometric' animals drawn in silhouette, without added colours and
…
that certain types are still found in graves of the later seventh century.2
…
of all three represent a very early stage in the history of Protocorinthian orna-
…
where; for example, the aryballos in Oxford with a large kotylai of this period are really like (cf. Welter
…
the shoulder is far less geometric in style. Perhaps p. 27), but not, of course, in the form which is
…
in this context are three kotylai by a single artist, found with Corinthian vases in tomb 173 at Gela
…
vases of the first archaic style, and, as we shall see, century are those illustrated in figs. 9 A, 120; the first
…
fall in the earliest years of the seventh century at the 3 Mon. Ant. xxii, pi. 30, b-c; Johansen pi. 6, 1.
…
which, it is to be hoped, will soon be published, 5 Patterns almost exactly as in the preceding;
9
of the old discipline, notably in the angular stylizations of the finials; but
…
corinthian vase-painters, particularly, developed one aspect of the subject in
…
2 The existing fragment is illustrated in A.M. 1897, upper frieze compare Johansen pi. 13, 1, and
10
21-3, cannot be later than the first quarter of the seventh century. In the
…
In pi. 3, nos. 1-2, are illustrated two small ovoid aryballoi in the British
…
palmettes shown in pi. 3 are typical of the developed archaic style; many
…
decoration until we reach the early red-figure period. In fig. 5 we have a
…
in several ways is given in Johansen pi. 27, 2; a an aryballos. Greenish buff clay, finely polished.
11
ment in pi. 4, 6. These fragments are interesting for several reasons:
…
These minute unguent vases are, in a sense, the most remarkable products
…
it would be a mistake to imagine that large vases were not also produced in
…
later than the kotylai with coursing hounds, one of which is illustrated in
…
is the lid in the Vatican, Albizzati pi. 7 and p. 31, figs. 7 and 8, which
…
dog's neck in pi. 5, 4 is painted bright yellow—an
…
very distinct advance on the stage illustrated in fig. 4,
12
are speaking. It is probably earlier than the lid in the Vatican, and about
…
of these are shown in pis. 4 (4), 6 (in the latter reduced to i).3 They are,
…
something of the kind in the kotylai illustrated on pis. 4 and 5, but there the
…
Aegina of several other oinochoai of developed Protocorinthian style.4 In
…
2 A drawing is given in A.M. 1897, 300 fig. 28.
…
paws, stylized as in Hittite reliefs (fig. 13 a). (3) The
…
are in Athens. These fragments were found at
…
and red spiral in field (cf. the red filling ornament
…
no. 224. The grave, no. 21, in which it was found
13
seen in Protocorinthian and Corinthian vases of all periods, and the drawing,
…
and the clay is very fine and light green in colour;
…
rendering of details, we have a close analogy in the
…
1 i, p. in. Orsi, writing many years ago, thought
…
and bottom in each case). On the shape see p. 32.
II: The late protocorinthian orientlizing style
16
the second are mostly of an external character, for the actual differences in
…
number of existing pieces. But the proof lies in external evidence; as we
…
tinguish any group of vases as belonging to so short a period of time. In
…
arranged in stylistic groups with a considerable degree of exactitude. Further,
…
1 The vases discussed in this chapter cannot be ch. ii, and I would ask that judgement should not be
17
more certainly between 540 and 500 B.C. than in the long, sure process of
…
change in the third Protocorinthian period is the transformation of the
…
logicallythe latest. The pointed shape seen,for example, in pi.9,8 is the usual
…
There is, I think, no need to spend time in pointing out the similarity be-
…
a floral garland, in the same manner as vases of the earlier period. The form
…
in the Transitional and Corinthian periods.4 There is another small change in
…
usually heavier than in ovoid vases. thian category (p. 167); it is certain, however, that
18
proportion to the whole than formerly, and the figures in it are therefore
…
The drawing, in some examples at any rate, shows little change from that ot
…
mouth, chest contour,1 and feet are always shown in some detail; sometimes,
…
corinthian style is the same in essentials as that of the preceding period; but
…
stylization recurs on a late Protocorinthian fragment is common in Attica until the middle of the sixth
…
rendered on no. 39 (cf. also pi. 9, 4); side whiskers Asia Minor (A.M. 1925, 56), is not found in the
…
dered also in the plastic aryballoi pi. 1, 7 and figs a few vases show no trace at all of added colour in
19
in the animal frieze, to the subsidiary decoration of the vase.
…
red-figured decoration gained in the late sixth century when patterns as well
…
common in the Mycenaean period, first reappears in
…
was a favourite motive in textiles or embroideries
…
though it does not explain the technique in which the
…
in many Protocorinthian and Transitional vases (e.g.
20
less good (except, of course, in the case of the alabastra and pointed aryballoi
…
late Protocorinthian category as defined in my own catalogue; but I have
…
have seen already that in the preceding periods large vases, particularly oinochoai
…
I cannot expect my reasons for disagreeing with Johansen in this matter to
…
over and over again in the vases which are generally recognized as Proto-
21
chrome scale pattern is found in later phases of the style, the peculiar elabora-
…
same group share the qualities just described in varying degrees. Johansen
…
at greater length in chs. ii and iii; here I need only say that it appears to consist
…
who speaks of Corinthian qualities in vases like those shown in pis. 8-11
…
According to Johansen's chronology, with which I am in general agree-
22
been put on exhibition in the galleries of the Pa-
…
sixth centuries, for Selinus is the only city known to have been founded in
…
We may take it that the finds from Selinus will not belong, at any rate in
…
previously kept in the magazines of the museum;
…
able speaks strongly in favour of Thucydides. For
23
from the acropolis, and in which quantities of vases and terra-cottas were
…
a few pointed aryballoi of the type shown in fig. 8 a, a few exceedingly
…
evidence of a continuation of'the Protocorinthian style' in the period of which
…
or polychrome painting. In all these three periods linear and subgeometric
…
vive after the particular period of black-figure painting in which they were
…
2 Johansen (p. 89) mentions an ovoid aryballos in
24
example, cups of the kind shown in fig. 9 B are found in very early Proto-
…
late Protocorinthian vases are contemporary with these aryballoi. In precisely
…
Now in estimating the value of this argumentum ex absentia we must bear
…
before the middle of the seventh century,2 and remained in continuous
…
current in all the civilized parts of Sicily and Italy, and that Selinus, which
25
figured, were excavated early in the last century, but apparently very little
…
Corinthian types normally found in graves with these {v. infra p. 56) are also
…
reach Naukratis in the late seventh century (see appendix ii), and this may
…
of Protocorinthian pottery in the eastern Mediterranean (Crete, Cyprus,
…
be the site of Casmenae (Holm, Gesch. Siz. i, 396). Corinthian pyxis (no. 906 in the Catalogue infra)
…
produced nothing of importance. The finds in 4 Cf. Furtwangler, Aegina i, 477; Johansen p.
…
to visit the Biscari Museum at Catania, where some early Corinthian are no. 503 b in the Catalogue and
26
Finally we have the evidence of the graves. I know of no single instance in
…
never found together in single-burial graves. Taken in isolation this fact
…
and subgeometric vases of the type already mentioned in connexion with
…
appear in the late Protocorinthian period. It is certain from the evidence of
…
When they occur in Corinthian graves, they represent a survival, after the
…
1 Graves which have been used more than once used several times. Professor Gabrici kindly in-
…
the graves in the small cemetery at Vroulia had been usually confused.
III: The transitional orientalizing style
28
similar in the two groups, the filling ornament usually consists of the fami-
…
separate group. Drawing, composition,subject-matter,and in many instances
…
balloi illustrated in pis. 12, 2; 15, 2-3. Johansen places the first of these in his
…
shown in pi. 11, 1-2 and 4-5 (vases not included by Johansen), we can see
…
tional vases like those shown in pis. 13-14. These last bring us to the fringe
…
illustrated in pis. 11-16, and who will set this against his impression of the
…
Chigi vase in the late Protocorinthian period. Nor is it that the Transitional
…
two styles is conveniently epitomized in the photographs of details shown in
…
Ultimately this contrast is intangible, because it is aesthetic in essence;
29
there is something distinctly mechanical about the way in which identical
…
but there is nearly always a touch of individuality in the use to which they are
…
because we shall find this tendency carried still further in Corinthian work.
…
rally compact in build. Elongation begins on Transitional vases which for
…
greater lengths. In like manner, the rendering of small details on Transitional
…
painters, and the way in which they are used, tell the same story: there are
…
Johansen pis. 20, 21, 24, 26-8, &c; N.S. 1895, 167; of the eye-socket seen in pi. 16, 6-7 (cf. pis. 12,15)
30
further, certain types which rarely appear in the late Protocorinthian period
…
eagle, or owl—in the centre. These three-figure groups are practically un-
…
regularly found are those of sphinxes, such as are illustrated in pis. 3, 1; 8, 5.
…
Of the motives which appear to be growing in popularity in the Transi-
…
number lions, till the latter are almost completely displaced in the second
…
not infrequently indicated in the later Transitional
…
in pis. 13, 5 (top row); 15, 7-9, 11, we have a new
…
in the numbers.
31
is a point of great significance in view of the later history of the style. This
…
between late Protocorinthian and Corinthian. In point of style, subject-
…
are perfectly amenable to interpretation as a link in an organic process of
…
are also a good deal larger than is usual even in the late Protocorinthian period.
…
1 The sphinx painter (nos. 137, 163-7, 187, and liarity of the goats is the drawing ofthe eye seen in pis.
…
from the others in outward appearance, but a great begins after the Transitional period, but who used
32
shown in fig. 118. There can be no doubt that fig. 118 b-c shows the later
…
the development implied in the difference between these two forms is con-
…
noticeable in the sharp angle at which the neck and shoulder meet. The late
…
significant also that the upper part of the vase is greatly diminished in propor-
…
^Compare the development in the shape of the 'Corinthian' period is to substitute curved for
IV: The relation between protocorinthian and corinthian
35
IN the preceding chapters I have tried to avoid the controversy which the
…
series. This arrangement appears to me the only one possible in view of their
…
been brought forward in favour of this view.
…
In reopening the question, I would suggest, first that it is really important to
…
thian vases is unquestionably a matter of importance in this connexion, for
36
in pi. 36 as typical examples of the 'Corinthian style', and consequently to use
…
and, through these, with the Protocorinthian, that we are in a position to
…
its most detailed exposition, and its ablest defence, in Johansen's book; in
…
As the period in question is that which saw the rise of the Corinthian school,
…
is something 'new and original':1 it begins in the latest Protocorinthian
…
origin of the Protocorinthian series must be sought in another centre.
…
field. And yet, attractive as it is, the 'separatist' theory fails in one essential
37
portant series of vases decorated in the so-called dot-rosette style. It has
…
vases incline now to one side, now to the other, and in general defy exact
…
The separatist theory is compelled to deal with this intermediate series in a
…
other; it is not part of a systematic process of evolution: it is what, in terms
…
buted to different centres, but could scarcely have been formed in the course
…
rather difficult criterion to handle in these cases; is the red-ground style of
38
would suggest that our use of this criterion in archaeology must always be
…
that there is external evidence in favour of the separate origin of the Proto-
…
(2) Pointed aryballos in the Louvre, from Italy (Johansen 172, fig. 115).
…
which is certainly not Corinthian, may be Sicyonian, but this opinion is in
…
Sicyon.5 There is therefore no evidence that the z sigma was in use at Sicyon
39
as Rumpf1 has recently suggested, but in any case it cannot solve the
…
learnt his alphabet, but not where he painted the vase. In this connexion the
…
mostly of the linear styles (e.g. of early kotylai like Johansen pis. 9, 17), in
…
very similar letter was still used for sigma, but in
…
in Boston, signed by Pyrrhos, because, as Furtwan-
40
So much for the positive evidence in favour of the view here adopted: it
…
view, as we have seen in ch. ii, is definitely at variance with the evidence both
…
tions which transformed vase-painting at Corinth in the late seventh century,
41
there is a certain a priori improbability in the view that Corinth was content
…
does not belong to Corinth lies a difficulty in imagining that the minute and
…
For there are Protocorinthian vases quite as rough in execution as the
…
in Attica, Boeotia, the islands, Eastern Greece, and the far west, often to the
…
from the simplicity of Protocorinthian painting to especially 2; pi. 29, 2 which looks far neater in the
V: The early cornthian orientalizing style
43
IN the last quarter of the seventh century the orientalizing style enters on
…
it was only in the last fifteen or twenty years of the century that the new style
…
is, on the whole, foreign to pre-Corinthian vase-painting.1 The change in
…
Transitional alabastra of pi. 15, and obviously may be in part contemporary
…
The four kinds of round aryballoi are illustrated in figs. 123-5, 128 (cf.
…
group', with shape and patterns as in fig. 123, style as in pi. 21, 5-8 and 10-11;
…
here, are contemporary: they are found in the same graves, and, though in a
…
pp. 18, 31-2, and the remarks in the catalogue pp. there are three pre-Corinthian examples.
44
. they are not uniform in style (since there is much variety of pattern and
…
nos. 746-7, one of which is illustrated in pis. 24, 2; 26, 7: both are carefully
…
see in discussing the external evidence for chronology (p. 55ff.), have been
…
longs to a particular group, which in some respects stands outside the ordinary
…
as a whole, the series illustrated in pis. 17-26 represents a single tradition and
…
exactly parallel in style to the oinochoai here illustrated, are mentioned in the
…
early alabastra and aryballoi) will show, are distinctly in the manner of the
45
19, 2. It is in every way a remarkable piece, and is certainly the best example
…
number of vases decorated in this style, and that these probably belong to
…
from some other series which we know to be later still. In precisely the same
…
understanding of the subjects which it portrays. In a few cases, certainly,
…
and cocks; the different renderings of these are was chiefly interested in human figures: contrast the
46
late Corinthian involves no progress in this sense, merely a difference in
…
principle involved: even confections like those illustrated in pi. 36 have an
…
animals running round the centre of the vase.1 In the early Corinthian
…
into a number of comparatively narrow bands. But there is consistence in one
…
logous change in the decoration of pointed aryballoi.
…
in the Transitional olpe no. 146, which is typical of
47
applied to the vacant spaces in the field, it gave the necessary degree of unity
…
It seems likely that the new filling-ornament was chosen in part, at least, for
…
trasting surfaces, in which the single elements, animals, human figures, and
…
which we have characteristic examples in pis. 17-26. The technique is clearly
…
White, as we have seen, is used on a few Protocorinthian vases, but never in
…
for the faces of sphinxes). On a few late Transitional &c); the red patches round the eyes in pis. 19, 2;
…
generally more prominent even than in the late 3 Cf. p. 11, note 3.
48
date in the early Corinthian period, for it is used by the 'sphinx painter' on
…
period; the connexion is,perhaps,clearest in the case of the small alabastra
…
find as a rule in earlier work.
…
in fig. 11. These elongated figures are absolutely unknown on Protocorin-
…
preted in the same sense : thus one of the favourite
…
illustrated in this book. The origin of this massive
49
difference of temperament which is clear evidence of a difference in time.
…
it cannot claim. And that, after all, is not surprising, for in the earlier seventh
…
the panthers of the types seen in pis. 10, 20, 24;
…
shown only in the late Transitional period (pi. 15):
…
elaborate form seen in pi. 15. The form shown in
…
the complex drawing of the shoulder in pis. 19,20;
…
on rib and thigh marks, in addition to picking them
…
The elaboration of detail which we find in vases
50
a comparatively recent experience. In Corinthian vase-painting, in the con-
…
Early as they stand in the history of Greek art, they represent the closing
…
terest in the later seventh centurv: but it is undeniable that the centre of
…
In discussing the Transitional vases, we noticed the beginning of the new
…
will show. In general, the preference of the period is for the schemes which
…
(p. 29), very little of this in Protocorinthian vases: and the particular form of
…
1 The favourite stereotyped compositions for small still unknown in the Transitional period, is typical
51
world is implied in the freedom with which early Corinthian artists added
…
carefully maintained in the earlier period, confusing fabulous creatures with
…
the rest first appear in the early Corinthian style.
…
appears in the late Transitional style.10 Another new motive, borrowed from
…
kind drawn in the black-figure technique.
…
they are constantly more and more in evidence. In
…
23, and the monster seen in fig. 6.
…
olpe Brit. Mus. 60. 2. 1. 18 illustrated in J.H.S. pi.
52
corinthian and Transitional types pass into the early Corinthian period in
…
We have as yet said little of the vase-shapes employed in the early Corin-
…
Corinth in the late seventh century, others were borrowed from abroad. In
…
the round aryballoi of the types shown in figs. 124-5, the neck-amphora, and
…
as to the history of individual shapes will be found in the catalogue.
53
tained at an advanced period in the seventh century. Ionia is shown to have
…
realize that in these earlier styles it is simply one of many motives, and one of
…
favourite Corinthian floral complex, an example of which is shown in fig.54E,
…
rosettes are scattered in fields decorated with 2 For Protocorinthian examples, see p. 31; Proto-
54
influence. This has already been pointed out in connexion with the horses of
…
be little doubt that the Hittite type, which is prevalent in the earlier seventh
…
are all fortuitous. It is, after all, by no means unlikely that in the later seventh
…
textiles and embroideries, should have reached Corinth in sufficient quantity
…
portation of these substances, largely, no doubt, from the East, was also in
…
common in the sixth century. The earliest examples
55
of any kind should turn his head. Early in the seventh century, when such
…
There is not much evidence of Ionian influence in the early Corinthian
…
Protocorinthian and Corinthian are never found in the same graves. It
…
associated in graves. But granted that the vases found in one grave will be
…
on an oriental shape, very common in Ionia : for the
…
Cretan in origin. The spotted deer of no. 114 A
56
thian style proper. Now these types (figs. 8-9) are not found in any graves
…
Syracuse tomb 178 (op. cit. 127). Kotyle as in fig. 9 a, but with tongues at the
…
Gela tomb 173 (Mon. Ant. xvii, 108 ff.). Kotyle as in Johansen pi. 17, 2;
…
Megara Hyblaea tomb 632. Group by one skeleton: kotyle as in fig. 9 c;
…
with concave sides, no. 667; kotyle as in fig. 9 a.
…
Cf. also Syracuse, tomb 57 (p. 34 supra). More graves are quoted in the
57
kotyle as in other graves previously quoted, but with smaller rays, and there-
…
were no vases of specifically Protocorinthian type in this grave, but there were
…
earlier grave Rhitsona no. 13 (op. cit. 346 ff.). In conclusion, I will mention
…
evidence of the style in which they are decorated this evidence would not be
…
impossible to place with certainty. I have mentioned all such cases in the
…
orientalizing style in the middle of the sixth century. It is possible that the
VI: The middle and late cornthian orientalizing styles
58
present insoluble. The principal difficulty is in distinguishing the vases of
…
lems, but it is none the less important. There are many cases in which we
…
that the best way of outlining the development in the first half of the sixth
…
and the end of the story clearly determined, we shall be in a fair position to
…
admitted to belong to a late date. In these the design is painted, not on the
…
be placed, roughly speaking, in the second quarter of the sixth century.
…
style in the late Corinthian period, or at any rate of one phase of it.
59
two groups. In the first group we have ordinary black-figure work ; in the
…
tant beside the general change in the conception of form. Further, let us
…
Lest it should be thought that this style is found only in the subsidiary
…
craters with figure scenes have subsidiary decoration in a totally different
…
and it happens that we have no useful records of the contexts in which these
…
but not in quantity; they are conspicuously absent partially drawn across the black surface of the boar's
60
of these, kotylai, were decorated with animal friezes in a style which is closely
…
late vases are almost all in poor taste;7 there are plenty of bad vases in
…
in grave 51.
…
7 The highest level of b.f. work in this period may
61
appeal to the creative imagination;1 (2) the wholesale change in the repertory
…
have completely disappeared; some, like the small alabastron, survive in a
…
treated in the same manner, and for the moment flourished exceedingly (cf.
…
tainty it should not be difficult to fill in the middle period. But a moment's
…
But in the process of disintegration different styles evidently existed side by
…
1 The only regular motives are sphinxes, sirens, 2 Certain parts are usually still treated in the b.f.
…
merated on p. 51, and more completely in ch. vii. in which whole figures are drawn in outline.
62
of a fairly exact chronology for Attic painting; in an appendix at the end of
…
(no. 853 and ff.), which in their turn lead back to a large class of orientalizing
…
vases correspond so closely in shape and subsidiary decoration with the
…
style with one of these cups (cf. pi. 33, 3 and 11)2 was found in a grave at
…
the same group.4 Similar amphoriskoi have been found in tombs at Taranto,
…
The handles are set a little below the offset rim, in Boston, not the vase from Samos; the obverse is an
63
have handles in the form of women's heads, as well as painted decoration. A
…
collected here (many of them are mentioned in the catalogue), we can dis-
…
and various others not cited individually in the 1148, 1308; intermediate between the two groups:
…
examples are mentioned under nos. 880-94. and several of the same shape as nos. 916-19, in
64
oinochoe illustrated on pi. 20 and in fig. 11. PI. 30,9, from a scale-pattern
…
oinochoe appears in a form which is definitely later than that current in the
…
The style is illustrated in pi. 30, 5 and fig. 140 bis. The drawing is very like
…
difference in character. A number of other craters which are mentioned on
…
(p. 62 and cf. also infra). I should therefore place this group in the earlier
…
The nucleus of this group is formed by pyxides with handles in the form of
…
with the tradition illustrated in pi. 28, 10-12; that is not surprising, for we
65
decorated with animals of various kinds, drawn in a handsome heraldic style,
…
We are now, perhaps, in a position to look back over the period which
…
that the early Corinthian was a style which took particular pleasure in bold
…
2 The same style recurs in the pyxis no.892, column is shown in pi. 30, 7).
VII: Natural history
67
vases; panthers, which begin to displace lions in the early Corinthian period,
…
to different oriental models: there is, of course, no sharp break in the tradi-
…
examples is almost identical, even in small details, with a well established
…
great depth from the nose down to the chin. But the lions illustrated in
…
Furtwangler,Kl. Schr. ii, pi. 22; Graf pi. 14, 385,&c. Ausgrab. in Sendschirli pis. 45, 47 &c, &c).
68
my mind, equally clear, though in this instance we do not know that Crete
…
phon kotyle, pi. 4, 1-2, or with the fragments illustrated in pi. 6.1 Other
…
is usual in Hittite round-sculpture.2 These Hittite works are of course
…
1 In addition to the remarkable general resemblance that of pi. i, 7; the 'mane,' fig. 13 b, with that
…
renderingof thepawsseen in fig. 13 a with that of pis. 2 Cf., for instance, Johansen pi. 24, 3 and pi. 36,1
69
the lekythos in Berlin;2 they introduce us to the Assyrian type which prevails
…
in the points of resemblance; and these are unmistakable. Not only is the
…
Hittite. Other indications of Assyrian influence in the
…
appears early in the sixth century, the massive heraldic
…
15a),5 it appears in a particular form which is, per-
…
and on many Argive-Corinthian plaques (cf. fig. 15B).9 The style in all these
…
eye-socket in fig. 11 (cf. Weber, Ass. Plast. pi. 14
…
much smaller in proportion to the whole than in
…
lotus. The affix in Berlin is said to have been found
…
9 See p. 226. In fig. 15 b the raised forelegs seem
70
other school. The related design, in which the lions are standing, also appears
…
pi. 50, 7) is illustrated in pi. 37,6; on the hydria no. 1449, pi. 37, 3, we have
…
or circles (e.g. pis. 17, 9-10; 22, 4); the lion's mane is never rendered in this
…
period. There is little change in the types.
…
3 Examples: pis. 14, 17, 22-4. Note the resem- iv,pl. 3). The stylization of the dewlap in the Europa
…
23), and is a good deal nearer in style to the metope deer with spotted coat. Often there seems to be a
…
thian boars never show the break in the centre of the pi. 13, 5; 23,4; 29,5). The hornless doe (pis. 8,9;
…
Schr. i, 488), is characteristic of the Ionian type. The 6 Atypical Corinthian goat is shown in pi. 25,5; the
…
4 Examples pis.9,11, 13,21-3,25; on Corinthian, (e.g.pi. 14 or nos. 39,675,688,^.); in this horns are
71
how closely, in the early phases of the style, they preserve the characteristics
…
the other evidence of Assyrian influence at Corinth in the latter part of the
…
pi. 38, i,4 the figures of which are not far removed in type or in quality from
…
similar in both cases, though the Cretan character, which still lingers in the
…
is based in part on certain untenable assumptions— by Prof. Beazley.
…
vase, whereas of course it is really very late, and is in 4 The 'flame mane' on these horses is unusual
72
ground.2 This position is, of course, impossible in nature, and represents a
…
Cretan (cf. Johansen fig. in, and the early Proto- Pferdedarstellung p. 15.
73
incorrectly drawn in this way.1
…
from the weight of the body; the position is not simply more nearly in
…
1 Cf. also the crater pi. 33, 5, which dates from the 4 Nearchos' horses are definitely in advance of
…
3 Further, in fig. 37, we have perhaps the earliest type of the Francois vase. Cf. also the Cretan mitrae
74
natural expression of the liking for elaborate polychromy which develops in
…
The amusing little horseman seen in fig. 19 bis is probably the earliest
…
been in the Louvre, on de Ridder's remark: Quibus multis
…
in these frontal groups was, no doubt, a move first made in
…
3 Attic examples are commonest in the time of
…
and the bronzes from Eleutherae discussed in ch. xv.
…
metope from Selinus see Gaebler in Jahrbuch 1926,
…
passim. Very rare in Corinthian except in the
…
of heraldic group: pi. 15,1-3, &c; in field: 986,1471,
76
with Corinthian artists in the late seventh century.2 On the alabastron no. 375.
…
which is a little more developed). In fig. 20 b we
…
tail. In Attica a parallel development took place:
…
probably influenced the development in Attica. See
…
white necks and white floral ornament as in pi. 42)
…
in J.H.S. 1927, 223 (Danae).
…
reins in chariot-groups: fig. 45 a, and nos. 1176,
…
which occur on Corinthian vases. Probably, in
77
he is represented in a very primitive form, with the snake body growing from
…
Chalcidian hydria in Munich.4 It is this last-mentioned vase which pro-
…
correct—and there is no reason to doubt it—Boreas was also represented in
…
in all cases, and the name must be regarded as a conventional term. See
…
next earliest picture is shown in fig. 22 A; here likewise he is swimming, as
78
he is on the aryballos no. 628. Later we find him splashing in the surf,fig. 22 B;
…
examples (p. 148); a third is shown in pi. 8, 8. On later vases they are
…
me is given by a 'Proto-Melian'2 amphora in Mykonos. Here we have a
…
2 See J.H.S. 1926, 210. are represented walking, not flying, with a bird in
…
In Corinthian examples the wings always spring group of two lions attacking a man (cf. C.V.A.
…
pi. 7,12; no. 357, and a similar vase in New York though she is very small in proportion to the animals,
79
therefore absolutely symmetrical (as in the Rhodian gold and silver plaques),
…
figured oinochoe in Paris.3
…
part in the development of the idea, an opinion which is shared by Ziegler5 in
…
In publishing his new Syracusan gorgon (fig. 23 e), surely one of the
…
and I think that a mere statement of the extent of the Corinthian material in
…
gone, 94; Pettazzoni in Boll. d'Arte, 1922, 491 ff.;
81
showed a gorgon in pursuit of Perseus; see A.D. 11 text p. 6, and
…
In all, nearly fifty examples; nine of them full figures; and to these we must
…
in further detail.
…
tional examples have certain essential features in common which enable us to
84
the low forehead of the Protocorinthian type; and in several others the spiral
…
point in common, the enormous relative proportion of the head to the body; the
…
is in essence the same as that between the satyrs of the fifth century and those
…
In the red-ground period there is little change, but figs. 27 B-C show that
…
and all more convincingly because in all but one or two cases the classification
…
We have, I think, to recognize a further fact in connexion with the Corin-
…
they have no snakes or other specific attributes of the gorgon proper. In the
…
2 Contrast the Acropolis gorgon Dickins no. 701 whole treatment of face and body in fig. 23 E is mani-
85
Perseus on the Thermon metopes, Perseus carrying the gorgon-head in his
…
Corinthian version of the story; we find it again in the Corfu gable, where
…
bined Cretan and Corinthian forms in the Etruscan this series of metopes, retains much of the character
86
If further proof be needed that in cases where we have no Pegasos or
…
Thermon metope,fig.23D,then on the Corfu gable and in the later Corinthian
…
know whether Argos played any part in giving the gorgon story pictorial form;
…
appear in Attica at the time when Corinthian influence in Attic vase-painting is
…
3 Scut. Her. 216 ff. Actually, the Perseus of the given to Athena, in all versions it was carried away,
…
there we clearly have a fanciful description of the 5 Compare the explicit accounts of the story in
87
Corinthian examples. In the Delos aryballos fig. 24 C we clearly have a form
…
which correspond broadly to the early sixth-century type seen in fig. 25 E.
…
1 A.Z. 1882, pis. 9, 10: Furtwangler, Kleine 3 This is especially clear in the treatment of the
88
similar to this, but was partly drawn in reserve (see p. 192). The gorgons of
…
An altogether different type of gorgon seems to have been in vogue in Ionia
…
lished amphora in Mykonos (shield device).
…
have certain points in common, and with the exception of no. 7, which is
…
gorgoneia in the strict sense, but they are obviously mova pi. 25, no. 98 and p. 163) are certainly early
89
tradition originated in Corinth and passed to Attica; from about the middle
…
independently by decorators in many parts. None the less, this usage seems
…
further in ch. xvii.
…
sphinx is almost always depicted in a seated position; the Protocorinthian-
…
examples, one of which is shown in fig. 28, are
…
3 Nearer to the Daedalic types in position and pro-
90
before it came to be connected with the Oedipus story. For in the very early
…
In addition to the very full treatment of the subject by Ilberg in Roscher's
…
in question are griffons; functions of this kind are
…
authority's article in Roscher, iv (Sirenen). There
…
motive, gaining in popularity in the late P-C period;
…
14, &c.); generally replaced in the middle and^late
…
can rank as a Greek invention (Rumpf, Veii 49), in
…
in which the goat's head grows on a 'wing' from the
…
late period. In all cases they have human legs.
91
whose body ends in a phallus—a shield device on the crater no. 1170.
…
Greek form is, however, known in the East (cf., for
…
to arrive in Greece; it appears in Attica in the
…
11 On Corinthian vases, passim, especially in the late
…
12 Pyxis (early Corinthian ?) in Palermo. Cf. also
…
15 Pyxis with convex sides in Palermo; cf. the
VIII: The corinthian figure style
92
Kalydon 3 in Aetolia.
…
inestimably precious as the only actual examples of free painting in the
…
There is, of course, a continuous tradition of work in the ordinary silhouette
…
lizing painter;4 the former will deviate, now in one direction, now in another,
93
brilliant development of polychrome figure painting which culminates in the
…
ments freely with outline drawing; lastly, in the second quarter of the sixth
…
actual examples in the Thermon metopes; the metopes are certainly post-
…
last phase of the Corinthian style in the second quarter of the sixth century.
…
Poseidon and Amphitrite, are clearly reproductions in miniature of paintings on
…
gods was Poseidon holding a tunny in one hand.2 Another was of the cap-
94
vases, the aryballoi in the Louvre, Berlin, and Boston illustrated by Johansen
…
35,3. The second begins with the Berlin centauromachy published in colours
…
corinthian period.3 In isolation, the drawing would be difficult to date,
…
The earliest of the polychrome vases are the centauromachy aryballos in
…
and part of one, drawn from an enlarged photograph, in fig. 29 A. When the
…
in the Protocorinthian geometric style. The small
…
phon on the early vase in Boston (Johansen pi. 30, 2)
95
scene in the same manner as the vases which have just been described.1
…
The origin of this complex polychrome style has often been sought in de-
…
in the seventh century had two techniques for executing figurative decoration
…
1 It is peculiar, however, in that the figures are
96
and ends of jewellery in which enamelling is employed to pick out decorative
…
nique is not the only thing that is new in these vases. Three of them at least
…
tion of spatial values which we find in ordinary seventh-century work. The
…
in this connexion has already been stressed,2 but I should like to go into the
…
1 Cf. Marshall, Catalogue of the Jewellery in the don and Aedon: note the geometric sharpness with
…
3 The following points appear to me sufficient with hair rendered as in Protocorinthian vases, and
…
v. infra. (2) The drawing of the torsos of Cheli- certain heaviness and angularity in the drawing,
97
is the resemblance between the colouring of the metopes and of the vases: in
…
Though the fragment is in itself insignificant, it has a particular interest, for
…
like those of the figures in the other polychrome Protocorinthian vases, are
…
first and last, showing us draped figures drawn with extreme care in outline
…
difference in comparing the earliest antefixes, which clay ground), as in the vases and at Thermon. Fine
98
(the new fragment in the lower left-hand corner).
…
draw the torso in profile, with consequent protrusion
…
the cloak. We can trace a long progress in the
…
and is to be dated in the latter part of the sixth
…
Diasand Thoas), by Studniczka in A.M. 1899,391 ff.
99
deed, we should expect in view of the greatly increased output of vases. The
…
connected with the Protocorinthian black-figure tradition illustrated in
…
shields are always larger than in most Protocorinthian and other very early
…
Chigi vase are large, as in Corinthian, and they
…
in pi. 31,1 and fig. 29 c. In this last instance we have a clear connexion with
…
could not be paralleled in Corinthian vases: the
…
batants in fig. 31 and pi. 21, 6 (contrast fig. 29 a),
…
definitely more substantial. In fact, although the
…
shields only touch, as in Protocorinthian (nos. 719 a,
…
4 In such a case one must judge primarily by the
100
B. Large vases in mixed technique.
…
ing scene, a fit subject for a picture, drawn partly in outline; on the back,
…
usual archaic delight in cheerful decorative detail. In certain respects this
…
painter's stock-in-trade in the late seventh century.
101
shown in figs. 34-8 will show that he is right f further, that Iole on the Eury-
…
it is difficult to judge a small drawing like the Athena of fig. 45 a in this respect.
…
women's dresses is clearly in harmony with this view. The same scheme is
…
A. Small vases in black-figure technique.
…
of the Delphic Kouroi,5 shows a real advance. An early date in the sixth
…
fig. 35 a, b). These give us a series of female heads drawn in reserve which
102
from the more accomplished rendering of the draped figures of Athena in
…
we have a work of the same period in the crater pi. 34,7. Indeed the resem-
…
is clear,is it not, that there are many new features in pi. 34,7. The drawing of
103
freedom of movement. But the advance in the matter of composition is even
…
painter of the crater pi. 34, 7 is obviously more at ease in disposing a frieze of
…
which is not found in any earlier work, the wounded warrior retreating, who
…
Helen, pi. 33, 5. In the drawing of the figures and in the composition these
…
number of related vases and fragments are mentioned in the catalogue.
…
often placed in the late Corinthian period. I have of Troilos in comparison with those of Theseus. The
104
individual imagination particularly striking in the impersonal age to which it
…
bably in imitation of Attic vase-painters, who had already discovered how to
…
The background of the picture, or often the whole vase, is no longer left in
…
pyxides were scarcely ever decorated in the new, elaborate, style.6
…
Altgr. Tracht, 96; Robert in Hermes, 1901, 387; 1471.
105
painters show an interest in colour for its own sake.
…
network of gay, outspoken, colours, matched against one another in equal
…
between Attic and Corinthian in the second quarter of the sixth century does
…
The part which is allotted to the subsidiary patterns in the late Corinthian
…
vase occurs on a fragment in Corinth; on red-ground oinochoai, hydriai, &c. passim.
106
more elaborate technique, but by definite advances in drawing and composi-
…
the shapes used in the red-ground style.
…
inaugurate a new tradition in the his-
…
drawing in the late Corinthian period.
…
archaic as those of Sophilos.5 The general tendency of the time, reflected in
…
begin their history in the early sixth century.
…
shapes occur in the light-ground technique, there is
107
that escaped his predecessors—of this the figures illustrated in pi. 40, 3 are
…
body in profile shows a similar advance. The earlier nude type is seen in the
…
The developed stage is seen in the figure of Hippotion on the Amphiaraos
108
2; Gaz. Arch. 1880,104, fig. 1, and the fragment shown for the first time in
…
Draped women occur in two schemes, both already familiar
…
rendering in which alternate sections of the dress were
…
no improvement on this beginning,4 and in much later work, which cannot be
…
in B.S.A. 1925/6,126 fig. 1, than in A.D. ii, pi. 50,1).
…
visible in the photograph pi. 39, 2), the hydria no.
109
elaborately drawn folds in the manner of the Brygos painter make a sudden
…
the correct rendering in profile of the chariot rail.1 The orientalizing
…
ground series. Closely connected with it are the fragments in Delphi and
…
of these is illustrated in pi. 41,4. They are all ordinary, careless pieces; my
…
in two olpai nos. 1407, 1407 a, and in a series of amphorae, no. 1419 and ff.
…
speaking. Two fragments from the Acropolis with sea-nymphs in much the
…
2 Note the similarity of the draped male figures in
…
found in later chariot scenes. The early date of the
110
same scene. The Acropolis fragments are in the style of Klitias, a fact which
…
artist, the painter of the Andromeda vase in Berlin (no. 1431): oinochoe,
…
the figures are all treated in the same summary fashion, with a minimum of
…
the figures in the battle scenes makes this unlikely.
…
Fig. 39. Pinax in the Louvre.
…
hip in all these vases and on no. 2; the white male
111
florid general effect, the later and more developed phase. In these last, the
…
pi. 42,1, we return to a simpler and more reserved style, comparable in many
…
Hector crater and no. 1475, of which a detail is given in fig. 36, are con-
…
The only important vase of later date is the crater in Leipzig, pi. 41, 2, the
…
the warrior in pi. 39, i; the change in the rendering of
…
style. The taste for contrasting colours in small
IX: The subject-matter of the cornthian figure style
114
IN turning to the subject-matter of the Corinthian figure style we come
…
pair,4 is that shown in pi.43, i. It varies little in essentials after the beginning
…
1 On these in general see Wrede.Kriegers Abschied, 5 The pyxis from Aegina fig. 30 gives the earliest
…
vations, and have been able to insert a few references.] composition which develops in the red-ground period.
115
same feature in contemporary Attic vase-painting, is obviously no mere
…
valuable in an age which found difficulty in expressing the quieter relations
…
that in two of the three instances where they occur, these motives are only part
…
1 On the Sophilos dinos and on the Francois vase; and the house of Hades, indicated by columns, in
…
contemporary with the Corinthian cup, or a little 2 Craters nos. 1181A, 1454; olpe no. 1409. In
…
Hypostyle, 82 ff.; R. Vallois in Rev. Arch. 1908, hydriae are the last important group of archaic
116
the principal scene; occasionally they take part in it.1 Chariots rarely come
…
vases in a scheme already known from a much earlier period; the shields how-
…
There are also pictures of men engaged in athletics* and hunting,9 of
…
2 Cf. no. 1483, and Rumpf in A. Anz. 1923-4
…
6 In addition to the examples mentioned by Lip-
…
infra). Stag-hunt: 780. The hare hunt survives in
…
the picture shown in fig. 43. Such scenes, as is well
…
7. In Etruria, on the other hand, they were very
117
Fig. 41. Pinax in the Louvre.
…
acrobat, on a fragment of a crater shown in fig. 42. On no. 1046 we have a
…
1 In the first the man is obviously in a cave (cf.
…
Richter, Craft 77, &c). In the first the potter is pro-
…
clay which is naturally forced upwards. In the
…
period. In the pinax A.D. ii, pi. 39, 16 b, we pro-
…
points out (Craft, 76) that there is no probability in
118
series as a whole, though others, such as pi. 34, 3-4, add interesting details. In
…
portant features in common with that of a well-known Assyrian relief,3 was
…
Corinthian series is clearly the most important in the early archaic period.
…
but are unknown in the Protocorinthian and Transitional styles. They have
…
The dress regularly worn by these dancers is a short chiton, in most cases,
…
2 On Corinthian hetairai see Navarre in D.S. iii,
…
in the late seventh century, see p. 53.
…
and hetaira as in Corinthian; cf. an amusing frag-
…
7 Nude men and padded women take part in the
120
they are human beings engaged in some act of devotion (or diversion?), or
…
dancers occur in mythological contexts, so that they seem to be at home in a
…
But even if it be granted that in several scenes we undoubtedly have
…
arguments in favour of the view that they are mortal worshippers.
…
Schnabel certainly approaches the matter from the right point of view in
121
connexion is suggested by a phiale in Athens, no. 1004. The vast majority of
…
known from literature, and Schnabel certainly goes too far in claiming that
…
by no means identical with the descriptions of the Kordax steps, occur in
…
grounds, was danced in her honour at Elis, partly because Artemis and a
…
a wine-crater and have drinking-horns in their hands, combined with the fact
…
1 Cf. for example fig. 44 b, right, which recalls 4 A possible exception is the alabastron in Syracuse,
122
vase in Wiirzburg (fig. 44b) a goat stands by the crater round which they are
…
a well-known crater in the Louvre (no. 1178: wine thieves (a) detected, (b)
…
obviously a burlesque of the kind known to have been current in Laconia,4
…
to be taken as a unity. There is a fragmentary pinax in Berlin which should be
…
actor in a burlesque in which the god is represented.9
…
found in the works quoted.
123
as daemonic even when scenes in which they occur are undoubtedly mytho-
…
daemonic, like silens or maenads, seems exceedingly doubtful. In any case it
…
in a fixed type with very little variation; from the extraordinary number of
…
stage scene: a little by-Hay of this kind would be 6 Frankel in Rhein. Mus. 1912 gives a very long
…
the other crater there is nothing at all to suggest 7 Dancers on Laconian vases: dinos in the Louvre,
…
god and his satyrs take part in a procession of dancers: this because I have heard it suggested that
124
Corinthian influence is strongest in the earliest phase of the Chalcidian style).2
…
of Meidian style in Leningrad, which represents the preparations for a
…
in style.5
…
Corinthian artists in this department of early Greek art. It will be understood
…
importance both in creating and in popularizing many of the forms in which
125
in Attica in the third, fourth, and succeeding decades. When we have a more
…
We are fortunate in that we are able to supplement the evidence of Corin-
…
mythological subjects—and that in the third quarter of the seventh century;1
…
After the third quarter of the sixth century the interest in narrative shows a
…
ment of the bronze industry shows us yet another aspect of the decline in the
…
1916, 1 ff. We will take the various groups of myths in the order of their
…
with a lion's head defies explanation (cf. B.S.A. dot-rosettes is exactly in the late Protocorinthian
126
Furtwangler was wrong in saying that Herakles wields a club. The weapon,
…
1895 pi. 14); Herakles attacks the lion in a scheme familiar
…
Iolaos on the right, with apir-q; behind Iolaos a length of hydra in mid-
…
a sword; Iolaos with apirrj as in no. 1. Crab attacks Iolaos ? On the left,
…
4. Crater, no. 1194 (see appendix i). Fragmentary. Part of Herakles as in the
…
1916,440 ff.; Gervasio, Bronzi e Vasi di Bari, 205 ff.; Corinthian Beta, S, occurs twice in the shoulder
…
inscriptions can be seen in the Cesnola Atlas (ii. pi. Corinthian epsilon (as well as an Attic) :abev5"
128
same subject in a different form. The hydra is no longer in the centre;
…
hydra scene with Iolaos' chariot in side view to the right, Iolaos looking back
…
These differ in varying degrees from the Corinthian scheme. In none of them
…
I know of four Laconian versions, a sherd from Naukratis in Oxford,
129
the probability that such a subject would find pictorial form in the Argolid
…
means omitted, but implied: for the weapons (bow in case, quiver, and sword)
…
as well as antithesis, and Hermes, with the bowl in his hands, forms an
…
ground, as that is not indicated elsewhere. The picture, in antithesis tells us that Herakles' meal was
130
said (cf. p. 230). On the chest the centaurs were no doubt in retreat, and not,
…
In both these Geryon is three-bodied and wingless; it was no doubt in this
…
[Herakles in the Garden of the Hesperides.
…
appears in this scene on the cup, recurs on the fragment no. 1190.
131
The subject appears in Attica in the middle black-figure style, and on
…
crater in Athens (12587, A.M. 1922 pi. 5), which Buschor (op. cit. p. 56)
…
painters in the second half of the sixth century; it occurs also on a Chalcidian
…
the subject, we can see from fig. 45 bis that it was cast in an unusual form. For
…
than the middle of the century, it is probably about 5 In the Shield (w. 70-1) an altar and a sacred
132
The only other story in which Herakles is concerned is the visit to the
…
on the crater) correspond to those preserved in a fragment of Hesiod (Flach, 70),
…
Robert sees a probable second version of the subject in the Assos frieze.
…
approximately in the middle of the picture). This
…
seen in both these instances will represent rows of
…
bars of the door in fig. 40 correspond likewise to
…
spear-arm in such an unusual position ? Are the
133
The Nessos story is not found on Corinthian vases, the lekythos in the
…
Amphora no. 1431. The only existing version of the subject in the archaic
…
and Berlin 1753 (Jahrbuch 1914, 183 fig. 5); in both of these we have the
…
1364 b). Considerably earlier than this fragment, which is in the red-ground
134
Wolters in Miinzer, Cacus, Progr. Basel, 1911, pp. 6-7.
…
Peleus lying in wait for Thetis.
…
but occurred on the chest of Cypselus; we find it in contemporary Attic vase-
…
generally to escape notice. The version of the story in which Paris makes
…
1 Anti's arguments depend on slight differences in
135
in fig. 48.1
…
Aineas; the occasion is that related in II. xiv, 4026°. (Schneider 20, 21).
…
chidas, in chariot; horses Xanthos, Balios, and Pheres.
136
view in Hermes 1901, 391 ff., showing that on the vase Achilles is depicted
…
more intelligible since the visit of Thetis with the armour is placed earlier in
…
Hekuba in front of him; their clothes distinguish
…
I think that traces of a beard are visible; in any case
…
because draped). A man in such a predicament as
…
tion of the palace. The figure in the corner will be
137
Protocorinthian aryballos in Berlin (Johansen 144 and pi. 23, 2a).
…
fig. 334. As Johansen points out, no. 1 gives the composition in its most
…
Early vase-painters in general show very little interest in the adventures of
…
The blinding of Polyphemos. Alabastron in New York, fig. 159, of the
…
in an impoverished form on a very bad column-crater in the Louvre (E 616,
…
1 The subject is treated in detail by Schmidt, 5 ko.1 avaKXivdels ireoev vtttlos (ix, 371).
138
frequently painted white in the late Corinthian period. The fugitive is there-
…
fig. 64; on these, and on the subject in general, see
…
Wandmalereien in Veii, has since proved.
…
5 There is one vase, a cup in Wurzburg (Annali
139
cited in the catalogue. Bulle's commentary on the scene seems to me more
…
literature cited on p. 98. For the winged horses in a Corinthian marriage
…
tance of this vase lies in (1) the correspondence between the principal scene
…
an Attic amphora in Florence 2 and a ' Pontic' in Munich,3 show the same
…
1 In addition to the literature cited in the catalogue 2 No. 3373; Thiersch pi. 3; F.R. iii, pp. 4, 5,
140
crater in Berlin are; the house of Amphiaraos—of which we have the Megaron
…
tioned by Pausanias. In face of such an extraordinarily close correspondence
…
served part of the necklace in the top right-hand corner. There was a second
…
shows that Hauser's argument in favour of this view
…
revenge in mind; the literary evidence tells us that
…
the opposite). And finally there is some force in
…
next to Amphiaraos and Baton in the Argive votive
141
least obscured. A second stage, therefore, in the history of the legend; or
…
back at wife and child, in the act of drawing his sword. The identification
…
Neck-amphora no. 1437^1.40, 1. The same subject occurs in a rather
…
the task is certainly in keeping with what one knows of that hero's character,
…
elsewhere (cf. e, g. Pfuhl fig. 150). For the draped from Curtius in several points (p. 251, note 4).
142
differences—many more, indeed, than in the case of the Amphiaraos story (on
…
Dionysos;6 the woman in front, one of the'Nysai',7 attendants onDionysos;
…
period. It appears in Attica about the middle of the sixth century, and is not
…
Attic; the use of E for Epsilon can be paralleled in
…
Hephaestus is treated at length in this article. Other
X: Floral ornaments
144
have a distinctive charm. Corinthian artists were much interested in this
…
There is one point in which the Corinthian
…
Fig. 51. Floral ornaments from Rhodian scarcelY ever rendered in silhouette, with
…
variably in the outline technique.3
…
plexes are constructed. In fig. 511 show two characteristic Rhodian ornaments
…
1 Floral motives are rarely used in this way on Pro- the degradation, of a Protocorinthian design,
…
illustrated in fig. 54: here the Protocorinthian mentioned on p. 8 (cf. pi. 5, 2 and fig. 4); oinochoe
145
which at once places them in another category. They are always constructed
…
accurate, for in the late period, perhaps under Ionian influence, there is a
…
in which the lotus has a rounded calyx, and one large central bud enclosed
…
ingly common, especially in the forms shown in figs. 55, h-k; 56, &c. With
…
Late versions, from red-ground vases, are seen in fig. 52, e, and on no. 1435:
146
Quadruple lotus and derivatives. A, in b.f. technique: fig. 53 ; the earliest
…
early, no. 524; middle and late, nos. 831 and 1286, 1334 a. In the latter we
…
B, in outline technique. This pattern can be traced back to the late Proto-
…
early Corinthian period: in any case it is closely connected with no. 30 c.
147
the latter, moreover, are stylized in a way which might easily degenerate into
…
from Assyria.1 In view of other evidence of influence from the same source
…
of the same shape as the vase in the Vatican we find a derivative, and less
…
the 'quatrefoil' ornament shown in fig. 54,e. In the quatrefoil pattern, the
148
In this form the pattern is found on round aryballoi, not of the shape A,
…
need to describe in detail here. In some the horizontal lotuses disappear
…
probably also very late, is shown in fig. 54, h.2 In the final phase, which is
…
Corinthian ornaments. It is found in the Protocorinthian period (Johansen
…
3 Already known at Corinth in the late Protocorin-
…
florid in form, is found on a few late Corinthian vases:
149
Typical examples from red-ground vases are shown in fig. 55, h-j;1 an unusual
…
further in the process of elaboration, and directly type; the proportions are probably not quite
150
the fondness for the 'budding lotus' (in fig. 55, h, and henceforward), and the
…
cups (p. 194), and occur fairly often in other Attic black-figured vases;2 they
…
some interest, for it was a favourite motive in Corin-
…
is done in fig. 56.5
…
in the first there is a close analogy, in construction and in the rendering
…
Thiersch p. 71, no. 4; lekanis in Palermo; &c.
151
of details, to the very early antefixes of the type shown in fig. 106.1 Ornaments
…
true, a favourite motive with Corinthian artists, but in Corinthian examples the
…
resembles a common early Corinthian type in construction, though not in
152
proportions. This type is the ringed palmette, shown in fig. 58, c;1
…
late vases, this ornament is extended in the manner shown in fig. 59, A-B,
…
a rough sketch, in fig. 60; the form, however, bears no resemblance to that
…
slow to realize the possibilities of this form of decoration, for in the seventh
…
740, column crater 776; in the late period we have a 5 Cf. the alabastron no. 435, which should probably
153
The idea was taken up again in the late Corinthian period. On several of
…
Chain of single lotus-flowers. This pattern was used in the Protocorinthian
…
derived directly from the late Protocorinthian period, but differs in certain
…
those of the Chigi vase. In all these respects the chain of the Eurytios crater
…
relation which we see in the early Attic amphora,
…
attic amphora in New York which has been men-
…
amphoriskoi not mentioned individually in the cata-
154
no. 1182, is shown in fig. 62 c. The principle of construction is that which is
…
The crater no. 1186, fig. 62 e, (pi. 34,4), introduces us to a variant form in
…
(1) As in fig. 63 (pyxis no. 913).
…
the kotyle-fragment, Graf pi. 15, 416, and the that this pattern occurred in Corinthian vases.
155
orientalizing period.1 In fig. 63, the bud is introduced into a chain of ordinary
…
end of the first quarter of the sixth century. The new influences were felt in
…
part of the sixth century: we even find it in a debased form as late as the
…
in the orient (Assyria, and Egypt from the new
…
6, 8-9 &c), and is regular in the Fikellura style.
…
fifth century (cf. the row of unjoined buds in no.
156
Corinthian vases.2 It first appears in Attica about the end of the first
…
examples are shown in figs. 174 bis, 179, 195 (see the remarks s.v. in the
…
Ivy pattern. Figs. 178, 187, 195. This type appears in Attica in the early
…
all illustrated in our plates. It will suffice therefore to point out one or two
…
in pi. 36, 12, nor the pot-pourri like profusion of shrivelled petals which
…
pi. 17; very common, in a later form (with elongated 4 e.g. Albizzati pi. 19; Pfuhl fig. 162. A compara-
…
2 Nos. 868,875 a, 885, 892, 943 a, cf. also fig. 65 d, examples, was still used quite late in the fifth century:
…
3 Graf, Akropolisvasen iv, pi. 98, 2400, 2405; pi. 17. See Gow in J.H.S. 1913, 211.
XI: Inscriptions on corinthian vases
158
chischen Vaseninschriften, i6ff.)/but the material has increased in the last
…
a and a are still found in the late period (e.g. 32, 33, 62).
…
written in full (cf. A.D. i, pi. 7, 1). In the inscription of the trippers from
…
vergleichende Sprachforschung, 1887, 152 fF.; 2 b is also used here in the same word: the inscrip-
…
treatment in Collitz-Bechtel, Gr. Dialektinschriften, gler in his Catalogue, and Roehl (i.G.A. 8, no. 38)
159
again likely that e (e<) is equivalent to iota. The town in question was probably
…
Zeta may be discussed in connexion with Xi, for on three pinakes2 the
…
The Corinthian Zeta was doubtless i,3 and the occurrence of 1 in place of 1 is
…
of the problem, but it must be modified in detail. In the first place, the two
…
'about 600 b.c.' but it may well be that in votive pictures, like those of the
…
A.D. ii, pi. 30, 12 (cf. Jahrbuch 1897, 13): ibym Larfeld in the passages cited above.
160
old form persists even in the second half of the sixth century (A.D. i, pi. 7,25;
…
archaic appearance, found in Attica (Journ. Int. Arch. Num. 1905, 5 ff.
…
In the late sixth century the straight iota becomes commoner; it is the regular
…
used (in Helena), side by side with the other.5 The majority of characteristic
…
Sigma is invariably indicated by m, as in the early archaic period at Sicyon
…
tions (17, 49), others are abnormal in one way or
161
(facsimile in Boston Mus. Bull. 1922, 65; 1926, 50).
…
it for nonsense, which is unlikely in a context of perfectly intelligible inscriptions,
162
in the same way as M(kv0o?, TSpyvdos, etc.
…
possible in the interpretation of the name Aivrjrd (or Aivira), but the nominative
…
1 Previous publications give the first letter as I, but this is certainly wrong; and they read B in EMS.
163
Wilisch gives the names in the wrong order and retains the old reading Tldpmv
…
14. Bottle no. 1072 (K. 16, no. 3 ; the best version of the inscriptions is given in
…
complete; one would otherwise expect " Aafyovos" as in no. 65. On V in
164
22. Crater-fragment (handle-plate) in Cambridge, from Naukratis (B.S.A. 1898/9,
…
For ei in place of 1 cf. AeiFas on no. 7, IJpeia/ios in no. 14, Elwv in no. 49, and
…
who threw in the prospective owner's name with the pattern, on request.
166
(To-priva). K. suggests that the use of upsilon for iota in the last name shows
…
Kymatotha, from Kymatothoa (the name of a nereid on a vase in Munich and
…
right reading. There are other inaccuracies in the current readings. The A^OM
…
50. Hydria no. 1449 (K.26, no. 41; facsimile in Furtwangler's catalogue.)
167
name in the light of the Laconian word Ktrrov, which Hesychius (Schmidt ii, 487)
…
(the aspirate) for B (epsilon) may be explained on the supposition it = e, as in no. 59
…
FAXVM (on the white anta in the left-hand corner), faxu?> MAAM\ (behind the
168
Kretschmer p. 28 ; on the M in Aafyo(3o9 (?) and the R in Kco-disSpa see above
…
equivalent of 6 irah, can be explained in the light of other forms, if we allow
…
(Kretschmer p. 189, two examples : add one mentioned by Beazley, G.V. in
…
may be H not r ; the surface is in a bad state and I could not decide which
…
The names are discussed at length by Fraenkel in ' Satyr u. Bacchennamen
…
important evidence of the close connexion between the two fabrics. In addition to
…
For H in 'Avn^dras, cf. no. 50 (Adiras). On the straight iota see above, p. 160;
169
Rumpf's publication in A. Anz. 1923-4 ; the last name is unintelligible.1 On <ppovirios,
…
72. Crater-fragment in Cambridge, from Naukratis. Red ground : part of horse
…
74. Crater-fragment in Bonn. Light ground (early sixth century ?). Part of three
…
74 bis. Crater-fragments in the Cabinet des Medailles (Froehner Collection). In a
…
75. Crater no. 1170 (K. 51, § 35 ; facsimile in Furtwangler's catalogue).
…
I have no doubt that the inscriptions on a small vase in the Louvre (L 38), which
…
in the Corinthian alphabet PVKTA, FIOKE, dpBVCE, and are painted, like the figures,
XII: Plastic vases
170
mainland, in the geometric period. Such examples as exist are nearly all
…
from Syracuse illustrated in fig. 71.2 This vase was found in a very early
…
significant resemblance in one point, the technique of covering large areas
…
modelled head—is not quite satisfactorily achieved. And in the sixth and
…
otherwise, vases—perfume-vases—in the form of lions, owls, ducks, pigeons,
…
2 N.S. 1893, 470; Johansen pi. 41, 5; Maximova, unrecognizable photographs in B.S.A. xiv, 118 fig.
172
companion piece in Berlin (Johansen pi. 32) are evidently a trifle more
…
in tombs, but this proves nothing; and actually, a
…
finds is against, rather than in favour of, this theory.
…
evil from the user, or to protect the dead in the
…
notion that the vases in the shape of a helmeted
…
interpret the vases in the shape of a human foot or
…
the seventh and sixth centuries. We find them in
…
designed. There is no difference in kind between the
173
the vase from Syracuse illustrated in fig. 76,
…
the head in proportion to the whole (another
…
truly fascinating object in the shape of an egg,
174
the orifice is beneath the tail, as in all other Protocorinthian bird-vases;
…
6\ in.—a most unusual size for a Protocorinthian
…
French (red-legged) partridge. It figures both in
…
nent trait which is correctly shown in the vases just
…
tridges in general see Keller, Antike Tierwelt, ii,
…
but I am inclined to think it was orange, as in the owl
…
4 In a foot seen from below the fourth (back) toe,
…
5 Cf. fig. 77 and pi. 44, 4. In the pigeon from
175
of the qualities which we noticed in discussing the vases illustrated on pis. 5-7
…
century for the beginning of the series. The pigeon in Syracuse (Johansen,
…
and Protocorinthian plastic lions. They have a technical point in common,
…
We have already mentioned one Corinthian plastic vase—the lion in
…
in Candia (three of them from Afratf: Liv. Ann. 4, lower; &c, &c. Maximova, pi. 10, 41, is the
176
illustrated from a new photograph in pi. 44, 5.1 From the details shown in pi.
…
Pomegranates: Maximova 89. Identical types are found in Ionia, as M. points out.
…
bucranium in Boston, A.J .A. 1918, 270, fig. 11, an Attic vase
…
Rams: all of debased type: Maximova, p. 104. A fine vase in the Louvre, Maxi-
…
greater part of the body. But there are two holes in
…
is explained at length in Pottier's article. Recently
…
4 In addition to the Ionian example in Florence,
177
Hares: (i) crouching as in fig. 80 b.1 (2) Suspended, dead, as in fig. 80 a.2 The first of
…
Sphinxes: all of one type, as in fig. 81 b (British Museum A, 1133,
…
Eagle-protomes: a regular Ionian type (Maximova p. 118). A vase in the Louvre
…
the types in question have never been found on any
…
is the position of the animal in no. 151, but nothing
178
perceptibly different in style as well as in many details from the
…
of East Greek vases in the form of bull's-heads (Maximova
…
group which, in my opinion, is probably Corinthian. It is true
…
is not always a certain criterion in the case of plastic vases. No. 1 is described as 'buff':
…
example in the museum at Aegina; there is yet
179
as no. 2, but the breakage makes it impossible to be quite sure. In any case, these two
…
land: straight in the lower contour, strongly curved above, and
…
now in the Louvre (Heuzey, Cat. Fig. Ant. du Louvre pi. 7,2; Gaz. Arch. 1880 pi. 23,2;
…
is yet another, obviously Rhodian like the first four, in Boulogne (Le Musee ii, 264
…
3 Mile Maximova is quite wrong in saying that she has a beard (implying a divergence from the
180
Maximova p. 163, and add one in Oxford (C.V.A. fasc. ii).
…
modelling of the face is usually very like that of pi. 48,13-14, but in many
…
Finally, a word as to the janiform vase in the Louvre signed /cAeo/nev^? vlklov aOrjvaios
…
1 To these may be added a good example in Wiirz-
…
on an early alabastron in Geneva, and on nos. 1004,
…
work such as the bronze reliefs discussed in ch. xiv.
…
the wave-lines in archaic hair, would produce. There
XIII: Local imitations and distribution of corinthian pottery
181
one time; whether, in other words, many of the vases which we call Corinth-
…
It is founded in the first place on the inscriptions which are painted in the
…
Corinthian vases are made is a distinctive feature of the landscape in the
…
though in the second quarter of the century it began
…
were made in Italy under oriental influence (Rapp.
…
basis by Raoul-Rochette in his article Annali 1847,
182
the factor which turned the scale in favour of Corinth was undoubtedly her
…
centre of the 'Corinthian' industry; in fact, no other explanation of the facts is
…
bability in favour of the theory of local origins, and I may perhaps add that I
…
In general, it is true to say that, if we except the vases long recognized as
…
Much of the imported pottery found in Sicily has
…
In Eph. Arch. 1917, 219, some Attic pinakes are
…
Rambo that the Chigi vase is Etruscan (Lions in
…
tion to local fabrics in some of the older books.
…
types in Rhodes, Delos and elsewhere creates a
183
The basis of any attempt to decide which vases are Corinthian in the
…
overseas) recur in identical form on many sites, so that they must be attri-
…
Antiparos and the almost identical vase from San Mauro, in Sicily, published
…
peculiarity of shape, materials, and secondary decoration; in such cases I have
…
to go upon. To counterbalance this, however, there is more variety in the
…
vases to their authors—a thorough analysis of the style in this respect would,
…
Before we consider the various centres in which they were imitated let us
…
here only one or two striking examples: on p. 281 Argive Heraeum, several were found in Rhodes, one
184
than enumerate the places where examples have been found, giving, in the
…
Northern limit is the village of Ostenfeld in Bavaria.
…
ments have been found there in great quantities (see p. 39). As long ago as
…
Corinth early in the sixth century: among the earliest are the kotyle p. 196,
…
an Ionian alabastron (sixth century) at Oxford; a faience aryballos in the
185
Anz. 1925,333 ; Sicyon (Protocorinthian, Johansen,p.87): several in Bologna,
…
B.C.H. 1905, 303; Epidaurus: 1393 ; Hermione: late vases in Athens.
…
at Dresden); (?) Korope: Protocorinthian kotyle in Oxford.
…
182 ff. (Orchomenos); no. 758 (Livadhia); and some late vases in Athens,
186
but scarcely any of it is traceable. Among the vases in the Woodhouse
…
Kl. Schr. ii, 5 ; various publications mentioned in these works are unobtain-
…
in Spalato): Casson, Macedonia 320. Issa: sixth-century aryballos at Zara
…
Syra: pyxis like no. 921 andff. in Vienna (Hof-Mus.). Delos: see Dugas,
…
cf. also no. 114 a. Many vases in Berlin 'from Smyrna', i.e. probably found in
187
Thasos: B.C.H., 1921,141. Koile: no. 67 a. Elaeus: late vases in the Louvre
…
kovsky kindly informed me are unobtainable in England. Cf. also A. Anz.
…
of column-craters. A few are mentioned in the catalogue.1 No Protocorin-
…
in Bull. Archeologique, 1907, 449 fig. 14 (cf. Johansen pi. 17, 2): another
…
majority of published examples are in Mus. Lavigerie pis. 21, 22 and Mus.
…
2, 288, no. 979; Bull. Arch. 1918, 296; and Delattre in Cosmos 1897,
…
1 The majority of fragments are distributed Appendix i) and in Heidelberg (p. 25, note 6). See
188
I do not mention unpublished vases described as Corinthian in reports of
…
Taranto has produced more Corinthian vases than any other site in
…
Historia, 1928, vi, 3, 1 ff.; Orsi in Atti del Congresso Internaz. Rome 1903,
…
xxii. Vico Equense: no. 1401. Nola: a good many vases in Berlin and Naples
…
and Acragas; as regards Acragas, he is certainly mistaken. Ischia: vase in
189
other Italian sites: the majority of the finds are in the Louvre, and the
…
Torcello: J.H.S. 1904, 128 (column-crater in Museo Aestuario; I have not
…
9): no. 664. In Sicily the principal centres are Syracuse, Megara,Selinus,and
…
this term in a double sense: to include vases which were more or less closely
…
thian aryballos at Hyeres, which was found in the
190
for instance, those which are still in certain quarters spoken of as Attico-
…
Corinthian style, but there is no need to discuss them here; in neither case
…
14, 15 Bowls of Vourva shape. Athens 978 (C.C. 610); 979 (C.C. 611). Others in
…
from Ialysos Rhodian. Others take refuge in the meaningless term Attico-
…
The clay is in all cases red throughout; usually it is fairly light in colour;
191
models. All the shapes moreover recur in the Corinthian repertory, and some
…
well with the general probability of an early date in the
…
though the appearance of the lekythos, and of the hydria in a form which is
…
On shoulder, 'snake' with a man's head in its mouth.
…
(4) British Museum B 33, from Nola. Fig. 86. In panel, lion to r. Above, rosettes.
…
2 i, p. 126. 4 Die Wandmalereien in Veii 44, note 8.
192
placed it in a list of vases of ' Boeoto-Chalcidian' fabric.1 Zahn suggested
…
is warm brown, turning to orange in no. 5. The whole character of the draw-
…
hand, are several vases by the painter of the gorgon-dinos in the Louvre:
…
3. Plates: London and Oxford, from Naukratis. PI. 53, 4 (London). In centre, gor-
…
merely to the lions which are a favourite motive in both classes (cf. fig. 86 and
…
mentioned is not certainly connected with these and and 2 is again a typically Attic detail, unknown in
193
floral ornaments (cf. fig. 86 and the side-ornaments on the amphora in Louvre
…
tween them are (1) that the drawing in the
…
in many ways very closely connected with
…
shown in fig. 62 f. (Rumpf, 154, a). Rumpf regards all these vases as 'Boeoto-
194
A lekythos in Berlin (1659, from Camirus) which is often spoken of as
…
21 bis and ter, fragments in Munich (from the Athenian acropolis) and Marseilles.
196
Frankel, Rhein. Mus. 1912, 96, mentions, in connexion with some of the
…
24 Athens 528 (C.C. 634), from Corinth. Patterns as before, but red line in place of
…
sistency is noticeable as in the cups nos. 8-10, for they have a double line across
…
26 Athens 940 (C.C. 633). Patterns as in 528, but even finer rays at base. A, padded
…
riders, (B) lion attacking bull, (C) lotus and palmette complex as in pi. 51, 3;
…
ornament; among the animals of the upper frieze the figure seen in pi. 51, 3.
197
the same vase is in Oxford. On neck, white dots, part of a rosette; above picture,
…
argument from a comparison of the curious little man seen in pi. 51,3 with the
198
by many details in the drawing of the animals to be the same hand as these
…
exception of the one in the Hoppin Collection, are by the same hand. Of the
…
ment, fig. 88, d and e, which recurs in almost identical form on all but five
…
Boehlau,3 Pfuhl,4 Johansen,5 Thiersch,6 Masner,7 and Fraenkel,8 in publishing
…
unusual peculiarity in common: animal protomes
199
Attic Vourva tradition, which stands in definite contrast to the provincial and
…
rhenian vases are typical. Both these Attic styles were copied in Boeotia: as an
…
column-craters, have no exact parallels in Boeotian pottery of this period.
…
from Thebes, is the only example which has been found in Boeotia.3 Definite
…
2-3. It recurs in almost identical form on the tripod no.30, and on an ampho-
…
Attic work. in Athens which I do not know. But, as I have re-
…
of this in going through the fragments from Nau-
200
Acropolis dinos, Graf 606. In the one case we have something more definitely
…
ment differs only in being a trifle more accomplished. In every other respect
…
Attic black-figured style; one need only compare the dancers seen in
…
works, is entirely in harmony with the evidence of the history of the Corin-
…
illustrated in Jahrbuch 1898, pi. 1 (Hoppin,
201
In conclusion I would mention a neck-amphora of very clumsy shape and
…
These are all unimportant, but must be mentioned here in order to prevent
…
in Munich, Langlotz, Fruhgriechische Bildhauerschulen pi. 13, 3.
…
Neck-amphora: Taranto (from a tomb in the Contrada Vacarella). Shape as the Attic
…
pi. 13, 2; Prinz, Funde aus Naukratis, p. 73). In panel, griffon-bird between seated
…
the clay in all cases is white or very pale buff, as in many Corinthian vases;
…
nothing of its general character, is derived from the Vourva style of Attica, in
…
1 Note the peculiar style of the second vase in lines, 'two-piece' wings, long separate hair strands
202
One knows that clay could be fired almost white in other parts of Greece
…
a date in the first quarter of the sixth century. The Taranto amphora was
…
Cybebe 16fig.22). Artemis with swans; horse protome ending in a bird's tail
…
15 (A. Anz. 1890, 91, 9). Three women in a cloak (cf. no. 5). Louvre L. 141
…
by Mayence, Kiister, and Watzinger, in publishing class of Corinthian aryballoi (no. 484 and ff.) and never
203
traced in the following group:
…
are decorated in identical style, though perhaps with rather more care.3
…
provenance which does not fit into a required scheme, but in this case the
…
A small tripod pyxis from Tanagra, now in Athens (no. 289, C.C. 617,4), is a
…
column-crater, was found at Halai in Locris; it is now at Thebes.
…
practice of outlining figures and rosettes with in- 4 Cf. also the crested eagle of no. 23, Morin-Jean
204
thian, was also made at Sparta. A typical example is illustrated in fig. 91.
…
are purely Peloponnesian in character, and at Sparta, where again Ionian
…
Examples of a third group of aryballoi which are in a sense connected with
205
Two alabastra from Andros, now in Heidelberg (A. Anz. 1916, 167 nos. 2
…
Berlin 3053 (A. Anz. loc. cit., fig.). Pointed aryballos ; precisely similar in style is an
…
Olpe: Palermo 153, from Gela. Clay and technique as in Corinthian; style and com-
…
1 Dugas pi. 55, no. 79. 3 In Athens (recent Greek excavations).
206
Corinthian; in addition to these stylistic and technical peculiarities, the shape is
…
ment would inevitably require a separate study, in the course of which much
…
types, with which, even in recent publications, they are frequently confused.
…
first appearance after the middle of the seventh century in graves of the late
…
authorities in recent years.1 For there is no doubt that the foregoing are closely
…
thian, no. 5 Italian. But the distinction is illusory as in 1897, when Boehlau propounded the theory that
207
large collection of authentic Corinthian drawings in the illustrations of this
…
use of colour in authentic Corinthian work);
…
co-ordination in the decorative effect of the
…
drawings are given in fig. 94. A characteristic detail is that the feathering
…
1 Cf.Loeschcke in A.M. 1894^.510 note 2; Karo, similar filling ornament, and the occasional use
…
but identical in many details and in general character second and third friezes.
208
human leg dangling from its jaws. This motive is unknown in Greek art, and
…
The Corinthian style, with heavy filling of incised rosettes, is imitated in a
…
buff, but is nearly always muddy in colour. The varnish is usually brown.
…
1 Die Wandmalereien in Veii, 1917. Cf. also the 2 They may of course have been made outside the
XIV: Metal vases
210
because the majority of the specimens which have been found in Greece come
…
but in the absence of inscriptions, Corinthian examples cannot be distin-
…
in R.E. s.v. Apelles,no. 14). On Corinthian bronze,
…
It is mentioned by Welter in A. Anz. 1925, pp.
…
ground, which we find in the late Protocorinthian
…
these a fragment of an oinochoe in Aegina with
211
period in metal, as well as in clay, is a fairly certain conjecture from the shape
…
tomb 93 at Syracuse (Achradina); complete except for handle. Made in two
…
1910, 320 fig. 42. Tongue-pattern in relief above, and incision at centre;
…
from Sparta). (6) Fragments of a silver aryballos from Leontini (now in
…
metallic in character than the Protocorinthian, and they show the influence of
…
in pictures on vases, and as these are exceedingly rare in clay (there is one
…
the same as that of the magnificent gold phiale in Boston, dedicated by the
…
date. We know that such dinoi were made in various scarcely be other than Protocorinthian and Argive.
…
been made at Corinth also in the Protocorinthian 3 Boston Mus. Bull. 1922, 65; 1926, 50; C.A.H.
212
the bowl in fig. 98) are slightly different in type, but all, save fig. 96c, are
…
influence. New models are introduced, and the old reformed, obviously in
…
tion in bronze work, which sets in at Corinth early in the sixth century.
…
which do not correspond to anything in clay. Note preserved; cf. however the earlier type fig. 9 b, which
213
reason for these developments is not far to seek; early in the sixth century
…
It was this technique, already in a comparatively advanced stage, which was
…
vases of these shapes in existence, but one has only to look at the handles of
…
vases which show metallic influence in other
…
6 See Neugebauer in R.M. 1923/4, 418.
214
first is the vase from Corinth, in the British Museum, published for the first
…
a metal original:2 we have the snake-motive in a more primitive form on the
…
1 On the snake-motive in general see Neugebauer the snake-motive in a debased form; the shape of the
215
The third oinochoe is the vase in St. Louis, pi. 42,2-3 ; here again the pattern
…
in pi.48,3, it will be seen that the evidence of plastic style confirms this proba-
…
decorated with the tongue-pattern, which are studied by Neugebauer in R.M.
…
true that Neugebauer, who was the first to reconstruct the series in question,
…
2 De Ridder, Br. de la Soc. Arch, no 32; at the 4 As usual in early oinochoai, the mouth is rela-
216
extraordinary find of Greek bronzes in a group of native graves at Treben-
…
South Italian in the find; that, on the contrary, all the affinities of the imported
…
evidence of the style in which the plastic decoration
…
by Rumpf in Deutsche Literaturzeitung, 1928,281 ff.
…
Jacobsthal in the review already referred to, and
…
and Phoenicia, and several points in connexion with
…
lotus flowers shown in fig. 53 a. On this analogy
217
thian colonies in the north-west, except Corcyra, it is a safe conjecture that
…
In order to see what it amounts to, let us review the principal pieces.
…
in the sixth century for the first time (cf. fig. 64)
…
the numerous Corinthian vases found in barbarian
…
must have been in direct touch with the Adriatic
218
Corinthian shape, and recalls that even late in the fifth century, long after it
…
other vases we have a form, typologically later, in which the snakes stand up
…
and handles in the Louvre (de Ridder ii, pi. 95,
…
gon motive here appears in its simplest and earliest
…
figures; folds in the style of the early red-figure
219
stylization of the gorgoneia is very much in the Corinthian manner—and the
…
temporary patera from Corinth, published for the first time in pi. 46, 5,1 gives
…
it recalls the kouros from Olympia in Boston (see p. 238), where we find the
…
inscription in the Argive alphabet, have recently been published—the one,
…
Bildhauerschulen pi. 34. The dinos, J.H.S. 1926 comparisons in R.M. loc. cit.
220
motive in many places, to recommend it. Now the hydria in New York
…
the question of plastic style, an aspect in which bronze vases, through the
…
bronzes, such, for instance, as the dancing woman in the Ashmolean (J.H.S.
…
enhanced, and not diminished, by the Argive hydria in New York.
…
like the dinos in London, Sieveking, Antike Metallgerate pi. 1, and the
…
in shape, but with a flanged instead of a convex handle; and it is similar in
…
to the middle of the second quarter of the century. In any case, it is a simple,
221
Boston oinochoe is, however, a fact of some interest in view of the probability
…
Beazley tells me there is a late sixth-century hydria in Copenhagen, a piece of
…
Peloponnese in Vienna (A. Anz. loc. cit.), and those which are now attached to
…
Corinth. The difficulty is the one which is so often encountered in the study
…
have been properly published and placed in their
XV: Decorative metal work
222
is mentioned in the report of the American excavations at Corinth for
…
in Oxford, which is illustrated in pi. 45, 3.3 This is of pure late Protocorin-
…
It was used by Mycenaean goldsmiths, and was well known in the geometric
…
Next in time are the gold reliefs from Corinth published by Furtwangler
…
little evidence, and it is easy to see in which direction it points. Several of the
…
not in great numbers: cf. A.D. ii, pi. 24, 27 (late
…
Previously published by Gardner in J.H.S. xvi, 323;
…
Schr. i, 458 ff., pi. 15,1: now in Berlin; another is in
223
reliefs of this class have inscriptions, one of them an inscription in the Argive
…
A strong argument against an Argive origin in the proper sense of the word
…
designs in a style recalling the Thermon metopes, but is of a different
…
from the Heraeum are analogous in form, but differ consistently in details.3
…
decoration is often very difficult to judge, but in certain cases it corresponds
…
it is in general true to say that the reliefs are dated far too early. Some,
…
project as it does in all the Corinthian examples;
224
been out of fashion. The old and the new often stand side by side in the same
…
entirely on the relief; in a few cases the relief is assisted by very fine
…
was a process which would naturally appeal at Corinth in the period of
…
The Argive-Corinthian reliefs were used in many ways; for sepulchral
…
matrices as the foregoing, but in a different order. Characteristic Protocorinthian
…
be of local make, but in any case are based on Protocorinthian models (with the
…
is, of course, applicable only in cases where the 2 See on the reliefs from Corinth, p. 230 infra.
225
in the first two sets of bronzes from Boeotia cited above. There are also some rosettes
…
lion, cf. the contemporary group of Herakles and Achelous in pi. 34, 6 (p. 130). A
…
style of the female figure2 points to a date in the first half of the sixth century; also
…
1 A distinctive feature of these is the division of the 2 Described in Fiihrer p. 72 as a bearded man.
226
Berlin inv. 8373, from Greece (A. Anz. 1893, 7 no. 6). Dated c. 600 B.C. in the
…
given by the stele in New York, Rodenwaldt, Das Relief bei den Griechen pis. 1, 2,
…
Kl. Schr. i, 424) are shown in fig. 103. Fig. 103 A, from
…
shape are mentioned by Studniczka in A.M. 1886, 76, note
…
pi. 14). In the former, the group of draught-players, a motive
…
v, 124, fig. 466);2 these are all in a rather mannered style
…
from Eleutherae, in the British Museum and in Athens, and
…
A few of the reliefs from Eleutherae have already been published; these are in Athens.3
…
as to the circumstances of their discovery, but it is said that they were all found in the
…
3 Bather, J.H.S. 1892, 250; fig. 21 is in the British
228
same matrices, and in the same state of preservation. In fact, without any external
…
yards in fact, preserved. Some of the more important types are illustrated in fig. 104;
…
with a group of heraldic lions). One of the reliefs in
…
is later still, for here we have draped figures in the
…
fig. 104 f, and several others decorated with patterns and rosettes, which do not differ in
…
2 Also there is in the British Museum an exact 3 Furtwangler, Kl. Schr. i, 379.
230
in the style of the reliefs from Olympia (cf. supra).
…
may be, Corinthian, are mentioned in the later chapters of this book; and a few
…
no more than a passing reference; they are mostly in the Louvre and in Athens,
…
tradition. This relief, which may be part of a tripod, is best studied in the
…
type are not found in Greek art before the sixth century,5 and that the scheme
…
2 Published by Demangel in B.C.H. 1921, 309 fig. gorgon on the well-known Rhodian plate, Buschor2
…
4 Cf.vonMassow, A.M. 1916,87; Studniczka, Ame- motive in a much more primitive form. The scheme
231
period.1 The dot-rosettes in the field are, of course, no criterion of seventh- (or
…
the late archaic period this is unknown in the Peloponnese except as a man's
…
In the article mentioned on p. 230, note 4, Curtius refers to this relief in
…
typically Scythian, and seem to point to a 'mix-Hellenic' fabric in the neigh-
…
body, towards the spectator; we have, in fact, a
…
feature, the ending of the hair in a curl which stands
…
Corinth in the Protocorinthian period, and occurs
…
design in which the central motives are sometimes
XVI: Corinthian sculpture
232
in his recent book Friihgriechische Bildhauerschulen. A number of related
…
they are placed in the seventh century, and, we are told, there is no certain
…
that illustrated in pi. 46, 2? True, they are incomplete, and the bronzes are
233
and Thebes—and complete figures of stone, in the pediment from Corfu and
…
group of vases of which an admirable example is illustrated in pis. 1,8-11; 47,4-5 •
…
schemes employed in all these schools are often virtually identical, but the
…
heads: first, that the head when seen in side view is unnaturally flat. Now
…
in the round. The flatness is therefore not the result of technical considera-
…
might seem that in the head pi. 47,4-5 the artist has been constrained by the
…
1914, pp. 251, 3 figs. 9, 11. Most authorities speak 2 On Rhodian Daedalic, see V.Miiller in Berl. Mus.
234
formula in the head Johansen pi. 32,1, in the pediment, and, in fact, in all
…
Protocorinthian painting of the kind shown in pi. 1, 7-11. As we have seen
…
The earliest Corinthian type, from a pyxis painted in the style of the later
…
are characteristic of Sicyonian sculpture; but here we have them in an
…
as in the Protocorinthian heads, there are manifest differences. I do not refer
…
one cannot yet describe the profile as that of a head) in profile, and the
…
inscription) is obviously very close to the head from the pyxis. But in side
235
the head from the pyxis, though the forehead hair is still rendered in the old
…
I think, be admitted that the Corinthian head does not suffer in the com-
…
Calydon, reproduced from Poulsen and Rhomaios in pi.49,1-2. There is,it is
…
bronze head, and the sphinx have one particularly striking feature in com-
…
The painting on the vase which he holds (cf. fig. 18 e) is definitely in the style
…
painted decoration is visible in the Corpus (iii, c, The likeness is strong enough to warrant the sugges-
236
later than the head in Oxford (pi. 47, 14)—the face is definitely broader above
…
A word now as to the heads illustrated in pi. 48, 8-9: they also have
…
The heads illustrated in pi. 48,5,11-12,15 form the nucleus of a new group.
…
head like pi. 48,12, 15 is equally good in a different way; in either case the
…
the relation of these heads to those of the early sixth century, and is in per-
…
pi. 48,11 ,but slightly softer and less archaic,2and by the red-ground vase in St.
…
further stage in the development of the traditional type.3 The very late
…
(pis. 28,12; 48,11) is painted in a different style, but
…
2 The animals are manifestly late in style and com-
…
flatness which characterized the earlier heads in a
237
scarcely expect to find in small terra-cottas the particular qualities which
…
Apollo and the clay head shown in pi. 48,12,15. There are, of course, obvious
…
that of the Apollo, the other features and the hair only a little less so; in profile
…
1 Cf. Pfuhl, A.M. 1925, 162. On the proportions 2 I cannot believe in the 'school of Cleonae'. It is
…
those of the Apollo of Thera. The correspondence who may have worked anywhere in Greece. The
…
various interpretations; a sculptor may borrow a be in part, at least, Argive (the hydria in New
238
on the Corinthian style in the third quarter of the sixth century (pi. 46,6; Filow
…
temporary patera from Corinth, published for the first time in pi. 46,5. Though
…
figures in contemporary Corinthian vase-painting: for example, of Hippo-
…
votive inscription in the Corinthian alphabet (pi. 46, 2).5 We shall return to
…
of Ismenian Apollo at Thebes, which is illustrated in pi. 49, 3~4-6 Pottier
…
are precisely what we find in Apollo of Tenea and
…
thian pinax in the Louvre. The feet are modern.
…
6 First published by Pottier in Mon. Piot 1899, pi.
239
firmed in the most convincing manner by the recent discoveries at Calydon.3
…
the Corinthian heads illustrated in pi. 48. This is quite obvious from a
…
have here is not exactly what one expects in a work of late archaic style, and
…
arguments in favour of the view that this sphinx was
…
is never present even in the lightest Boeotian clays.
…
Boeotian. But this argument obviously collapses in
…
the originals: the dot painted on the lobes of ears in
240
sculptural style. They are discussed further in the chapter devoted to archi-
…
early classical sculpture in the Peloponnese. The Corfu sculptures, however,
…
The former question cannot, in my opinion,be answered except with certain
…
which rests in part on the purity of their style, and in part on the analogy of
241
The pediments from Corfu, which are best studied in the admirable photo-
…
of Peloponnesian style, and that they were found in a Corinthian colony, is
…
metric', is not common in the earliest periods; indeed I know of only one
…
noticed in Corinthian work—angularity, not so much of contour, though
…
the earliest Corinthian gorgon (see p. 84); in type she is clearly later than the
…
light on this problem. Among the finds published in
…
3 The fullest discussion is that of v. Liicken in
…
there are snakes, not indeed in the hair, but round
242
and the vases illustrated in pis. 38-40, &c.2
…
period, they may well be a little earlier than these. In an isolated case of
…
The gorgon, then, is in the Corinthian manner of the early sixth century;
…
In contrast with this, and with the Corfu gorgon, the craters nos. 1195 (pi. 34, 7), and 1196, and on the
…
ception of plastic form—most notably in the treat- 3 Moreover several of his comparisons hold good
…
difference in the treatment of the legs is equally common at all periods (cf. the bull's tail, pi. 6);
243
than human form. And if we compare him with Zeus in the right-hand
…
criticism: one may compare Zeus with Tydeus in pi. 40, 2, or equally with the
…
Corinth, in Copenhagen (pi. 50, 3-4) ;4 these are plainly later and belong, no
…
element in the nose is the curve of the lateral
…
turned mouth is, of course, impossible in a normal
244
also from the isthmus,1 and a lioness from Corfu in the British Museum
…
from Calydon, one of which is published in Poulsen and Rhomaios's report,
…
from the isthmus, and are comparable in quality with the much more archaic
…
is a very unusual one—in the plastic lion at the back of the Protocorinthian
…
quoted in the preceding pages are, to my mind, sufficient to preclude a date
…
of Corinthian sculpture in the second quarter of the century, whether of
…
those in Copenhagen; there is more modelling in the fig. 16.
…
acquired by the Berlin Museum, Berichte 1927, 61 from Miletus in the Louvre, Cat. Sommaire pi. 58,
…
the far more powerful, though exceedingly conven- appears at a very early date in Etruria; cf. the lion
245
which we have been concerned. In several instances there is a fair degree of
…
evidence depends in a great measure on the importance which is attached to
…
'Corinthian' kouroi (pi. 46, 2) has an inscription in the Corinthian alphabet
…
in the kouros of Etymokleidas (pi. 46,2) and the woman from Tegea (Langlotz
…
(Langlotz pi. 40,2) in comparison with the Corin- 2; to those enumerated by Winter, add now Deltion
…
2 Walters 243, pi. 4. The last two of these types have been found in
246
Corinthian group—bronzes like that illustrated in pi. 46, 2 and the other
…
series, the head from the Acropolis, and the original of the Citharoedus in
…
the Corinthian output. In the earlier period, as we have seen, Corinth was
…
take the view that she maintained her importance in the fifth century. For
…
no. 3 are mentioned in AJ.A. 1898, 212 and thirteen 115, and two primitive objects in the British
…
fore reasonably be regarded as Corinthian and their Corinth), but are almost uniformly weak in style. It
…
these are certainly interesting because they are indi- 1 Alinari 24494 (retouched in places); Petrizis'
…
mentioned above—but they yield little information it in pi. 46,4; Athens, Nat. Mus. 11691. Previously
…
unusually poor lot, and stand far below the plastic mirror. In profile the caryatid shows the very
XVII: Architectural decoration
248
IN the concluding chapter of this book I shall try to give an outline of those
…
tained in Koch's invaluable article in Romische Mitteilungen, 1915, and Mrs.
…
In a thorough treatment, the decoration of the archaic temple would have to
…
be connected with Corinth in one sense or another.
…
stitution of the country in the archaic period, would lead us to expect, and
…
Greeks of the seventh and sixth centuries. In so far as the clay revetment was
249
the variety which we find in other decorative arts. Variety of course there is,
…
of those that have been published, explain themselves in relation to the
…
tively little of importance left. In the seventh century there is one fairly large
…
Corinth at a very early period in the story of the Sicyonian Butades who
…
at Thermon, and these earliest examples are all more or less Corinthian in
…
have been found inscribed in the Corinthian alphabet. The revetment
250
of Corinthian origin will be considered in further detail in connexion with
…
for the most part, understand the clay revetments in which the roof of the
…
tioned must be the kind in which the cover-tile and
…
Kopivdoei8r]s mentioned in the inscription from
…
3 The importance of Corinth in the matter of
…
in a new form. A period in the seventh century when
…
of Muller in A.M. 1923, 68, and Montuoro in Mem.
…
instance in Sandys' (Loeb) edition. The achieve-
…
and points out that these show the gable in a very
…
least worth bearing in mind that Corinthian archi-
251
these in various contexts, but we must glance at them once more, since they
…
that any of these sculptures are from a pediment), but at Corfu and in Sicily
…
pears long before the gorgon in the seventh century, and there is some pro-
…
decorators of the pediment. Further discoveries in Greece may show whether
…
That Corinthian pedimental decoration was imitated in the early sixth
252
were found in another Corinthian colony—Syracuse.1 It has often been
…
triangular antefixes of the kind which is illustrated in fig. 106. This
…
of the technique would, no doubt, make it possible to decide in which cate-
…
We never find the same proportion of palmette and volute in the 'Corinthian
…
in a new form in Jahrbuch 1928, 54 ff.
…
spotted as in the examples just mentioned, Van
…
figs. 143-4) at Delphi (ibid. fig. 89, above), and in
253
period'—either in vase-painting or in architectural decoration (cf. p. 151).
…
is the sima decorated with a cable pattern as shown in the illustration. The
…
Corinthian work in the revetment of the third temple of Apollo at Thermon;
…
of much of the material to be discussed in this chapter, and it would be
…
from Troezen, no. 12, has two colours in the pattern;
…
making cover and flat tile in one as evidence for his
…
tongue pattern on the under-side; waterspouts in the
…
Corinthian in style, and may perhaps represent the
…
8 Semi-circular, with bearded gorgoneion in relief
254
general argument. The metopes, which are painted in the style of the third
…
47, io, is purely Corinthian in style; the same seems to be true of the lions' head,
…
give indisputable evidence of the prestige of Corinth in Aetolia. We may
…
century temple which stood on the acropolis, in the grounds of the villa Mon
…
leads one to suppose that commercial relations may be published in the account of the temple of Ar-
…
takes violent exercise in a top hat. Mr. Woodward end of the century (cf. p. 244); this lion however
255
All, so far as one can judge, are Corinthian in style, but are made of local clay.
…
judge from the photographs, these are also Corinthian in style, but are later
…
We know more about temple-decoration in the sixth century, and can
…
sphinx-head illustrated from the preliminary report in pi. 49,1-2, which is im-
…
of other sphinx-acroteria. A sima-block and an antefix are shown in
…
Thermon and Corfu, and, as already remarked, recall in certain details the
…
developed in style than the earliest Thermon ante- thian ?
258
antefixes of the type shown in fig. 107, a type which is clearly a development
…
sphinx.3 Fragments of several sphinx-bodies, and the head shown in pi. 49,
…
blocks, and in one the lion's-head waterspout is fairly well preserved.4 This
…
have already met this type of sima in the temple of Apollo at Thermon (see
…
mane being red in both cases.
259
. 40, are Corinthian in type, though, as the clay shows, they are evidently of
…
Koch and by Mrs. Van Buren.2 The profile is the same, in principle at least,
…
doubt that Koch is right in assigning this sima to the gorgon temple. The
…
of the Corinthian style in the early sixth century. A larger and more elaborate
…
the revetment of which we have been speaking.3 The sima, shown in fig. 108 b,
…
obscured in the process; I therefore prefer to leave it as it stands. The
…
several antefixes. The sima and antefix are illustrated in fig. 109. It will be
…
and no. 1447, pi. 43, 1: we see the same motive in a
260
torus is decorated in much the same way as at Calydon.
…
mediately succeeds the Calydon style, in the second quarter of the sixth
…
shown in fig. 109 is illustrated by a revetment, also from Corinth, which Mrs.
…
a new feature which we shall meet again in the Megarian Treasury), and an
…
Architecture 88, 325, who places it in the third 5 The fragment from Mycenae, Van Buren fig. 111,
261
acroterion, from Olympia, resembles these in small details, as well as in
…
refined sense of form, but also a conscious reserve in the use of ornament,
…
had long been given up; the antefix is now decorated in the same manner
…
in another sense, also, for, as has been pointed out, the motives are those which
…
shown in figs. 109-110. The flowers and the connecting chain have a grace
…
a lustrous surface, precisely as in the Calydon head
…
of the Louvre sphinx pi. 49, 3-4: in both the billets
262
in precisely the same way as the flowers on the cornice from those of earlier
…
made in one block with the sima and the edge-tile, a technique which, as we
…
Thebes,5 Olympia and elsewhere; and the fragmentary acroteria in the
…
Greece to Gonnos in Thessaly, and include Calydon 7 Many fragments of Nike-acroteria from the
…
sixth century; mentioned in A.J.A., loc. cit.,together statuette,' from near the temple of Athena Chalinitis,
Catalogue of late protocorinthian, transtional, and corinthian vases
264
offer more than an abbreviated list of vases, with summary descriptions. In its
…
to quote more than one or two examples of each class; in order to establish the
…
scriptions—are given in the chapters which deal with these aspects of the
…
in the process of firing. It is a very common thing to find one side of a vase
265
in the atmospheric conditions within the kiln. It may be that the bright green
…
Corinthian clay is always clear in colour: it is easily distinguishable from
…
like the clay of Attic vases in the full sixth century. The vases with a strong
…
the early sixth century: in these cases the red colour was produced intention-
…
inherent in the clay, but of the treatment to which the clay is subjected. We
Catalogue of late protocorinthian, transtional, and corinthian vases / Contents
Catalogue of late protocorinthian, transtional, and corinthian vases / Late protocorinthian vases
269
shown in fig. 113. In the lower
…
(except in no. 11). [No. 9 is now at Oxford.]
…
late in the history of the Protocorinthian style. The
…
style of the animals on the latter are definitely in the
270
geometric period, two of which are illustrated in
…
from the East,2 and are more definitely ceramic in
…
In the last quarter of the
…
in the Corinthian type, and there
…
taller in proportion to its
…
lower frieze in nos. 21-3, like that of the aryballoi
…
a sketch in fig. 113 bis). This vase, and others (such
…
(Camirus—several examples in the Louvre, published in the
…
A.M. 1903, 238), but they differ in many details from the
…
The excavations in which these vases were found will
…
type of handle seen here and in the Cretan vases is not
271
With flat mouth, as in Corinthian, but the shape of
…
similar style in the British Museum(i9i2.6.26.182),
…
tron was found beside another skeleton in the same
…
For alabastra decorated in the subgeometric and
…
was found at Sovana in Etruria, and not in Rhodes as
…
spotted fallow deer is found in mainland art (e.g. no. 114 a).
…
101; Johansen p. 103 fig. 55). Frag., Inscription in
…
is drawn in outline with extraordinary skill; the
…
On the shape, see p. 32. In comparison with the
…
justice. Close in style to no. 47. British Museum, 32
272
36 Syracuse (N.S. 1925.pl. 21). Neck frag. In centre,
…
as before. In centre, part of lion or panther. These
…
30). Painting in two techniques: (1) white on black,
…
frieze, with lower part of a figure dressed in short
…
In style and technique (incised contours, brown for
…
Frags, in two techniques, as in no. 39. Johansen has
…
PI. 8, 1-6. From my own excavations in 1927
…
bounded by polychrome bands as in no. 32.
…
(cf. no. 32). Below, polychrome lines as in no. 31.
…
goat, stag, water-bird—all in rapid movement.
…
one who wishes to place such a vase in the Corin-
…
or incision. In this instance note the typical Protocorinthian
273
50 decorated in this style? Munich 227 (S.H. pi. 11).
…
Aegina, fragments of a lid.2 A fragment in Athens
…
sen pis. 12, 18. In the late Protocorinthian period
…
same change takes place in the decoration of the
…
series continues in no. 665 (cf. on no. 646). Athens,
…
2 Found in different places near the temple of Aphrodite, but apparently parts of the same vase.
Catalogue of late protocorinthian, transtional, and corinthian vases / Transitional vases
274
comes a siren ; Johansen pi. 27, 2). In the lower
…
also, in reaction against the tapering form of the late
…
same hand as the last, differing only in small details;
…
In field, in 1, incised rosettes and dotted circles as
…
Ht. at least 15 cms Same scheme as before; in
…
Shape as pi. 15 or fig. 118. Decoration in narrow A.
…
Replica of the last, differing only in very small de-
…
16, 1. Patterns as in the preceding, but the colours
…
pi. 45, 4). 1, bull, goat, ram, lion. 2, as in last.
…
bulls. 3, coursing hounds, swan. Both are close in
…
alabastra mentioned in the early Corinthian cata-
276
in 361-6). British Museum 42.4.7.24. Upper part
…
fit, delicately drawn in reserve. A still-life of a rare
…
as shown in the drawing, is probable. Red, yellow,
…
rosettes ; the white squares in the check-pattern are reserved.
…
The dinos was evidently a rare shape in pottery at
…
PYXIS IN THE SHAPE OF A DINOS 3
…
in having a foot, but may have inspired the manufacturer
277
in 127).
…
Cited as a parallel to one in Dresden (A. Anz. 1925,
…
as in no. 128. One frieze: lions, goat, panther, bull,
…
animal friezes; below each, scale band in black-
…
with slight differences in the arrangement of the
278
Below, red and yellow bands as in no. 32. 1 repainted.
…
E 418, from Italy. Above frieze, patterns as in last.
…
pieces, each with four friezes: animals as in 163, 4,
…
Heidelberg, pi. 14. Close in style to the foregoing. 168
…
Elongation as in nos. 166, 7. Ibid. 68. 1. 10. 770 176
…
with details in yellow and red: continuation of the
…
1397. In general similar to the last. British 186
…
With animal-friezes in black-figure technique. A.
279
This type begins in the Protocorinthian period1
…
Naukratis in the British Museum (1924.12.1.1179).
…
blobs in field. A row of rosettes; double rays.
…
rim, metopes as in 193 and ff., but with dogs.
…
Berlin 325, from Corinth (now in the University 199
…
Berlin 326, from Corinth, and one in Oxford
…
found in the same tomb); cf. also Syracuse tomb
…
always of the form shown in fig. 9 a. The corre-
Catalogue of late protocorinthian, transtional, and corinthian vases / Early corinthian vases
281
becomes commoner in the late Protocorinthian
…
in the early Corinthian period. Instead, we have
…
in the late seventh century; towards the end of the
…
none as early as the earliest alabastra. In most early
…
alabastra. In the sixth century the small alabastron
…
Small vases, decorated in black-figure style. a.
…
described. Average ht. c. 8-10 cm. Deviations in
…
the rosettes are often larger, than in pre-Corinthian
…
Louvre E 489, from Italy. One in Turin. Cab. 223, 4
…
in Heidelberg, and no. 266 a. 227
…
is published in his 'Archaic Period in Russia', pi. 1, which
282
416). White dots used, exceptional in this class.
…
laea. PL 25,1. Found in tomb 586 with other early
…
similar wings, but one in front of the body, one
283
foregoing in black-figure technique. In the following
…
Small alabastra decorated in the 'subgeometric' style, B.
…
tongues. On the body, in addition to the figures,
284
this type are very common in early Corinthian graves
…
have been found in early Corinthian
…
pointed aryballoi of the type shown in fig. 8 A.
…
Groups A-C continue in a broad sense the style and
…
development, a great increase in the size of the
…
were not sensitive in this matter, and regularly
…
4 White dots are, of course, found in Mycenaean vase-
…
fullest; even vases over 12 inches in height are decor-
…
tioned, but also in all earlier vase-painting at Corinth.4
…
aryballoi in general. I have no doubt that the origin
…
in the Louvre (de Ridder ii, pi. 65, 1101), a
…
dots in close conjunction with the incised lines. This
…
as in later Melian vases, Clazomenian sarcophagi, &c.
285
in Delos x, pi. 67 (no. 380 infra).
…
method in such a case, as we have to do with a man-
…
in the early Corinthian category, omitting a few which
…
11); replica in the Hermitage (inv. 1391). Berlin
…
12. Gorgon-bird; at the back, lion. Found in a
286
p. 137, fig. 3). (1) battle (hoplites and slinger—in
…
(How to Observe in Archaeology (Brit. Mus.) 54
…
An oriental shape, common in Eastern Greece and
…
cised lozenges in field. Delos (Dugas pi. 28, 373 476,7
…
these vases are commonly found in Corinthian
…
inferior in technique. This type is often found
…
2 Unique shape, but cf. a vase in Cairo, Edgar pis. 5, 6.
287
Graves in which the above types
…
in the 'Corinthian' period: shape A (fig. 123), a
…
a simplication of shape A. Both first appear in the
…
popularity in the late seventh century is, no doubt,
…
earlier, as the patterns drawn in reserve recall those
…
trated by v. Bissing in the volume Steingefasse of the Cairo
…
2 An aryballos with floral ornament of the kind in ques-
…
tongues and circles; on body, floral, as in fig. 54b.
…
type shown in fig. 54 d, brings us a stage nearer to
…
the principal pattern closely similar in all cases; the
…
tion was found in tomb 706 at Megara Hyblaea—a tomb
…
recollection is that it was of the kind shown in fig. 54 b or c.
288
crosses and loose dot-rosettes in the field.1
…
kind; in this instance, however, the vase was a
…
519 were found in graves of the late seventh century.
…
attacking stag; in the field, among the rosettes, a
…
Sicily. Dancers nude; in the centre, dinos
…
shown in fig. 18 a. Perhaps Transitional. Berlin
289
white dots (unknown in the warrior group).
…
all round; handle-back always as in fig. 125, never as
…
dots which are not found in the warrior group, the
…
(ASTVOS'IAAHMI) incised on rim. Found in the
…
set that quoted above, in which no. 551 was found
…
the palmettes end in small, nipple-like dots, precisely
…
central petals and dots at the end, as in those just men-
…
shown in fig. 53 c and is obviously middle Corinthian.
290
unspecified) with a panther. Close in style to nos.
…
c. 7 cm. These vases are common in early Corinthian
…
London, in my own possession. Lion-protome.
…
1900, pi. 22, 7); examples in Corinth, Corneto,
…
Megara Hyblaea tomb 608 (alabastra as in the pre-
…
in field. The gorgon's chiton yellow and red,
291
629 fish in his hand. Athens 336 (C.C. 492). Octopus.
…
vases: shape B 1. Patterns as in nos. 564-99.
…
A variant pattern in which the palmettes are con-
…
found in early Corinthian graves,
…
Note the vertical zigzags, suggesting lacing, on the vase in
…
in Italy (S.H. pi. 29, 746).
…
corinthian shape was taken in the late Protocorin-
…
higher in proportion, and has a broader foot (cf. pp.
292
of the sides, which we do not find in Protocorin-
…
form tends to be higher in proportion to its breadth
…
formerly in a dealer's shop in Athens; another
…
appears in the late
293
verticals incised in black. Syracuse, from Gela
…
Transitional styles, and becomes common only in
…
HANDLES IN THE FORM OF FEMALE
…
Perrot ix, 607 fig. 318). On the lid, in very lively
…
lished in B.S.A. 1927-8.
…
final form is shown in fig. 180.
…
, 6 Exceptions, with figures in subgeometric style: Mon.
…
ther, siren, lion; on the handles, cable in outline
…
The following, however, is, unusually low in propor-
…
sirens, &c, in the style of the aryballoi of the warrior
…
almost exact parallels in wood: a
…
Corinth in the archaic period.
294
20, no. 36); others were found in tomb 64 at Gela
…
on, but in many instances it is impossible to make
…
from Corinth. Metopes with birds, as in the kotylai
…
is Corinthian. The shape is fairly common in Attica
…
tion of Protocorinthian traditions in the Corinthian
…
of zigzags (as in most Protocorinthian kotylai),
…
Below the main frieze, in no. 673, a row of rosettes
…
150-1, 184) either now, or in the earlier seventh
…
find it in Boeotia and in Attica (though not, it seems,
…
and early orientalizing examples (in Athens, from
…
fluence in the finds from the tombs of the Bernadini
…
lished in B.S.A. 1927-8.
…
dini tomb is finely published in Memoirs of the American
295
broad band of pattern at the rim (except in nos.
…
unusual in the early period, somewhat resembling
…
goat, panther. By the handles, a star as in Proto-
…
same source in the British Museum. Athens, from
…
fabric: found in tomb 66 with early alabastra,
…
fig. 571). No rim pattern. Panther, boar; in field,
…
772, 1142, on an oinochoe in Corneto, mentioned under no.
296
have gone out of fashion early in the sixth century.2
…
of bull; details in yellow as well as red. Early.
…
The multiple vase has a long history in the Aegean
…
in form, are Naukratite and Rhodian examples:
…
British Museum 73.8.20.387. The ring as in pi. 44, 707
…
sphinxes, goat. Thick f.o. in 2-4; little in 1. Prob-
…
The Protocorinthian type shown in fig. 9 b, which 708
…
thian in having a larger foot, greater depth in the
…
The change of shape made the change in decoration
297
which first appears in the late seventh century.
…
nos. 572, 573. A similar cup is in Berlin (no. 1154).
…
Museum 1921. 11. 28. 1. Ext. in same style as last.
…
A. There are fragments at Corinth, decorated in
…
bull, lion, hoplites in combat between sphinxes.
…
painted in black-figure technique; the rims of
…
panther, does, rather later in style than the fore-
…
Other Corinthian fragments in the B.M. may be
…
and Ure in J.H.S. 1911, p. 72 ff. The subject
298
Cretan,1 and that the shape was first adopted in
…
Corinth in the early Corinthian period. The great
…
three panels with animals. Subsidiary decoration in
…
black-polychrome decoration. Found in a tomb
…
in the late seventh century, it is true, but it only
…
in the Italian excavations at Afrati (Liv. Ann. 1925 pi. 3,
…
wider in proportion to the whole, and the individual
…
similar in style to 734. Vienna, Oest. Mus. 128 737
…
ments closely similar in style to no. 734 and ff.
299
able in style from no. 1093 and ff.
…
The two varieties (high- and low-necked) known in
…
of the lion shown in pi. 25, 6. Oxford 1879. 101.
…
3 Unless, indeed, the olpe from Rhodes in Tubingen,
…
patterns on neck as in Protocorinthian. Corinth
…
from Rhodes. Incised verticals as in last: panther,
…
4 For the mouth cf. the vases cited in J.H.S. 1926, 208
300
fig. 159). Above, tongues in black-polychrome
…
The shape first appears in the early Corinthian
…
swans). In the uppermost frieze on rev., lotus
…
2 Cf. Beazley in A.J.A. 1927, 350-1, publishing the
…
as in no. 780 a). Be-
…
One frieze, as in 769. Goat, panther, swans, lotus
…
friezes of lions, bull, panthers, &c.; in the fourth,
…
new, not only to Corinthian art but to Greek art in
…
vase in Copenhagen C.V.A. iii, H-I, pi. 125 (late sixth
301
Corinthian column-craters vary in shape consider-
…
in the late period. Side by side with it in the late
…
The column-crater appears in Attica in the early
…
proper in various native Italian imitations.6 Bronze
…
distinctive features in addition to those already men-
…
on late Corinthian, zigzags are normal. In the
…
the Comast fabric (see p. 196). The vase in Athens A.M.
…
one in Bonn; there are fragments of another, from Nau-
…
small in proportion to the height of the whole,
…
vases (cf. no. 634). One group in panel on each side.
…
13; photo Alinari 35749). H.p. cocks, precisely in the
…
in his recent publication, not only attributes this vase
…
alabastra are found in graves with Protocorinthian
…
a specially Attic motive in the mid-sixth century, and
…
(?) Ionian, in the Calvert Collection; photo in the German
302
though the principal motives are the same as in
…
and we need scarcely recall that they are in diametrical
…
in graves with vases of Protocorinthian type, but as
…
Protocorinthian style' in the Corinthian period at all,
…
horses, which are remarkably archaic both in build
…
and p.), Herakles in the house of Eurytos (Eurytios
…
the style in all cases distinctively early, but there are
…
are much nearer in general character to those of
…
Iole stands out as one of the earliest in the long series
…
which forehead and nose meet; this is equally clear in
Catalogue of late protocorinthian, transtional, and corinthian vases / Middle corinthian vases
303
in numbers in the middle period. I do not know of
…
no. 5; Schaal, G.V. in Frankf. Samml. 25 fig. 9; id.
…
decorated in a looser, weaker style, and
…
drawing as in the Chimaera plates (no. 1040 and ff.).
…
Mykonos. Two examples identical in type with the 802 a
…
in no. 803. I know of no
304
much more so than in the Gorgoneion cups, and one
…
cross, in reserve. At centre, gorgoneion. On handle-
…
the Protocorinthian tradition in the Corinthian
…
period begin in the early sixth century (see on no.
…
nos. 1155,6. In nos. 821-35, central motive flanked
…
Taranto, from tomb 119. In centre, four palmettes. 834
305
835 a Frankfurt (Schaal pi. 6 e). In centre, woman.
…
840 as no. 836. Delos (Dugas pi. 27, 346). In centre,
…
With various motives. Style and patterns as in
…
No. 652, placed in the early Corinthian catalogue,
…
lotuses, rendered in the same style as the ornaments
…
The shape displaces the concave-sided pyxis in the
…
1 For a variant form introduced under Attic influence in the sixth century, see nos. 1504, 5.
306
is standing—cf. no. 1105, the only other example in
…
examples in Palermo from Selinus. Bands of
…
in two groups : (1) C.V.A. pi. 17, 2 and 5, which are
…
PYXIDES WITH HANDLES IN THE FORM
…
sphinxes, panthers, goats, does, lion) in the style of
…
1 I think now that this vase should have been placed in the early Corinthian category.
307
Distinctive style, with many dots in the field,
…
as in fig. 67 a. Brussels A 1035. PI.28,10 (C.V.A.
…
are a Boread, and a chimaera in the style of the
…
in--1 ■
…
as in the last. Subgeometric figures: women holding
…
Greek Vases in Poland, 1), and three about which
…
late period. The vases in Lyons are probably of the
…
unknown in Athens till the fifth century.
…
lebes, or in an adjoining grave. Naples, from 902
…
seeing it in Vienna.
308
panion piece in Orvieto. This I have not seen, but
…
439). Others in Syracuse and Fig. 147.
…
in a tomb with amphoriskoi like no. 1076 and ff., kotyle
309
broad shape of the vase in contrast with earlier types.
…
correctly drawn?). Herakles and the Hydra, and in
…
16, 1). Patterns and shape as in 943. Women
…
following are identical in style and subject: Athens
…
fig. 590). Apollo (in chariot?). Inscription p. 163
…
Black, as fig. 151 (London, in my own possession). 973
310
derives directly from the earlier form shown in
…
shown in fig. 9 b after the end of the seventh century.
…
in the late seventh century (cf. Syracuse, Achradina
…
vases. We have, in the first place, a series of female
…
types shown in figs. 32-4. After the very angular
…
tainly later in type than early Corinthian and early
…
in Attica from the time of Klitias onwards, the
…
however, is wrong in saying that the correct render-
…
cups, nos. 975, 975 a, no doubt early examples in
…
in a grave with other vases which point to a date
…
Corinthian cup appears suddenly in the Attic reper-
…
type are collected in ch. xiii under the heading the
…
regular Attic black-figured forms which were in use
311
in the Gorgoneion group (nos. 986-98), which must
…
There is a large cup in Munich which it is difficult
…
(net, zigzags, tongues, and as in fig. 153 or plain,
…
3 Fine rays at the base in all cases, bounded by two or
…
Thus in nos. 986, 987, and 989 the gorgoneia are
…
horses are distinctly early in style. Jena. Fig. 45 b 987
…
pattern as in fig. 153. Louvre
…
1922 pi. 3 ;id. G.V. in Fr. Samml. pi. 7). A,banquet. 990
…
the gorgoneion cups; in no. 992, note the smaller
…
three fine lines (three lines, as in the Attic cups, in no. 986
312
cated by the lack of angularity in the profile.
…
of women: style exactly as in nos. 945-9. Padded
…
further Beazley, Greek Vases in Poland, 4.
…
with palmette complex, as in nos. 1049-51 of the
…
types are found in Attica;3 the earliest Attic plates,
…
remarked in J.H.S. 1926, 211, connects it definitely with
313
I, decoration in concentric bands; b.f. technique.
…
1037 (C.V.A. pi. 10, 7). Fragments in Oxford, from
…
decoration of the interior. Patterns as in group II.
…
Richter, Ancient Furniture fig. 179). Man in bed.
…
Ant. xiv, 786, fig. 7); Attic b.f. in Bologna (Pellegrini
…
lar in section. The following,
…
horsemen, female heads in out-
…
Professor Beazley tells me there are two in Brussels and
314
fig. 6). Return of Hephaestus; loose dot-rosettes in
…
/ ;' "i /' dered in b.f. technique,
…
in b.f. technique. Typical shape, fig. 158. Charac-
…
Other examples in Taranto
…
goats, bird. Late. Replicas in Syracuse, from Leon-
…
Three friezes, in the middle of 2, battle, at the
315
1094 f°°t, red beta Tj as in last. British Museum 61. 4.
…
vase, decorated in a very careful style; the general
…
II, part of the vase decorated in black-polychrome
…
pattern as above; on the front, in white, a bull and
…
ing on stalks in the field, as often in late Corinthian.
…
84, 1). As last, but inferior in technique and with-
…
horseback, and cocks about lizard, in addition to
…
type in Athens (cf. C.C. 518, 520, pi. 22).
…
horsemen and warriors; star-rosettes as in nos. 806 ff.
316
54; Maclver, Iron Age in Italy, fig. 86). Panther,
…
5). On shoulder incised decoration as in no. 1102
…
rays. In the same tomb kotyle no. 928 and ff., pyxis
…
ducks; in field, crosses. Perhaps early Corinthian.
…
in style than on late Corinthian vases; for the style
…
lotz pi. 13, 3), but here the handles no longer stand off as in
…
youth; B, panther (style as in pi. 29, 7, which is
…
in last. Bonn 464, 28-30. Frags.: sphinxes, eagle; 1164
…
temple of Apollo.' Many similar fragments in
Catalogue of late protocorinthian, transtional, and corinthian vases / Late corinthian vases I
319
1201 Berlin 4513. Rider drawn in outline. Berlin 3394.
…
fig. 12; Pfuhl fig. 172; A.M. 1916, 180). Scene in
…
Siren. There are several similar vases in the Louvre,
…
Patterns as before, except in no. 1225. Thin f.o. of
…
1206 A somewhat similar vase is in the Hermitage (inv.
…
white slip mentioned in the publication. Leipzig 1225 a
…
of warriors; in field, dotted circles and palmettes.
…
narrow concentric circles, occasionally tongues as in
320
3 For example in tombs 49, 50, and 51, discussed on p. 60.
…
given by Ure in J.H.S. 1909, 310 (Graves 31, 26, 18, 12, 46
…
an isolated survival of this type in the middle of the
…
date in the sixth century.
…
were several in tomb 86 at Rhitsona (c. 580-70 b.c.:
…
indicated has been traced in detail by Ure on the
…
a few unimportant variations in the size of the cross-
…
intermediate form, are discussed by Ure in J.H.S.
321
1909, 309 ff., and in Eph. Arch. 1912, 113 with figs.
…
thus derives in the main from the Rhitsona exca-
…
a late sixth-century grave at Deve Huyuk in
…
schaft 1909, 206 (Hackl); Weicker in Roscher iv,
…
bird (cf. pi. 3 6,9-1 o). A similar vase in Dresden, from
…
a swan and a panther identical in style with those of
…
foil pattern drawn in
…
commonest in the second
…
in tomb 126 (third quarter of sixth century Ure, Sixth and
322
Ceramicus. Differs in small details from the last.
…
found in a late grave.
…
C. Linear patterns in the 'white style'. A large class;
…
decorated with a single head in the middle of a long
…
PYXIDES WITH HANDLES IN THE FORM
…
usually late in appearance.
…
Very close in style to nos. 1382, 3. New York
…
Fragments of these vases in Athens, from the
…
With linear patterns in
…
in general similar to the last, but with rays at base.
…
could be used in the pattern (cf. the kotyle no. 941,
323
II, with linear patterns in the white style. Another
…
patterns (tongues, bands, zigzags, &c.) in the Uni-
…
There is a fine fragment from Naukratis in Oxford
…
Professor Beazley), in Eleusis; Berlin 4988 (A.M. 1916, pi.
…
there are two holes in
…
rim pattern; rays as in fig. 151. Sphinxes and sirens;
…
614,420. Others in Chaeroneia and Palermo.
…
With men in groups: finer style. B.
…
figured (pink on black): photographs of two examples in
324
C. Black with shading in place of rays at base: type,
…
middle Corinthian kotylai, but are unknown in the
…
copied in Attica in the late sixth and fifth centuries.1
…
1 Cf., for instance, Schaal, G.V. in Frankf. Samml. pl.
…
in Bologna (Pellegrini 9, no. 56) and Taranto
…
scriptions incised in the field (p. 165, no. 30). By the
…
ff.). Decoration in panel, below red
…
pl. 1, 10). Swan between sphinxes. Replicas in
325
right in attributing the vase to
…
in panel (except in no. 1384); below, reserved line.
…
Geneva, as last. Design as in last, but tongues on 1386
…
in nos. 1391, 6, 7.
…
(Gerhard, A.V. pi. 258). Nine warriors running, in
326
of handle. In panel, Troilos and Polyxena waylaid
…
the earliest Greek examples both are decorated in
…
earlier in style, is shown in pi. 48,10. For the style
…
shape in general see Jacobsthal, Ornamente pp. 15,
…
archaic character of the Corinthian form shown in pi. 42.
…
rendering of folds in Corinthian (here implied by
…
in chariot, seen frontally. Inscriptions p. 165, no.
…
Red slip on the panels. Pattern band in panel
…
2 Such ' folds' first appear in Attica in the second
327
-+1431 siren. Very near in style to the last. Berlin 1652,
…
graph in Professor Beazley's possession.
…
entirely different in character from the early
…
101 fig. 14; photographs in the German Institute
…
Pfuhl fig. 178). Tongues inside mouth as in late
…
neck and mouth. A, B, dancers as in the last, but
…
Amasis painter (cf. the neck-amphora in the Cabinet
…
knobs on handles in nos. 1444, 5).
…
1925/6, 124). The vase fired red intentionally in
328
freely used in the main design and for patterns (cf.
…
22, in colours and fairly accurate; Folzer no. 120;
…
p. 136). Handle decoration as in the last. Inscriptions
…
work. The prototype was in the manner of Lydos,
…
rate patterns (cf. nos. 1446, 7); in panel part of
…
(outlined in paint on red ground ?); 2 and 4, black;
…
the right, swan and siren. Not far removed in
329
fig. 55 h, but with volutes below as in fig. 55, 1).
…
palmette as in fig. 55 h, but in b.f. technique. A,
…
Jean 71, fig. 74). H.p. as in the last. A, 1, as in the
…
(cf. fig. 57 e), the side palmettes in b.f. technique.
…
aus den Antikensammlungen in Italien, 87; photo
…
an ancient design. A, 1: chariots galloping to r.; in
…
craters in Corinth, Syracuse, Palermo, the British
…
(fig. 27 e) ; in front of one, an incised protome. A,
…
Furtwangler's mistake (Berl. Vas. 1, 205) in de-
330
frag, with part of [Herakles and] Kyknos in combat;
…
in the manner of the Amphiaraos painter. Inscrip-
…
ornaments, as in fig. 55,1. A, 1: departure of Hector;
…
from Caere (Pottier i, pi. 50). H.p., floral, as in fig.
…
in the second quarter of the sixth century. The new
…
1 Note the unusual relation of breadth to height in no.
…
to Chalcidian; nearer also to Chalcidian in shape than
…
vase in Geneva which seems to be an imitation of the
Catalogue of late protocorinthian, transtional, and corinthian vases / Late cornthian vases II
331
animal-frieze style in vase-painting after the middle
…
our only evidence of figurative painting in this
…
produced in the potteries of Corinth at this time.
…
original ideas. Although reduced in circumstances,
…
tioned in the following list. The second embodies
…
usually applied in an off-hand way, with consider-
…
the type illustrated in fig. 176; others, again, like the
…
the preceding period—either in shape, or decora-
…
The vases in the list which follows are attributed
…
and cinquefoil aryballoi in the late sixth and fifth
…
not found in fifth-century graves.
…
as in fig. 66 b. Chaeroneia 315. Buds as fig. 66 a.
…
(Weicker, Seelenvogel 143, figs. 66,7; id. in Roscher
…
(not in C.V.A. i); photo Giraudon 8011). Birds
332
in C.V.A. Oxford iii, i pi. 48, 18, which are decor-
…
speckled birds which are a favourite motive in the
…
1500 almost identical vase in Palermo) and Thebes, from
…
1500 a attractive than either of these is one in Leyden
…
IN THE FORM OF FEMALE
…
is usual in Corinthian vases;
…
in the late Corinthian man-
…
century, but I think it might be earlier; in any case, it
…
undoubtedly influenced by an Attic type in which
…
II, variant form in which the supports meet beneath
…
in the Berlin Museum (Jahrbuch 1886,153, found with late
333
are rendered in the same style: this pinax belongs to
…
see my remarks in C.V.A. Oxford fasc. ii. Late
…
appear in the last quarter of the sixth century.1
334
to show that this type continued in the late sixth
…
xiv, pi. 9, 1.). Five examples were found in this
…
were mentioned in the catalogue of Transitional
…
In certain cases, cf. fig. 181a (from Antiparos, in
…
the examples in this grave differ from the normal
…
in pattern or shape, and the execution, though it is
…
size?), and over 500 at Troezen (see pp. 185, 8); in
…
in both the cone pattern at the rim points to a sixth-century
335
intrinsic impossibility in the suggestion, and as
…
fig. 12); Naukratis (fragments in Oxford); Cyrene
…
lekythos in tomb 309 at Syracuse.
…
considerably in details; the style is peculiar, with cer-
…
in graves from 550B. c,
…
There are many minor variations in patterns. The
…
could not be shown in the drawing. Delos (Dugas
…
vertical and horizontal, as in some Attic cups.
Appendix I
339
close to that shown in pi. 28, 11-12 (both details
…
of the type shown in fig. 9 c: cf. no. 191 and p. 23).
340
head in Berlin mentioned on p. 176, and heads
…
curious pelike in Berlin (3984, Miiller, Polos, pi.
…
II. A. Fairbanks, Catalogue of the Greek and Etruscan Vases in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.
…
are sometimes such that it is impossible to form a clear idea of the nature of the object portrayed. In some
…
in the Annual of the British School in the near
…
PI. 37, 346. 6: Attic, apparently early in the sixth
…
ornament in the top row occurs on a Corinthian ary-
…
queried in the text.
341
vases in the Louvre. I must therefore confine myself to exceedingly brief notes.
…
mentioned in the catalogue), except nos. 4-6, which
…
IV. H. Payne, C.V.A. Oxford, fasc. 2. The references in Necrocorinthia to the Oxford vases are given in
…
lekanis of the type no. 1529, and Attic vases. This type in question.
…
PI. 5, Corinthian neck-amphora, no. 1438. and, as I have done in ch. xiii, argues that it is Attic.
342
however, would seem to lie in the connexion with the On p. 14 (no. 10) the author of the above-men-
…
and bull in black polychrome technique. Evidently viii, 1930), mentioned in the Preface,
…
XII. The pyxis from Sparta mentioned on p. 5, note 1, is now published in B.S.A. 1926-7, pi. 6. I have
…
12, vii, 3 is Cretan in type, at any rate (cf. B.S.A. rather unusual Rhodian imitation; 74, geometric
…
Too late for inclusion in this book I received photographs from Mr. Albert Gallatin of a very curious and
…
In connection with the acrobat seen in fig. 42, it may be mentioned that an aryballos with two acrobats
343
in the third quarter of the sixth century for this
…
in the work of this artist.
…
type seen in the Thermon metope, fig. 23 D. The
…
ing Corinthian examples, is strongly Corinthian in
…
The oinochoe from Corinth published in pi. 45,1-2,6 is now published by Miss Lamb, Greek and Roman
…
The architectural terracottas from Corinth are now published by Mrs. Hill in Corinth vol. iv, pt. 1. I have
…
Corinth in the early period. The earlier examples from the Acropolis are strongly Corinthian in style.
Outline of the chronology of the early attic black-figure style
Appendix II
345
that it is perhaps worth while to suggest a chronological scheme of early black-figure painting in
…
amphora cannot be later than 550 b.C. In this connexion it is worth recalling that the early date
…
in placing the Francois vase early in the sixties, and the fragments of later Klitian style in the latter
…
2 F.R. iii, pis. in, 133; Pfuhl figs. 313-14; Langlotz,
…
clearly earlier than that of the Andokides vase in the
…
stages in the history of the amphora in the second half of
…
the use of red in the pattern above the panel; this is a
…
before this system of renderings was evolved. In general
346
series of vases to be placed is one which includes the comast group discussed in Ch. XIII, and the
…
vases has been stressed in Ch. XIII; enough here to recall that the earliest of the comast vases are a
…
developed in shape than amphorae which have been attributed to the early sixth century,5 and shows
…
style of the sixth century never achieved; this is of course most clearly apparent in such works as
…
the Acropolis fragments in the manner of Klitias are
…
Hoppin p. 164, the amphora in Florence, Pfuhl fig. 211,
…
4 In style and in technique the gorgon dinos is con-
…
5 Cf. Langlotz's dates for the amphorae illustrated in
Appendix III
348
kind of objects the Romans discovered in these graves.
…
nothing in the text to prevent this identification—though it is surely difficult to imagine that
…
materials than metal. This is proved by some of Martial's epigrams, in which vases of clay and
…
below, reach more picturesque results—'works in pottery
…
suggests that the cemetery in which these graves lay was
…
painted Corinthian vases); Pottier in D.-S. i, 2, 1508,
…
Hauptstatten des Gewerbefleisses in Kl. Alterthume 18,
349
material discussed in this book.
…
truth. Butades was further credited with having invented antefixes in the form of human heads,
…
Above all, it must be admitted that the picture of the early figure-style given in Ch. VIII does not
…
and described as an artist who used but one colour and drew in outline, shows both that there are
…
Bronze. We hear in literature of only one archaic Corinthian bronze, the palm-tree, with frogs
…
have been late, seen by Wieseler in a private collection at
…
7 In the 'Nymphaeum'; Athenagoras, probably draw-
350
one would greatly like to be able to visualize, was the only surviving votive in the Corinthian
…
been Corinthian in the ordinary sense of the term. The earliest 'Corinthian bronze' proper of which
…
bronze' of some kind was made in the Roman period.8 And it is further probable, to say the least,
…
which are found in graves in Greece would rarely have reached the fabulous prices paid by the
…
op. cit. 36 ff.; Pottier in D.-S. s.v. Corinthium Aes.
…
bronzes in the Roman conquest. Pliny indeed adopts an
…
(see next footnote) in order to deny that any so-called
…
Iud. v, 201: Corinthian bronze used in Herod's temple;
…
fortuitous mixture of metals, which took place in the sack
…
four silver vessels, dedicated by Croesus and placed in
Addenda
352
I have omitted to mention that nonsense inscriptions (which I have mentioned in other cases) occur
…
PI. 50 was inserted into the series when the corresponding text was already in page-proof; I was
…
motive, as in the curiously unleonine conception of
…
striking that in more than one instance they are not
…
is in Boston (Festschrift James Loeb, 88-9 figs. 7-
…
larity in style, and particularly in the rendering of
References to the illustrations and notes
354
examples without great difficulty. The plates contain, in the first place, photographs of Proto-
…
to prevent the possibility of confusion with Corinthian vases. Drawings have been placed in the text
…
black, incised, mane; the other figures, 18 a-e, are done entirely in black-figure technique. The horses
…
be reproduced directly in collotype (as is done, for example, in pi. 6); but though the ink copies of
…
1 In pi. z cross-hatching is used to indicate pink; these irregularities are all mentioned in the text or in the
355
106 n. 4, 108, in, 230
…
76, 236 n. 1; in 21 a the chest-stripe and the
…
(contrast the publication in Ant. Denk.)
…
ted; see the publication in Mon. Ant. 70
Index
Maßstab/Farbkeil
THE CORINTHIAN FIGURE STYLE 95
will be added to this series: a fragmentary alabastron decorated with a battle
scene in the same manner as the vases which have just been described.1
The peculiarity of these polychrome vases is that their decoration is
planned from the outset in three colours: brown (inclining either to yellow or
to grey) for flesh, with red and black for the remaining surfaces. The same
colours are found on orientalizing vases, for instance, in pi. 5, but here the
usage is different: red and yellow are simply enhancements, employed to
alleviate the monotony of the silhouette. In the polychrome vases of which we
are speaking, there is no basis of black:2 equal emphasis is laid on all the
colours that are used. The Chigi vase (no. 39) is the most perfect example of
this technique.
Fig. 29. a-b, Protocorinthian; c, Corinthian, a, from the aryballos pi. i, 8-n (enlarged);
b, from no. 39; c, from no. 482.
The origin of this complex polychrome style has often been sought in de-
scriptions of inlaid metal work such as the shields of Achilles and of Herakles,
and the inlaid dagger-blades of the late Minoan period have been quoted as
examples of the kind of models which must have inspired the painters of the
'style magnifique'. The arguments which have been brought forward to
support this view3 are obviously weakened by the absence of any contem-
porary metal work of the kind which this hypothesis requires. Metal workers
in the seventh century had two techniques for executing figurative decoration
—embossing and engraving—and the former at least was still in a very primitive
stage of development at the time of which we are speaking. Apart from the
practice of inlaying the eyes of statues, the only traces of archaic Greek inlaid
metal work appear to be some fragments found at Olympia,4 and a few odds
1 It is peculiar, however, in that the figures are
arranged, in oriental fashion, at different levels in
the field, and not in horizontal bands; compare the
bronze relief, Annali 1852 pis. H-I (Furtwangler,
Kl. Schriften i, pi. 14, 3 and 4), and Nikosthenic
cups such as Hoppin B.F. V. 182-5.
2 Either metaphorically, or literally; for the brown
or yellow is always placed directly on the clay.
3 Cf. especially Johansen, 160; Furtwangler Kleine
Schriften ii, 106; Studniczka, Schild des Herakles, 54.
4 Olympia, iv, 848, 925, quoted by Studniczka,
op. cit.
will be added to this series: a fragmentary alabastron decorated with a battle
scene in the same manner as the vases which have just been described.1
The peculiarity of these polychrome vases is that their decoration is
planned from the outset in three colours: brown (inclining either to yellow or
to grey) for flesh, with red and black for the remaining surfaces. The same
colours are found on orientalizing vases, for instance, in pi. 5, but here the
usage is different: red and yellow are simply enhancements, employed to
alleviate the monotony of the silhouette. In the polychrome vases of which we
are speaking, there is no basis of black:2 equal emphasis is laid on all the
colours that are used. The Chigi vase (no. 39) is the most perfect example of
this technique.
Fig. 29. a-b, Protocorinthian; c, Corinthian, a, from the aryballos pi. i, 8-n (enlarged);
b, from no. 39; c, from no. 482.
The origin of this complex polychrome style has often been sought in de-
scriptions of inlaid metal work such as the shields of Achilles and of Herakles,
and the inlaid dagger-blades of the late Minoan period have been quoted as
examples of the kind of models which must have inspired the painters of the
'style magnifique'. The arguments which have been brought forward to
support this view3 are obviously weakened by the absence of any contem-
porary metal work of the kind which this hypothesis requires. Metal workers
in the seventh century had two techniques for executing figurative decoration
—embossing and engraving—and the former at least was still in a very primitive
stage of development at the time of which we are speaking. Apart from the
practice of inlaying the eyes of statues, the only traces of archaic Greek inlaid
metal work appear to be some fragments found at Olympia,4 and a few odds
1 It is peculiar, however, in that the figures are
arranged, in oriental fashion, at different levels in
the field, and not in horizontal bands; compare the
bronze relief, Annali 1852 pis. H-I (Furtwangler,
Kl. Schriften i, pi. 14, 3 and 4), and Nikosthenic
cups such as Hoppin B.F. V. 182-5.
2 Either metaphorically, or literally; for the brown
or yellow is always placed directly on the clay.
3 Cf. especially Johansen, 160; Furtwangler Kleine
Schriften ii, 106; Studniczka, Schild des Herakles, 54.
4 Olympia, iv, 848, 925, quoted by Studniczka,
op. cit.