Trull, William: Raphael vindicated: by a comparison between the original tapestries (now in London) of Leo X. and the cartoons at Hampton Court, as repaired by Cooke : with brief historical and artistical remarks upon the whole series (London: Thomas Hookham, 1840)

45

it is perfectly clear and distinct; and the engravings have so
copied it: now it is equally clear in the Tapestry, but a male
figure ! Doubtless, a grand mistake, yet easily made on
patching over faint indications of a figure, covered with ample
drapery.
In the Cartoon will be observed two crutches on the fore
ground, which the cripple is supposed to have thrown down;
this is just enough to carry out the subject, in the meager and
ineffective manner of Cooke; so unworthy of that splendid
Asiatic grandeur that Raphael has thrown into all the costume
and details of these works; and so correctly, that those best
acquainted with that country have critically gone over the
nine Tapestries in astonishment, at the minute accuracy in the
representation of manners, and customs, even as followed in
Asia at the present time.
To the crutches Raphael added a knee-cap and wooden leg,
with belt, straps, &c.; thus drawing the beholder deeper to
the essence of the subject, besides giving greater beauty and
importance to the fore-ground.
Other remarks might be made in regard to inaccuracies
about the buildings at Lystra, but it may be unnecessary after
so much having been said, on other and more important parts
of the subject; and quite enough, one would imagine, to
assist in drawing a just inference, of the real merits of the
Tapestry.