Cook, Arthur B.
Zeus: a study in ancient religion (Band 2,1): Zeus god of the dark sky (thunder and lightning): Text and notes
— Cambridge, 1925
Cite this page
Please cite this page by using the following URL/DOI:
https://doi.org/10.11588/diglit.14696#0505
DOI Page / Citation link:
https://doi.org/10.11588/diglit.14696#0505
Abbreviations
Chapter II: Zeus as god of the weather / § 1: Zeus lightens, thunders, rains, etc.
Chapter II: Zeus as god of the weather / § 2: The Diosemía or “Zeus-sign”
Chapter II: Zeus as god of the weather / § 3: Zeus and the lightning / (a): Lightning as a flame from the burning sky / I: Zeus Keraunós
Chapter II: Zeus as god of the weather / § 3: Zeus and the lightning / (a): Lightning as a flame from the burning sky / II: Zeus Kataibátes
Chapter II: Zeus as god of the weather / § 3: Zeus and the lightning / (a): Lightning as a flame from the burning sky / III: Zeus und the Sky-Pillar
102
see further Overbeck Gr. Kunstmyth. Zeus pp. 263—266, Miiller—Wieseler—Wernicke
…
1—20 figs. 1—4. See further an interesting chapter in F. Cumont Etudes Syriennes Paris
106
Sculpture from Augustus to Constanline London 1907 pp. 166—213 pis. 51—62. Further
…
in the case of the Trajanic column. See further Mrs A. Strong Roman Sculpture from
…
Croisades. Historiens grecs. Paris 1875 >■ 618 A—C, 661 c). See further F. W. Unger
129
other parts of the Mediterranean world—to go no further afield3—
…
p. 129 b See further Lobeck Aglaophamus ii. 934, G. Kroll De oraeulis Chaldaicis
143
may venture a step further and identify this
…
feathered coiffure see further Sir A. J. Evans Scripta Minoa Oxford 1909 i. 24^ figs.
147
fifth region8, adds further points of interest. In the centre of a
…
Mitth. 1890 v. 264 f. See further L. Stephani Nimbus und Strahlenkranz St Petersburg
160
And here, at the risk of faring worse, we must go further. For
…
the Arch. Zeit. 1866 xxiv. 182 f., id. Wandgem. Camp. p. 274 no. 1279. See further
167
would merit further investigation1. Our concern is now with the
…
further that within the limits of Greece a variety of towns claimed
174
the southern rather than the northern wall of the temple3. Further,
…
temporaine du temple, du moins bien anterieure a notre ere.' See further Courby in the
178
with the same signification3. Further, Apollon's 'lofty pillar' was
…
1167 f.), but also from the cosmic decoration of its roof {ib. ii46ff.: see further R. Eisler
187
three goats grazing, and a number of votive offerings. See further H. Heydemann in the
…
TLvduvos. See further T. Schreiber Apollon Pythoktonos Leipzig 1879 pp. 6 n. 27, 44,
206
Hoppin Red-fig. Vases i. 66 no. 51, supra i. 335). As to the further interpretation of the
…
reading lots {Class. Quart. 1916 x. 235). See further E. Gerhard Das Orakel der Themis
223
persons went further and frankly spoke of Pythagoras as Apollon
…
nonsense, to be dismissed without further enquiry. But there is
Chapter II: Zeus as god of the weather / § 3: Zeus and the lightning / (a): Lightning as a flame from the burning sky / IV: Zeus und Dionysos
270
Bessoi see further E. Oberhummer in Pauly—Wissowa Real-Enc. iii. 329 ft".
…
further J. H. Mordtmann loc. cit., P. Perdrizet ' Relief du pays des Maedes representant
291
See further Immerwahr Kult. Myth. Arkad. p. 26 f., O. Jessen in Pauly — Wissowa Real-
…
Work in Class. Stud, igoj p. 62 f. is too cautious to accept. I have discussed it further
Chapter II: Zeus as god of the weather / § 3: Zeus and the lightning / (a): Lightning as a flame from the burning sky / V: The double Zeus
349
2 Supra i. 468 n. 8, 635. See further G. F. Hill in the Journ. Hell. Stud. 1916 xxxvi.
…
17 See further F. Imhoof-Blumer in the Journ. Intern. d'Arch. Num. 1898 i. 26, 28 ff.
…
116 c5 Trdjj.ij.eya ZeO). See further G. A. Gerhard ' Der Tod des grossen Pan' in the
Chapter II: Zeus as god of the weather / § 3: Zeus and the lightning / (a): Lightning as a flame from the burning sky / VI: Zeus and the twins
436
divinity. Further, the kings claimed descent from the twin sons of
…
8 Hdt. 5. 75. See further Frazer Golden Bough3: The Magic Art i. 48 ff., who urges
464
They were further connected with Dionysos, Silenos, the Satyrs, etc."
…
Strab. 307. See further F. Olck in Pauly—Wissowa Real-Enc. vi. 631 f., 654.
Chapter II: Zeus as god of the weather / § 3: Zeus and the lightning / (b): Lightening as a flash from an eye
Chapter II: Zeus as god of the weather / § 3: Zeus and the lightning / (c): Lightning as a weapon
516
above are the weapons of the sky-god. Further than that we cannot
…
ment. For further discussion see F. M. f. Lagrange 'La Crete ancienne' in the Revue
517
a bordered robe covers him from neck to knee. Further to the right
…
Od. 3. 444. See further Stephanus Thes. Gr. Ling. i. 2. 133 C—D, G. Meyer Griechische
519
and the passages cited in the Thes. Ling. Lat. iv. 1079, 31 ^- See further D'Arcy W.
…
a telephany of the sky-god himself (supra p. 187). See further O. Keller ' Rabe und
543
these handles by a reference to 'Minoan' cult appears further from
…
'Minoan' style. Further, the 'hour-glass' ornament, so characteristic
547
curius and Rosmerta (?) [supra i. 481 n. 9: see further S. Reinach ' Teutates, Esus,
…
and cakes (Paus. 9. 40. 11 f. : supra i. 406. See further Folk-Lore 1904 xv. 371 f.).
570
kekaumene1. Further, the epithet of Apollon Bozenos appears to
…
aefiovai Ala, dya\p.a 5e Aids KeXtikov v^yXri dpvs (see further Class. Rev. 1904 xviii.
…
1 Hierokles avveKdri/ios p. 671, 1 Wesseling, p. 21 Burckhardt. See further B. V. Head
572
But what of his further statement that Arselis transferred
…
Hellenica London 1856 Kings and Dynasts p. 20, Head Hist, num.2 p. 622. See further
617
must some day be completed, will accumulate further evidence of an
…
further W. Ruge in Pauly—Wissowa Real-Enc. vii. 1132.
641
ing Eyes4.' Further reflexion has,
…
Further bibliography in W. Helbig Fiihrer durch
…
2. 892 (fulmina codd. R. Bentley cj. culmind). See further T. H. Martin La foudre
680
his exploit3. Further, he bore the image of Artemis done up in a
…
.. ,'£lplwv(os tpyov) on the strength of Diod. 4. 85. See further J. Alberti and M. Schmidt
696
Further than this we cannot trace it. But C. Trieber in his important article 'Die Idee
…
name is similar to HIkos.' Prof. Langdon further informs me that 'The Assyrians and
715
name of the Phoenician Hephaistos, whom he further identifies
…
be spelled6), and a further assumption that either of them was ever
…
ecrefidaOrjaav • Kakeiadai Se ainbv Kai Aia MetXix'c. See further F. C. Movers Unter-
Chapter II: Zeus as god of the weather / § 4: Zeus and the thunder
Chapter II: Zeus as god of the weather / Retrospect
434 Twins as Children of the Sky
Finally, Eustathios in the second half of the twelfth century includes
this notion along with others in his commentary on the Homeric
couplet1. It would seem, then, that Greek speculation from Hellen-
istic to Byzantine times sought to identify the sons of Zeus with
the two segments of the animate Sky. T. H. Martin2 has plausibly
conjectured that this is why the Pythagoreans regarded semicircles
as sacred to the Dioskouroi3.
(7) Twins as Children of the Sky.
I would dwell for a moment on some aspects of this mytho-
logical development. In the first place, it solves without more ado
an otherwise baffling problem with regard to twins in general.
Sir James Frazer, in his survey of superstitions as to twins in Africa,
remarks concerning the Baronga of Delagoa Bay : ' They bestow
the name of Tilo—that is, the sky—on a woman who has given
birth to twins, and the infants themselves are called the children of
the sky4.' He adds in a footnote: 'The reason for calling twins
" Children of the Sky " is obscure. Are they supposed in some
mysterious way to stand for the sun and moon5?' Dr Rendel
Harris, who has contributed so much to the study of twins6, carries
the enquiry a stage further by pointing out ' that we have here
among the Baronga the exact equivalent of the Greek ' Dioskouroi'.
But if that be so, there is no need to prolong discussion. The
1 Eustath. in Od. p. 1686, 33 ff. erepoi Se ov rrdvv iridav&s voovvTes to eTepy)p.epov itri
tov tov fiev rrjSe ffiv rfj rjp.epa il>? tov erepov ev veKpots ovtos, tji Se eripa tov Xolttov los
darepov TeOveuiTos, eis ra Svo /car' ovpavbv ~r]pua<paipia tovs AtocrKovpovs virovoovaiv, wv
darepov p.ev virep yrjs dei eari, darepov Se vrrb yrjv. orrep dvaTpewcov 6 Trapa/3dTrjs (prjaiv
us ovk e%et Xbyov eiprjffOat Aioanovpovs Trap 'Op,rjpu> ra Svo t)p.ia<paipia tov rravros. k.t.X.
(the reference is to Ioul. or. 4. 147 B cited supra p. 433 n. 4). Cp. Eustath. in II. p. 410,
18 ff. ore Se oi AioaKovpoi /cat els to, Svo rj/xicrcpaipia rod iravTos evorjdrjaav, /cat eis tovs
TpoiriKovs Se paXtara kvkXovs, 6 Trapa/3dT7}s 'lovXiavbs 'iypa^ev, ws SyjXovTai /cat ev tois eis
tt)v OSvaaeiav.
2 T. H. Martin La foudre I'electricite et le magnitisme chez les anciens Paris 1866
p. 297 f.
3 Damask, quaest. de pritnis principiis 261 (ii. 127, 7 ff. Ruelle) 5ta rt yap tu> p-ev tov
kvkXov dviepovv oi Wvdaybpeioi, tlS Se Tpiyuvov, rep Se rerpdyuivov, rip oe aXXo /cat aXXo twv
evdvypi/MpLiov tlov (Tx^/iaTWf, los Se /cat /mktusv, ojs t<x i}/LiiKVK\ta toIs AiocrKovpois; k.t.X.
A different view is cited by Iambi, v. Pyth. 155 awevSeiv Se rrpb rpaTrifys TrapanaXei
Albs ^.urrjpos /cat 'HpaxXeovs /cat Atotrkovptov, tt/s Tpocpfjs vfxvovvTas tov apx^ybv tcai tov
ravTrjs i)yep.bva Ata, /cat tov 'Hpa/cXea ttjv 8vvap.1v tt)s (pvcrews, Kai tovs Aioo~Kovpovs ttjv
crvpLcpcoviav tQv drravTivv. On this see A. Delatte Etudes sur la literature pytkagoricienne
Paris 1915 p. 115 f.
4 Frazer Golden Bough%: The Magic Art i. 267 f., citing H. A. Junod Les Ba-ronga
{Bulletin de la society neuchdteloise de geographie x) Neuchatel 1898 pp. 412, 416 ff.
5 Frazer Golden Bough3 : The Magic Art i. 268 n. 1.
6 Supra i. 760 n. 7.
7 J. Rendel Harris The Cult of the Heavenly Twins Cambridge 1906 p. 26.
Finally, Eustathios in the second half of the twelfth century includes
this notion along with others in his commentary on the Homeric
couplet1. It would seem, then, that Greek speculation from Hellen-
istic to Byzantine times sought to identify the sons of Zeus with
the two segments of the animate Sky. T. H. Martin2 has plausibly
conjectured that this is why the Pythagoreans regarded semicircles
as sacred to the Dioskouroi3.
(7) Twins as Children of the Sky.
I would dwell for a moment on some aspects of this mytho-
logical development. In the first place, it solves without more ado
an otherwise baffling problem with regard to twins in general.
Sir James Frazer, in his survey of superstitions as to twins in Africa,
remarks concerning the Baronga of Delagoa Bay : ' They bestow
the name of Tilo—that is, the sky—on a woman who has given
birth to twins, and the infants themselves are called the children of
the sky4.' He adds in a footnote: 'The reason for calling twins
" Children of the Sky " is obscure. Are they supposed in some
mysterious way to stand for the sun and moon5?' Dr Rendel
Harris, who has contributed so much to the study of twins6, carries
the enquiry a stage further by pointing out ' that we have here
among the Baronga the exact equivalent of the Greek ' Dioskouroi'.
But if that be so, there is no need to prolong discussion. The
1 Eustath. in Od. p. 1686, 33 ff. erepoi Se ov rrdvv iridav&s voovvTes to eTepy)p.epov itri
tov tov fiev rrjSe ffiv rfj rjp.epa il>? tov erepov ev veKpots ovtos, tji Se eripa tov Xolttov los
darepov TeOveuiTos, eis ra Svo /car' ovpavbv ~r]pua<paipia tovs AtocrKovpovs virovoovaiv, wv
darepov p.ev virep yrjs dei eari, darepov Se vrrb yrjv. orrep dvaTpewcov 6 Trapa/3dTrjs (prjaiv
us ovk e%et Xbyov eiprjffOat Aioanovpovs Trap 'Op,rjpu> ra Svo t)p.ia<paipia tov rravros. k.t.X.
(the reference is to Ioul. or. 4. 147 B cited supra p. 433 n. 4). Cp. Eustath. in II. p. 410,
18 ff. ore Se oi AioaKovpoi /cat els to, Svo rj/xicrcpaipia rod iravTos evorjdrjaav, /cat eis tovs
TpoiriKovs Se paXtara kvkXovs, 6 Trapa/3dT7}s 'lovXiavbs 'iypa^ev, ws SyjXovTai /cat ev tois eis
tt)v OSvaaeiav.
2 T. H. Martin La foudre I'electricite et le magnitisme chez les anciens Paris 1866
p. 297 f.
3 Damask, quaest. de pritnis principiis 261 (ii. 127, 7 ff. Ruelle) 5ta rt yap tu> p-ev tov
kvkXov dviepovv oi Wvdaybpeioi, tlS Se Tpiyuvov, rep Se rerpdyuivov, rip oe aXXo /cat aXXo twv
evdvypi/MpLiov tlov (Tx^/iaTWf, los Se /cat /mktusv, ojs t<x i}/LiiKVK\ta toIs AiocrKovpois; k.t.X.
A different view is cited by Iambi, v. Pyth. 155 awevSeiv Se rrpb rpaTrifys TrapanaXei
Albs ^.urrjpos /cat 'HpaxXeovs /cat Atotrkovptov, tt/s Tpocpfjs vfxvovvTas tov apx^ybv tcai tov
ravTrjs i)yep.bva Ata, /cat tov 'Hpa/cXea ttjv 8vvap.1v tt)s (pvcrews, Kai tovs Aioo~Kovpovs ttjv
crvpLcpcoviav tQv drravTivv. On this see A. Delatte Etudes sur la literature pytkagoricienne
Paris 1915 p. 115 f.
4 Frazer Golden Bough%: The Magic Art i. 267 f., citing H. A. Junod Les Ba-ronga
{Bulletin de la society neuchdteloise de geographie x) Neuchatel 1898 pp. 412, 416 ff.
5 Frazer Golden Bough3 : The Magic Art i. 268 n. 1.
6 Supra i. 760 n. 7.
7 J. Rendel Harris The Cult of the Heavenly Twins Cambridge 1906 p. 26.