Passavant, Johann David: Raphael of Urbino and his father Giovanni Santi (London , New York: MacMillan and Co., 1872)

fault/ in tire otirerrvise §006 rvorics of Oari lileinr. von ffeinecicen, "i>faclr-
ricirten von Ltinstiern un6 Lunstsaclren/' I^eipr.i§, 1769, 2 vols. in 8vo.;
of I^ancion, "Vie et duvres 6e R.apiraei," ?aris, 1805-9, 8 vols. in 4to.;
an6 of tire Lount von I^epei, " LataioZue 6es Ustampes Aravess 6'apres
R.afaei," t>/ lauriscus Ifuiroeus, Vranirfort-on-tlre-iVlaine, 1819, in 8vo.
Virese rvriters attribute to Itaplraei man/ rvorics rviricir are not Iris;
I^epei fre^usntl/ confuses into one article several different suir^ects, or
else, ire 6ivi6es one subject into several articles.
I^a6 tire rvoric of 2ani, "iilnciciope6ia nreto6ica critico-raZionata
6eiie Leiie T^rti," karnra, 1820, been ternr!nate6, it rvoui6 Irave contained,
periraps, tire nrost exact information on tire en§ravin§s from R.apiraei.
Lut, except in some rare exceptions, rviricir rve siraii taice care to
mention, our statements ail rest on tire results of our orvn examinations.
W Irave enumerated tire secon6-ciass enZravinZs as rvsii as tire rest,
exciu6inZ, Irorvever, tire rvorst productions of our orvn time.

?rLiricfort on tire Mnine.